Blog

Alcoholism at Oxford University: A Perspective

0

I can still remember the first time I got drunk. I was around 13 years old. A friend had stolen some of his dad’s whisky, and we got through half a bottle together. The experience wasn’t particularly extraordinary, apart from one thing: even then I was astonished, terrified, by just how much I enjoyed being drunk. The rush, the feeling of the alcohol coursing through my veins, the way it made my worries and anxieties dissipate for a few blissful hours. I subconsciously realised something that, years later, I would spend countless hours grappling with; whatever joys I could experience sober, they would be even better with a bottle in hand.

The next few years went by relatively normally. The lack of independence borne from still living at home meant my alcohol use was kept in check. All that happened was that every week or two when me and my friends were out drinking, I’d always end up getting absolutely shitfaced –  far more than anyone else.

Then I arrived at Oxford University. It only took a few weeks for my alcohol use to absolutely soar. I was 18 at this point, and without my parents breathing down my back, I was free to drink as much as I pleased. In the Michaelmas and Hilary just gone, I drank an average of around 100 to 150 units a week. I drank virtually every day – and I mean drank, enough that almost every night ended with me stumbling up the stairs to my accommodation and collapsing in bed, drunk out of my mind. I spent well over a thousand pounds on alcohol, leaving less than half of my money for other expenses.

There are probably very few environments worse for would-be alcoholics than Oxford University. The atmosphere of constant stress, the omnipresent ‘work hard, play hard’ undertone, the fact that almost every society runs countless boozy events, combined with virtually every college having a cheap and accessible bar, meant that I stood little chance. It’s true that, regardless of where I went, alcohol problems would have probably arisen. Of the three factors often leading to alcoholism – a family history of alcohol abuse, beginning drinking at a young age, and past mental health problems – I tick every one.

But Oxford undoubtedly exacerbated my issues. It doesn’t have much of a drug culture (in my experience, at least), but it has one hell of a drinking culture. Very few people seemed to notice how out of hand my drinking was getting. In a society where getting drunk regularly is a common occurrence, it’s hard to differentiate between someone who likes to drink and someone who needs to drink. When I finally began the long and painful process of seeking sobriety, the lack of support provided by the university was shocking. My addiction advisor suggested I  seek out alcoholic support groups within the University. As far as I can tell, no such group presently exists.

The solution isn’t, however, some sort of puritanical clamp down on drinking among students. The vast majority of you reading this article will be perfectly capable of drinking healthily and in moderation – and I am deeply envious of you. College bars and drinking events provide most with a hugely enjoyable social space. Some alcohol free alternatives would be nice, but that’s all. Instead, the University needs to do more to assist those students who are struggling; and we all need to be more ready to look out for the warning signs of alcohol dependency. There’s nothing wrong with wanting to drink; but when we start noticing that ourselves, or others, need to drink, alarm bells should be raised.

The writing of this article marks the two month anniversary of my sobriety. These past few weeks have been tough, much tougher than I could have ever expected. But they’ve also been incredibly rewarding. Getting over an addiction requires a complete life reset; it requires reconnecting with the friends and passions that you lost to booze. The constant urge to drink still hasn’t left me, if it ever will. Knowing that you can’t under any circumstances do the thing you want to do more than anything else is torture. But finally, for the first time in many months, I’m able to appreciate the beauty of our world, the simple joys of friendship, without the distorting lens of the bottle – and that makes it all worth it.

But if there’s one piece of advice I want anyone who relates to this article to take to heart, it’s this: don’t go cold turkey. Alcohol is one of the few drugs whose withdrawal can be fatal. For me, it was so bad that I was rushed to the John Radcliffe emergency unit, suffering from delirium tremens – a condition arising from alcohol withdrawal with symptoms like tremors, delirium, hallucinations, and even seizures which could potentially lead to death. Talk to your doctor, or any other NHS resources, so you can withdraw with the help of medications to protect you.

Drinking in moderation can be great fun, but if you notice yourself or anyone else unable to put down the bottle, becoming dependent on alcohol to get through the day, it’s time to take a break. And if that’s too hard, speak to a pastoral adviser or counsellor. Alcohol nearly ruined my life. For many years to come, I think, I’ll still be grappling with its consequences. I don’t want it to ruin yours.

‘Personal imprint’: an interview with the founder of Tree Artisan Café

0

During exams, my friends and I formed a study group. While it took us three years to realise that studying might be important even for a History degree, the dread for our upcoming exams eventually sunk in. Amidst the panicked conversations about misogynistic late-Roman chroniclers (looking at you, Procopius) were the study breaks at some point in the day to visit a café. A European-style working day with a long lunch break was essential to feeling like a real humanities student, and spending on coffee or cake proved to be an excellent means of coping with exam stress.

Now that exams are long gone, I have found time to consider what I could write about that would allow me to reflect on my experience of Oxford as a city, and I was torn between pubs and cafés. However, having been teetotal for the first year of my degree, in lockdown for the second and a finalist for my third, my pubbing credentials are well below par. Being a sugar-addict, however, my café CV is brimming with relevant experience, and I felt the need to pay some kind of tribute to the coffee shop scene here.

Bored witless by the Law Library, I applied for a loyalty card at the adjacent coffee shop, Missing Bean, and I also occasionally resorted to the suspiciously cheap coffee in college, where the exciting catch is that the oat milk is off and the coffee tastes burnt. As Exeter’s Cohen Quad is in Jericho, Tree Artisan, located on Little Clarendon Street, became our most-visited café. To find out what coffee shop life is like in Oxford from the point of view of the owners, I decided to interview Tree Artisan’s founder and owner, Graziella Ascensao.

Tree Artisan Café now feels like a fixture of the Oxford coffee scene, but it faced challenges from the very start. Graziella moved to Oxford from Brazil at 18, and later worked in the service sector, as both a barista and a waitress, and began to save up until she could afford to open her own café. It seemed as if fate had conspired against her when the COVID-19 pandemic hit as soon as she had secured the lease for the premises.

However, consistent with the rest of her attitude connected to her work, Graziella approached the challenge with a positive mindset and turned it into an opportunity. ‘At that time, I saw it was the time to open,’ she says. ‘When people were in front of their computer all day, they wanted to pick up a coffee and go to the park’. While, due to COVID-19 restrictions, she found it harder to cultivate the atmosphere she wanted within the physical space, she managed to generate a small community of regular customers who appreciated the friendliness and good coffee on offer. ‘I found positivity in that. I am always trying to be a warm person’.

This attitude is Graziella’s main take on the difference between the culture of chain cafés and that of independent ones. She takes pride in buying everything from independent suppliers, from bread to coffee beans, not wanting to compromise the culture of a small local enterprise. ‘There is more love, more passion. With chains, whoever you are, you are a number. The staff are a number, the customers are a number, everybody is a number. It is completely different to when you have a focus on the people’.

This focus is arguably what makes Tree Artisan Café unique. After exams, my friend and I worked there one afternoon, while the café was quiet. As we worked, we noticed that the staff recognised and talked to almost every customer who walked through the door. For a generation that appreciates the personal experience afforded by food vendors, this kind of human interaction sets Tree Artisan Café apart from chain cafés, where the staff often seem stressed and keen to hurry along to the next customer. The feeling that you’re part of a community is a huge appeal, and one that makes sitting in Tree Artisan much more appealing than, for example, sitting in Café Nero.

While the independent café market in Oxford is crowded and competitive, Graziella does not feel this is a hostile environment, and rather sees a market where independent outlets do not have to try and beat each other down to stay in business. ‘Honestly, I respect all of them, because I believe in this world there is space for all of them. Tree Artisan has my biometric, it is different from all the others. It is my personal imprint on them. It is like my baby. I am not comparing to others; I love it because it is mine’.

This ‘personal imprint’ is a huge part of independent coffee outlets in Oxford, and Graziella’s experiences definitely shape how Tree Artisan operates. Having been vegan for three years, she ensures there are multiple dairy-free, gluten-free and vegan options on the menu. As a lifelong member of the allergy club myself, it is welcome to have actual choices, especially when they’re genuinely delicious and likely to even be bought by someone who isn’t allergic to the other options. The menu is also rotated regularly, according to which options prove most popular, which allows Tree Artisan to be customer-driven, rather than constantly supplying the same, bulk-bought generic options available at a chain.

Graziella’s enthusiasm talking about running her own café is infectious. ‘It is hard work,’ she tells me at the end of our interview. ‘I’m here at 4:30 in the morning every day, and I have gratitude to be here. It is my passion, I am happy to be here’. It is this highly personal desire to create a positive experience for every customer that sets Oxford’s independent outlets apart from their corporate competition, and Tree Artisan Café is the perfect example of this alternative, people-focused approach to growing as a café in Oxford.

Image credit: Emily Perkins.

What are Conservative Party Members thinking?

0

Friday 2nd September is creeping ever closer and with a government that seems to be set on inaction until then in the midst of the biggest cost of living crisis in decades, for millions it can’t come soon enough.  Before then though, 0.3% of the population will decide who the next Prime Minister is and all signs now seem to suggest that that person will be Liz Truss. 

Personally, I see it as a tragedy on several levels but, above all, I cannot cease to be totally baffled by the polls that show Truss will win by such a landslide.  Not only is it now with seeming daily regularity that a new independent report, financial expert, or ‘Tory grandee’ points out her economic plans are both unfundable and inadequate.  More than anything, the Conservative Party Members seem set to condemn themselves to losing the next election by electing a leader and resulting cabinet that is beyond impalpable for the general population.

I suppose the first step in trying to get inside the mind of Tory members is understanding who they really are, something that is notoriously difficult and explains why opinion polls in leadership contests vary so much in comparison with those of general elections.  Although the information is not officially published, Tim Bale, professor of politics at Queen Mary University, concluded nearly ten years of study on this and told the FT last month that “There hasn’t been much change in the demographics of the Tory grassroots since we began our research on party members back in 2013.”  The research found that, rather unsurprisingly, that members are disproportionately older men.  63% were male (compared to roughly half of the UK population), their median age is 57 (the national average is 40), and 80% fall in the so-called ABC1 category of the most highly-paid demographic group (this makes up 53% of the country).   They also match the classic stereotype of being white and right-leaning on issues, with 76% voting for Brexit and 95% identifying as White British in a country where that makes up just 83% of the population.  Now, that is a lot of numbers, but the fact that those voting on our next leader come from such a small and narrow segment of society is not only plainly a crazy and scarcely believable part of our democratic system but goes some way to explaining how and why they have leaned so heavily on Truss over Sunak. They have rewarded her ludicrous attempts to evoke Thatcherite policies which don’t fit the current economic climate and, much like the Foreign Secretary’s desperate efforts to emulate Thatcher’s personality and dress sense, are outdated.

Despite this, in fact for this very reason, one would think that the constant comments from some of the Tory party’s oldest, most successful, and most well-respected names, about just how baseless much of Truss’ economic policies are, would have swayed more of the base towards Sunak.  Kenneth Clark has described her approach as “nonsense and simplistic” and related it to techniques that might be used by a Venezuelan government.  Former leaders Michael Howard and William Hague, as well as well-respected current MPs such as Dominic Raab, Jeremy Hunt, and Michael Gove, have all taken to the airwaves and newspapers in the past few days to speak against the idea that tax cuts can resolve the crisis.  Even Lord Lamont, Treasurer in the Thatcher government remembered so fondly by much of the conservative party base, has publicly backed Sunak over the holes in Truss’ plans. It isn’t only individuals who think that her plans are misguided either: the IFS joined countless other economists last week in pointing out that her current ideas are simply unfundable unless they are accompanied by spending cuts.

What makes all of this even more crazy and difficult for me to get my head around is that the members seem blissfully unaware of just how unelectable Truss is for the electorate as a whole.  With a general election looming in 2024 you would think that there would be an appetite for a relatively inoffensive leader who appeals to as broad a base as possible.  Whereas Sunak has at least shown his ability to appeal to a large spectrum in the past, earning himself the nickname ‘Dishy Rishi’ during his Eat Out to Help Out glory days, Truss has never shied away from bulldozing ahead with unpopular policies and divisive comments.  Whether that is upsetting Scots by saying that the best way to deal with their democratically elected leader is “to ignore her” or regular workers by telling them to put in some more “graft”, Truss trails Keir Starmer and rival Sunak in every poll of the general population.  And if recent leaks of her planned cabinet are to be believed, placing Jacob Rees-Mogg as Levelling-up Secretary, she hardly appears to be planning a change of course on this front.

So – why?  What is it that appeals?  It might well be a case of Johnson continuity – indeed in surveys, many have said that they feel Sunak betrayed their leader by resigning and becoming one of the major catalysts for the Prime Minister’s downfall.  In reality though, I think it is more of a case of the members being genuinely detached from the real world themselves.  For whatever reason they don’t seem able to see their impending decision risks disaster for millions of people across the country by worsening current financial pressures as well as putting them in a catastrophic position ahead of the next general election. Two years is a long time in politics, but right now I struggle to see why on earth the turkeys are voting for Christmas.  

Image: CC 2.0 – UK Government via Flickr.  

Vessel : A Review

0

CW : mention of disordered eating, fat phobia, body dysmorphia

Have you ever wept in a toilet stall—maybe during a particularly rough school day, maybe during a night out that went wrong—thinking that you were completely insulated from the world outside, only to realise that there’s a giant gap in the door –  so whoever is walking past can definitely see you, all puffy-faced? Grace Olusola’s Vessel spoke directly to my teenage self and my current self alike, as I found myself in that exact situation after the show: watching the play felt like having my private, internal feelings about my body and food externalised and projected onto the stage at the Old Fire Station this Trinity. I felt seen. 

Last summer I vented my frustrations at feeling like the only fat person at Oxford on Twitter, and my notifications pinged more than normal for a little while. Initially, I worried that a play seeking to address themes of bodies and food in the Oxford community would centre the experiences of people who are afraid of looking like me. While I do not seek to invalidate the experience of people who are insecure and conventionally attractive, there’s a difference between being insecure about having rolls when you slouch and, as the Comedienne comments, “the world decid[ing] whether you’re ugly or not for you”.

Yet Olusola and her team of six other directors have taken the wide-ranging diversity of such relationships with body image into close consideration. Vessel is made up of twelve discrete episodes, each drawing inspiration from student survey responses on questions around bodies and food. The episodes differed significantly in tone, managing to tackle these issues with sensitivity and humour, and reminded me of scrolling through TikTok: we see a spoof of 2000s fatphobic TV shows, titled ‘Formerly Grotesque Fat People Bake On Blind Dates While We Watch’, and a monologue on different kinds of Reese’s peanut butter cups, among others. In ‘Not Like other Girls’ we even see a girl sniffling in the school toilets, not unlike me after the show.

The episodic structure and use of several directors is certainly a strength of the show, reflecting how our relationships with food and our bodies has as much to do with class, race, gender and sexuality as with what we see when we look in the mirror. I particularly enjoyed how the show played around with form and structure to reflect this: in ‘Femi’, Tariro Tinwaro sings of a best friend with an eating disorder “outrunning bodies like mine”, while in ‘The Comedienne’ we see Chloe Ralph hilariously enact the awkwardness of mediocre standup about her friend group and conclude “with friends this fucked up, this may be one of the few situations in life where being the fat one is actually the best status in the group.” 

Olusola cites her experience as a welfare officer at St. Catherine’s College, as well as her own body image struggles, as a catalyst for Vessel: this certainly shows throughout the production, albeit not in a way that feels patronising, didactic or reductive. At the beginning we hear a voiceover announce the show’s trigger warnings, and that if at any point an audience member needs to leave and take a break, they are welcome to do so. Likewise, at the end the crew offered pens and index cards to audience members as a chance to reflect on what they had just seen.

While I did sometimes find myself wishing for more cohesion between the writing of the episodes, I enjoyed the way that each episode was announced by the pinning of a poster or a graphic with its title to a board at the back of the stage, creating a sense of collaginess and accumulation. This imagery of food wrappers and containers was neatly alluded to in ‘Motherhood’, an episode where a woman tidying the house for a date discovers her daughter’s binge-eating stash concealed between stage blocks. During the interval, a friend remarked that the episodic nature reminded her of opening a door at a house party and accidentally walking in on a conversation between strangers that you were not meant to overhear, as alluded to perfectly in a scene where we watch the awkward reconnecting between old friends gradually tip over into a painful conservation about responsibility when one is  mentally ill. Olusola’s skilful writing shines through in lines like “I had a brain that betrayed me–you were the collateral”, and “sorry, force of habit, when you’re at death’s door [so often] you start leaving a key under the doormat.”

The presence of fat actors and explicitly working-class characters, albeit only a handful, on a student stage was particularly refreshing to see, although I did find myself wishing for more than a few of the twelve episodes in a show about bodies to centre their experiences.

Overall, Vessel’s careful balancing of sensitivity and humour in its treatment of the subject matter of body image and food made it an important and worthwhile watch; I can only hope that we see more stories and actors with these experiences on the Oxford student stage in the future. 

Where do we go from here?  Reflections on a day of chaos in Downing Street

0

Where do we go from here?  Reflections on a day of unprecedented chaos in Downing Street…

The past few years in British politics have repeatedly defied belief but Thursday 7th July will go down in history as the most chaotic, bizarre, and extraordinary day that our country has seen in decades.  This morning, it was barely possible to make a cup of tea before returning to the television to learn of another ministerial resignation or letter from newly appointed cabinet ministers calling for the Prime Minister to go. Chris Mason taking the phone call from Downing Street to confirm Boris Johnson’s resignation live on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme perhaps perfectly summed up the incredulous nature of the morning’s proceedings. The big question now though is what on earth happens next?  Where do the Conservative party and the country go from here?  As it stands, the PM insists that he will stay on until a new leader is announced, but is that really feasible?  Who is best positioned to succeed him? One thing is certain, the turmoil is far from over…

Who Next?  The Runners and the Riders

The main reason why Johnson has survived in post for so long in spite of countless scandals that would’ve buried leaders of the past has been the lack of an apparent successor. Now the Conservative party is facing a leadership election with contenders from across the political spectrum, as it tries to decide its future.

Liz Truss

Bookies odds – 7/1

Long-time favourite of old-time party members but counting many enemies among fellow MPs, the outspoken Truss has never been afraid to make her leadership ambitions clear. Much like Johnson, she has been happy to bend her political beliefs to fit with her rise to power after backing remain in 2016 only to become one of the biggest supporters for a hard Brexit in recent years. Brash and brazen with political stances branded by many as ‘Thatcherism on steroids’, she certainly wouldn’t offer the dramatic change in tone and direction needed if her party is to stand any chance of rescuing themselves at any approaching election.  She may also struggle in early stages of the leadership race, with several MPs declaring privately that they wouldn’t back her.

Nadim Zahawi

Bookies odds – 8/1

Zahawi was centre stage in the political chaos of the last 48 hours after being appointed Chancellor of the Exchequer on Tuesday night, doing the media rounds defending the Prime Minister on Wednesday morning, and then calling for his resignation on Thursday.  His political stock rose substantially as vaccines minister during the pandemic and, popular amongst his colleagues, he now appears to be one of the favourites to succeed Johnson.  The only thing standing against him may turn out to be his relative inexperience in government. 

Rishi Sunak

Bookies odds – 4/1

There are few men in history who have had such a dramatic rise to fame and fall from grace as Rishi Sunak. An unknown among the public when appointed as Chancellor he attracted fans throughout the pandemic with generous furlough and ‘Eat Out to Help Out’ schemes before becoming embroiled in the Partygate scandal and brought down by questions over his wife’s non-dom tax status.  There’s a chance that his shock resignation on Tuesday night might just have saved his chances and he is sure to be a front runner if he can convince MPs of his credentials.  Equally, his resignation letter suggested that his could be ‘his last ministerial job’ and a return to pre-political life could certainly prove to be an attractive proposition for the former banker.

Sajid Javid

Bookies odds – 7/1

Having already failed twice in leadership elections could it be third time lucky for the man who initiated the final chapter of Johnson’s prime ministerial career?  Although his dramatic move and speech after PMQ’s will appeal to some, few can really doubt his own personal motivations for moving against the PM when he did and that kind of ‘snakery’ as Number 10 likes to call it has been enough to see others named Michal Gove get the sack.  Javid would offer something different in terms of a political direction and would appeal as a more stable set of hands but his flip-flopping hasn’t won him many fans amongst MPs and party members.

Penny Mourdant 

Bookies odds – 5/1

Who? I hear you ask.  The bookmakers’ favourite that’s who!  Mourdant finds herself in the bizzare position where not having any experience working in recent cabinets will be seen as one of her biggest strengths.  If you are in search of a metaphor for the dire state of the Tory party then this is it.  Being a long-time Brexit backer makes her palpable to the right of the party and the ERG but her membership of the liberal Conservative ‘One Nation’ caucus means that she has a fairly wide reach.  She has perhaps the fewest enemies of any of the obvious contenders.  Then again that is inevitable when you consider that she has never held a post of significance within government.

Tom Tugenhadt

Bookies odds – 14/1

‘The rebels’ choice’, Tugenhadt is one of the few likely runners who has spoken out against Johnson from the start.  The Chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee slammed him for his performance as Foreign Secretary and has remained critical ever since.  His rhetoric always focuses on a renewal of traditional conservative values, the meaningful substance of that rhetoric unsurprisingly remains in the dark.

Jeremy Hunt

Bookies odds – 11/1

Hunt will undoubtedly frame himself as the man who stood up to ‘Johnson the bully’ and never served in his cabinet.  In reality, insiders suggest that his close relationship with Theresa May meant that he was never invited to – a quite extraordinary thing when you consider the amount of ministers Johnson went through.  Hardly a superstar as health secretary Hunt would represent a return to the more traditional style of government of Theresa May and although that be unexciting to some MPs, large swathes of party members could be convinced by a reassuring return to relative normality.

Ben Wallace

Bookies odds – 5/1

The defence secretary never resigned from the cabinet but did just about manage to squeeze in a letter calling for Johnson to go before the final decision was announced.  The former soldier is broadly seen as reliable and undramatic, both potentially very attractive characteristics at the moment.  He has won international acclaim for his dealing with the Ukraine crisis and the general public would be sure to back him on that but he is notable for his lack of experience in all other areas of government.  Despite his popularity, he has also previously stated his desire to take on the role of UN Secretary-General in the future and that may yet prove to be his next step.

So, in conclusion, the race remains very much open.  Dozens are sure to declare their leadership bids over the coming days and countless campaign websites will no doubt be launched within hours but the stark reality is that none of the options are pretty for the Conservatives.  The party is in a mess, politics is in a mess.  Opposition parties insist that Johnson cannot remain PM whilst the process continues and any caretaker would get the chance to audition their potential on the biggest stage.  It still remains to be seen how long the elected leader will stay in post.  Can any of those listed above really stake a claim to Johnson’s record-breaking mandate from 2019?  A general election may very well be on the cards and, if that is the case, then the calculations change all over again for the MPs with the fate of the nation in their hands…

Your Thoughts

We asked you to sum up your thoughts about our departing Prime Minister’s time in office and departure itself – it’s safe to safe that the responses were mixed and I am happy to report that you didn’t hold back!

Charlie Aslet on the nature of Johnson’s departure:

“Boris Johnson’s resignation had as much dignity as a streaker at a football game. He clung to power until even his unkempt reflection was telling him it was time to pack it in. Some people would have thought it honourable to jump before being pushed. Not Boris. He was beaten up by all his closest friends and colleagues, his trousers hoisted around his ankles and then given a mighty boot up the buttocks before stumbling over the cliff. His only consolation as he tumbled down that rockface was that he managed to give Michael Gove a final slap in the face before he fell, giving him the sack when everyone else was resigning. In a way, I feel a bit sorry for Boris. His resignation was like the assassination of Julius Caesar, except this time it felt like he also managed to stab himself a few times before he died. But, then again, the man seems incapable of telling the truth. Even when he says he’s leaving it’s difficult to believe it will actually happen. When he says he’s actually staying, that’s when I’ll be ready to believe he’s really going for good.”

We then asked you for reflections on Johnson’s premiership:

“Good riddance babes”

“One word – joke”

And your predictions for the future:

“Same circus different clown”

“There is an unfortunate possibility that the Tories may be redeemed in the public eye”

“No chance anyone else will have anywhere near the decision-making prowess of Boris – prepare yourselves for an era of catastrophic indecision”

“I’m just sad for the people of Ukraine. Their future is now in doubt more than ever.”

“Someone equally bad or worse will become Prime Minister, there is no winning!”

Image: CC:2.0 (BY-NC-ND 2.0 via FLKR)

Putin’s ‘hockey buddy’ funded Teddy Hall and Saïd Business School

UPDATE: On the 29th June, The UK Government announced a new round of sanctions on several high profile Russian figures including Potanin, with the aim of “hitting Putin’s inner circle”. A government statement read: “Potanin continues to amass wealth as he supports Putin’s regime, acquiring Rosbank, and shares in Tinkoff Bank in the period since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.”

As the Western world moves to sanction overseas Russian money, Cherwell has found that St Edmund Hall and the Saïd Business School accepted donations from Vladimir Potanin, the oligarch and metals tycoon who is the second richest man in Russia.

Potanin, 61, has a net worth of $27 billion, as estimated by Forbes. In 2020, he was included on the US Treasury’s list of 210 Russian oligarchs, businessmen and politicians under considerations for sanctions, dubbed ‘Putin’s List’. He is widely known for regularly playing ice hockey with Putin. Potanin’s fortune fell by $3 billion on the day that Russia invaded Ukraine. Potanin also served as the Deputy Prime Minister for 7 months between 1996 and 1997. 

In 1999, Potanin founded the Vladimir Potanin Foundation to “implement large-scale humanitarian programs” in the fields of “culture, higher education, social sport and philanthropy development”. The foundation donated £3 million to St Edmund Hall in 2018 to endow a research fund for Earth Sciences, and to jointly establish the Vladimir Potanin Associate Professor and Tutorial Fellow in Earth Sciences with the University of Oxford. The endowment also funded the three-year Vladimir Potanin Tutorial Fellow of Russian Literature and Modern Languages.

The foundation also granted $150,000 to the Saïd Business School in 2017 for a fellowship scheme for the Oxford Social Finance Programme. The school selected 15 Russian charity workers to attend this programme between 2017 and 2019. 

The collapse of the Soviet Union in the 1990s allowed well-connected individuals to profit from the bloc’s transition to a market economy by gaining control over newly privatized state assets. Many of these deals were done privately, without competition. While in office, Potanin proposed the controversial ‘loans for shares’ scheme, which is seen as having furthered the rise of the oligarch class. This scheme effectively caused the consolidation of oligarchs’ control over the Russian economy. ‘Loans for shares’ encouraged wealthy businessmen to loan money to the Yeltsin government in exchange for state-owned shares in companies, many of which extracted and processed Russia’s abundant natural resources. 

Of the programme, he told The Financial Times: “It is the biggest PR tragedy of my career. Of course, the privatisation process has to be transparent. And in our case it was not. My plan was different. I wanted to privatise the companies with banks and qualified people, raise their value, and then sell them.”

Through this scheme, Potanin and his long-term business partner Mikhail Prokhorov acquired a 54% share in Norilsk Nickel (Nornickel). The two businessmen separated their assets in 2007, leaving Potanin with 34.6% of the shares in Norilsk Nickel. The company’s total assets amounted to $20.7 billion in 2020.

On top of being the world’s largest producer of nickel, Norilsk Nickel is one of the world’s largest industrial polluters. In 2020, the company produced 1.9% of total global sulphur dioxide emissions. The company has announced that it intends to reduce suphur dioxides from its plants in the heavily polluted Norilsk region by 90% by 2025 from a 2015 baseline.

Potanin is the only Russian to have signed The Giving Pledge, in which the super-rich pledge to give a majority of their wealth to philanthropic causes. Other signatories include Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerber, and George Lucas. He said his decision was motivated by a belief that “wealth should work for public good”, and as a way to “protect [his] children from the burden of extreme wealth”.

A spokesperson for St Edmund Hall told Cherwell that the gift was accepted “in good faith and at a time when relations with Russia were in a substantially better place. This was a one-off donation and the College does not anticipate any further funding from The Potanin Foundation.

“The College is deeply concerned at the events happening in Ukraine and sincerely hopes that a peaceful outcome will soon be reached,” they added.

The Saïd Business School told Cherwell: “The grant went through the University’s robust approval process and the partnership ended in 2019. The focus of the programme is to improve the social impact and philanthropic work of charities and non-government organisations (NGOs) across the world. As a global business school with students and alumni from across the world, we have been deeply saddened at events happening in the Ukraine and hope a peaceful outcome is soon reached.”

The University of Oxford, Interros, and The Vladimir Potanin Foundation were approached for comment.

Image credit: Kremlin.ru/CC BY 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Review: “Black Lives Playlist: Track 2” by Sam Spencer

CW: homophobia, racism

A couple of hours before watching Track 2, I saw a friend’s Instagram story pointing out the comments on a post from the official 10 Downing Street account. The post celebrated the ‘extraordinary contribution of LGBT’ people to Britain, but the comments were full of the kind of vitriolic homophobia that it’s hard to believe still exists in public spaces. It is this kind of hate, as well as the prevalence of outright racism, especially in online spheres, that makes projects like the Black Lives Playlist essential.

Track 2 is, primarily, a monologue about the experience of being Black and gay. It centres around The Speaker’s complex inner turmoil between shame and pride in his sexuality. Whilst we may now fortunately live in a world where homosexuality is far more accepted, this play serves as an important reminder that prejudice still very much exists in our society,and that microagressions can have serious consequences especially where marginalised identities intersect.

In spite of this, Track 2 never feels like a PSA about homophobia or racism. Instead, its character-driven nature is relatable to anyone who has ever felt out of place at a family party; anyone who’s questioned what they really want from life; anyone who’s kissed someone they didn’t really like and regretted it; anyone who’s looked at themself in the mirror mid-breakdown and thought, actually, they look kind of hot. This is the play’s greatest strength: writer Sam Spencer manages to both convey a very specific life experience and connect with universal feelings of anxiety and difference.

The Speaker tells us about a day spent visiting his sister’s boyfriend’s family for the first time – an experience that sparks complex emotions and difficult memories. This central narrative introduces us to the story of his ex-boyfriend, and a rendez-vous with a man from the gay hook-up app Grindr who asks The Speaker some difficult questions. Each of these narrative strands ties together cohesively. Credit must go to Spencer for creating a plot that plays out in such a satisfying manner, and to director James Newbery and assistant-director Grace Olusola for translating it onto the stage so effortlessly.

The different visions of the show’s team work flawlessly together. With one-person shows, especially those performed and directed by different people, it’s easy for conflicting creative visions to come across in the finished product, but no such issue exists here. The use of music adds to the piece brilliantly, and the colourful lighting accentuates the vivid narrative, although the lighting could perhaps have been used to accentuate key moments to a greater extent, and mark transitions between time periods more clearly. Yet, the collaborative nature of the project translates into a show that knows what it wants to be, and executes this vision immaculately. 

The greatest strength of the direction is its simplicity: the story is allowed to speak for itself, which is essential to its success. Spencer’s script never tries to be overly clever or conceptual, instead relying on its innately heartfelt character development and engaging humour. He has a talent for visceral description, making both messy hookups and family dinners crystal clear in audiences’ minds, despite the minimalist staging: The Speaker remains sat alone in a dark space throughout. The script is structured very cleverly, with the hook-up acting as a frame that gains new meaning at the end, and the sister’s boyfriend storyline leading us craftily to an emotional climax. In addition to this, Spencer’s mixing of personal anecdotes with general thoughts on the likes of Stonewall statistics and making out with girls helps the writing sit so perfectly on the line between specific and universal. If I were to be especially fussy, it could be said that the script becomes slightly repetitive at times. Some elements, such as the use of the Grindr sound effect, could do with verbal clarification for audiences less familiar with the app, and the ideas around religion could have been fleshed out further. It remains, however, a remarkable piece of writing.

Spencer also performs his writing with a real honesty, transitioning smoothly between a public-facing cheekiness and moments of serious emotional depth – there are points where we feel genuine concern for him. The only things subtracting from the performance are some issues with awkward cuts and poor sound quality – the choppy switches between cuts takes us out of a few important moments, and dialogue with the off-screen voice in the first scene is at times hard to make out. These flaws can be easily forgiven, though; the show would work seamlessly in person, but we are unfortunately still gradually exiting the age of online theatre.

Like every other theatre fan, I’ve watched a lot of filmed monologues over the last year and a half. The influence of the likes of Fleabag can be felt within this piece (what would a review of a monologue be without a reference to Phoebe Waller-Bridge or Michaela Coel?), but it’s clear that the team have taken into consideration the limits and possibilities of the form and made it work for them. With its cohesive structure, engaging character and unfaltering honesty, Track 2 takes its place as one of the best examples of what has become an era-defining genre.

Image Credit: Pete Miller.

Editorial: Russell Group Student Newspapers for No-Detriment Policy

As the editors of Russell Group student newspapers, we are writing collectively to request a reversal of the Russell Group’s statement, 7 January 2020, ‘on ensuring fair assessment and protecting the integrity of degrees.’

As editors, not only are we students or recent students ourselves but we are also in constant contact with the students at our respective universities, as part of the function of our extracurricular roles. Apart from sharing in their collective experiences, we have a unique insight into their attitudes, viewpoints and beliefs. We speak and listen to them every day – and every day since the beginning of this academic year, we have heard students calling for more understanding, cooperation and empathy from university management. 

The statement shared by the Russell Group on 7 January showed the inconsistencies between what they and we understand to be adequate teaching. Whilst we enormously appreciate the hard work of teaching staff under these challenging circumstances and understand the complications ‘blended learning’ has presented, students have repeatedly said they have not been adequately supported throughout this pandemic. This is by no means to disregard the tremendous efforts of university staff, but it is simply a consequence of the realities of a year like none other in living memory. 

The lack of a ‘no detriment’ or ‘safety net’ policy has been a miscalculation by the Russell Group. Students across the UK have been left feeling abandoned by both the government, devolved administrations and universities themselves. 

As the editors of 28 student papers, we pick up and record the views of our students on a regular basis. What many are telling us, as a result of personal and shared difficulties, is that they do require the support a clearer ‘no detriment’ policy would deliver.

We object to the assumption made by the Russell Group that ‘emergency measures’ are no longer ‘necessary’ or ‘appropriate’. We are living through what are undeniably unprecedented times – this is a global emergency. The Prime Minister has labelled these weeks of the third lockdown as the critical point in the UK’s fight against the pandemic – death tolls are high, hospitals have reached capacity, we are still just in the early days of administering vaccines. Students, locked down in various levels of economic and social stability across the nation, are facing some of the most important exams we have sat in our lives to date – under some of the most difficult circumstances many will have faced. International students, too, have been working all term from various time zones around the globe, detached from the support of their student communities.

If anything, this point in the pandemic is perhaps the most urgent. We are now facing a mental health crisis amongst young people. Figures by WONKHE and Trendence have shown that more students feel lonely and isolated on a daily basis as a result of the pandemic. Additionally, surveys of undergraduates by various higher education policy advisers have found that over 50 per cent of students say their mental health has significantly deteriorated during the course of the pandemic. 

Students are attempting to sit assessments with a lack of resources, varying internet connections and mixed home environments. There are students without desks, who share bedrooms with siblings, who have caring responsibilities when they’re at home. Across the country, there are students from wide and varied backgrounds who are struggling to study for their final year assessments, many also affected by illness and bereavement owing to COVID-19. Students from lower income families as well as estranged students are disproportionately affected in their learning experiences this year and less able to receive the traditional means of support. They do not deserve to be dismissed.  

Yet, no one from the Russell Group denied the emergency of the situation when metal fences were erected around halls at Manchester. Universities even went as far as to declare their own local emergencies by locking down individual residences during outbreaks amongst first years. There was no denial of ‘emergency’ when students were being blamed in the media for spikes in national COVID-19 cases. 

A-level and GCSE exams have been adjusted to as if this were an emergency – so why aren’t the Russell Group responding in the same way for university students?

It should also be noted the UK government have voided themselves of much of the responsibility for the problems students face. On January 15, the Minister of State for Universities Michelle Donelan tweeted that ‘if universities want to continue charging full fees, they are expected to maintain the quality, quantity and accessibility of tuition’. A government who demands this from its universities should put support systems in place to enable it.  

You have explained to our respective Student Unions that it is more appropriate for universities to provide ‘a range of policies and tools’ to ensure fair assessment for students. Whilst we agree some universities will need to adapt their policy on an individual basis, the Russell Group’s collective position against ‘no detriment’ or ‘safety net’ policy does not match the reality of what many students have faced, and are continuing to face, this year.

In principle, a ‘no detriment’ or ‘safety net’ policy should ensure a student’s grade is not worsened as a result of the pandemic. Currently, many of your universities’ mitigatory policies amount to simply offering more time for assessments. Frankly, a matter of extra days or a week is not sufficient for the challenges that we have outlined above, which students are facing in real time.

We understand that an algorithmic approach is not entirely viable due to the lack of benchmark data for many students at this stage of the 2020/21 academic year – that’s a mathematical given. But it is by no means impossible to support an alternative ‘no detriment’ policy built for the circumstances. The University of York, for instance, is implementing a comprehensive policy, attempting to take into account the unique challenges posed by this pandemic, as opposed to reshuffling and extending existing policies. 

By readjusting the weightings of each year towards a student’s overall degree and choosing the better of the two for penultimate- and final-year undergraduates, as well as allowing first-years to re-sit up to 90 failed credits in exams, the University of York have worked to try and introduce an appropriate and fair policy. Postgraduates, who should not be forgotten in any such policy, have also been offered an assured ‘safety net’. Overall, it is certainly not perfect but it at least strives to fulfill on the principle of ‘no detriment’, allowing students to simply focus on their studies, with some confidence they will not be impacted by COVID-19, whilst preserving the value of their degrees to employers. 

We urge all Russell Group universities to introduce similarly comprehensive policies.

Whilst we understand that every subject, university and student is different, showing the understanding and empathy to their students embodied in York’s approach should be a basic requirement.

Presently, there are a small number of universities, such as Cardiff, that have recently implemented similar policies. Yet their commitment to this editorial is on the basis that students from all Russell Group universities should have the same level of assurance.

Overall, many students will of course respect and largely agree with your desire to maintain degree standards comparative to other years and to ensure, as you say, that they still ‘command the confidence of employers and professional bodies’. However, where other aspects of society have shifted or seen unprecedented measures introduced over the course of the last year, we believe a reweighting or rescaling of degrees is certainly possible. The students we write for and hear from daily are not asking for a policy that allows them to stop working or learning, but one that simply acknowledges the reality of the pandemic and its wide-ranging impact.

Ultimately, you claim you want to uphold the integrity of our degrees. Yet a university’s first responsibility is to its students and acting with integrity ought to mean upholding this responsibility. Many students across the country have not received the ‘blended’ or ‘hybrid’ learning experience they were promised; many are now separated from their campuses, with its facilities and libraries, due to a third national lockdown brought about largely by an unforeseen variant; many are facing personal, long-term hardship as a result of the virus, and/or extreme difficulties at home.

The integrity of a degree, too – students would hope – should encompass a focus on the opportunity to learn and study as well as a focus on rankings and outcomes. The integrity of university institutions should entail safeguarding the mental wellbeing of its students. Under the current plans laid out by most Russell Group universities, students are reporting to us loudly that neither of these are currently in line.

Students have not been quiet about their concerns. With exams fast approaching, and some already underway, now is the time for Russell Groups universities to act compassionately and responsibly.

Editorial: Oxford must adopt a no-detriment policy for this year’s finalists

0

It is an understatement to say that we are living in extraordinary times. Last March, the UK, along with the rest of the world, came to a grinding halt at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic as we tried to cope with a crisis that was entirely without precedent. The Prime Minister told us then that “things are going to get worse before they get better” – but the reality of this warning has only now been fully realised.

Ten months later, the UK has entered the worst stage of its crisis so far: tragically, cases and deaths have soared and, once again, students have been asked to study from home with Hilary term teaching moved online. However, many are highly concerned about the limited and restrained adjustments recently made by the University of Oxford to account for the deterioration of the coronavirus crisis and its impact on the upcoming term and students’ education as a whole. 

It is not unreasonable to expect that students should not be disadvantaged by circumstances wholly beyond their control. That is why the editorial boards of The Oxford Blue, The Oxford Student and Cherwell are calling on the University of Oxford to introduce a fair ‘no-detriment’ policy for finalists.

While the scale of this tragedy has been devastating in terms of loss of life, the quality of students’ education has also suffered enormously. Students have raised serious concerns in recent days and weeks about issues at home: different time zones to Oxford in their home location; a lack of space; noise; and an absence of essential work tools including a desk, books, a computer and a stable, high-speed internet connection. Furthermore, international students are faced with additional (and unpredictable) challenges, such as having to make travel plans, negotiating complex and changeable immigration policies, undergoing mandatory periods of quarantine (either in private accomodation or specialist facilities) and/or firewalled internet access. Students who are materially more privileged than others in these areas are thus at a significant advantage compared to their peers. 

Many students have also felt lonely, confused and anxious throughout the pandemic. Like the rest of the population, students have had to contend with self-isolation and the emotional impact of being unable to socialise normally with friends, family and partners. Some students have been ill with COVID-19 themselves or had to care for sick household members and loved ones whilst keeping up with the famously rigorous, unrelenting pace of an Oxford degree. The pandemic’s asymmetric demands on students means that a one-size-fits-all approach cannot be feasible and a ‘no-detriment’ policy is crucial for student success.

In such extraordinary circumstances – and ten months into the UK’s COVID-19 crisis – students deserve better than inflexibility and an insistence that it is possible to study as normal in such tough conditions. It is crucial to recognise the circumstances that led to the establishment of the ‘no-detriment policy’ last spring have only been prolonged and exacerbated over the course of recent months. If students are to pay full tuition fees for a severely diminished university education, it is right that the University at least intervenes to accommodate the impact of COVID-19 on our learning experience and academic attainment. 

Last year, in light of the rapid spread and impact of COVID-19, the University listened to student feedback and implemented what they called a no-detriment policy, designed to ensure that finalists did not suffer from the consequences of a global issue outside of their control. Whilst by no means perfect, this policy was executed well in many respects. The optionality from last year should be continued further given the nature of the ongoing crisis. Imposing any one formula on the entire student body will unfairly disadvantage a significant number of its members. If we prioritise simplicity, we may unintentionally neglect the nuances of the situation which we face. Decentralising choice to students means that assessment will consider principles of fairness and equity, and ensure that each student can face the challenges we all find ourselves facing on their own terms, in a way that is right for them. That is what a no-detriment policy must guarantee.

There is undoubtedly a shared interest amongst the entire staff-student body in not wanting the value of an Oxford degree to be diluted, and everyone understands the importance of ‘academic rigour’; it is why many students apply to study here. However, it is unavoidable that students will be affected to varying degrees by the pandemic. Some will feel unable to be examined at the end of this calendar year if, for example, they or a close family member fall ill and/or they have been struggling with mental health issues. Others may be able to undertake exams, but will have to do so in extremely difficult conditions. More still will need to fulfil academic conditions to begin postgraduate courses but may or may not be able to be assessed next term. It suffices to say that no one solution can accommodate all students in a satisfactory manner and, therefore, a solution similar to last year must be implemented.

Yesterday’s email from the University, however, is not only a disappointment but an insult to the entire student body. By refusing to implement a clear ‘safety net’ policy, the University is downplaying the real-world impact that the pandemic has had on students’ learning – both in terms of access to teaching and resources, and of the effect of this crisis on students’ mental health. Some individual departments have also introduced policies that represent a ‘business as usual’ approach to exams and assessments, despite students’ loss of library access, resources and study spaces. A reliance on examiners’ personal acknowledgement of the past year’s unique circumstances cannot replace a formal framework that can evaluate and mitigate inequalities in learning and attainment. 

The University has said that it will announce “additional measures” to ensure fair degree outcomes in “the middle of Hilary term”. The only way to ensure fairness is for the University – in conjunction with departments and faculties – to commit, as soon as possible, to a no-detriment policy for all those taking exams and submitting other assessments, Such measures can ensure that no individual Oxford student is unjustly disadvantaged by the effect of the pandemic on their learning in the last year and during the next.  

Oxford’s Student Union, which serves as a voice for a student body of over 22,000, has said that the University should “recognise the academic challenges by reassessing workloads and assessment practices”, calling for a “fair outcome policy” defined as “a system of policies put in place to mitigate the detrimental effects of the pandemic on students with exams and coursework this year”. This will involve the re-scaling and re-weighting of exams and coursework to reflect the impact of the pandemic on the whole cohort. At an individual level, the Student Union has called for students to be able to file for mitigating circumstances and deadline extensions – without needing to prove that the pandemic has affected their studies – and to access better financial, academic and mental health support. We wholeheartedly endorse these demands and encourage students to find out more about the Student Union’s campaign and services and attend the online workshop taking place this evening (13 January), which will address these issues.

Other universities in the Russell Group, such the University of York, have also started to implement similar ‘safety net’ policies, and the Universities of Leeds, Lancaster and Bristol are considering similar approaches. A petition by Oxford students to the Vice Chancellor to implement “fair safety nets” has already attracted almost 800 signatures at the time of writing. 

On Tuesday, the University ruled out the possibility of a ‘blanket safety net’, but given the disruption caused to the last two terms – which will likely endure even beyond Hilary term – it must now act to introduce a fair no-detriment policy which will also reflect the impact of the pandemic on assessments, just as last year’s safety net did. To fail to do so will present an entirely unfair disadvantage to Oxford students, directly undermining the University’s commitment to student welfare and academic success.

The effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on a whole generation of students can not even begin to be graphed on a curve. This crisis is, as we are so often reminded, ‘unprecedented’ – but extraordinary times surely call for equally extraordinary measures. 

A fair, robust no-detriment policy is one of those measures – and it must be implemented now. 

Editors-in-Chief and Managing Director, Cherwell, The Oxford Blue, and The Oxford Student

All I Want for Christmas is Food!

0

Come Christmas, what’s on your table? Are there bowls overflowing with cranberry sauce? Plates filled with pigs in blankets? A prize bird gleaming on its platter? Traditions differ, but some dishes find their feature every year. 

For most, the star of the Christmas feast is the turkey: the plump, golden-skinned bird that takes pride of place. But different birds have had their place; peacocks, pheasants and ducks all had their time on the table and before Victorian times, a goose was the typical centrepiece of the Christmas meal. 

Henry VIII, a man then synonymous with decadence, may have been the first in England to try a turkey, but it did not come into fashion until Charles Dickens chose to emphasise the immense philanthropy of Scrooge’s gift to the Cratchits by swapping their traditional goose for turkey. No expense would be spared, and thus the Christmas turkey fell into vogue. Isabella Beeton, author of Mrs Beeton’s Book of Household Management, and the Victorian authority on all things to do with housekeeping, bolstered this new trend by proclaiming that Christmas for the middle class “would scarcely be a Christmas dinner without its turkey”. 

Two of the more controversial members of a Christmas dinner, Yorkshire puddings and Bread Sauce, both find their origins in leftovers. Although many would argue Yorkshire puddings should only be eaten with roast beef, they actually originated from the drippings of fat off mutton as it roasted. As dripping fell into a pan filled with a batter, a Yorkshire pudding – enormous by today’s standards – would grow. Anyone with a food-strict upbringing similar to my own would never imagine a Yorkshire pudding on their plate come Christmas, yet this favourite continues to divide the country. It takes just a quick google search to discover the years of articles that have piled up from yuletides arguing pro-YP or against!

Yorkshire puddings’ more traditional, but stranger cousin is bread sauce. The beige, lumpy, liquid-like substance is not much more than gloop to those who haven’t been brought up with it. But to a fan, it’s a haven of stodgy delight. Bread sauce also originates from leftovers. In the Medieval period, soups were thickened with leftover bread, rather than flour as used today. These soups were prepared for Christmas feasts and evolved into the bay/nutmeg/clove flavoured slop (can you tell I wasn’t raised on it?) that so many will douse their turkey with this week.

As with anything that has its roots in the dinners of yore, the veg on our plates at Christmas have been shaped simply by whatever our ancestors managed to grow. Brussel sprouts found their way to the UK from Belgium, being the only cold-hardy green around. Parsnips, the preferred partner to sprouts, are harvested in the winter. Their first frost causes sugars to be released from their starch stores, giving them their characteristic sweetness (you won’t find that fun fact in your cracker). 

Christmas desserts may be the most reliably underwhelming part of the day. Dessert has the opportunity to hold such creativity and glee, and yet the dry, misshapen lumps turned out year after year hold nothing but an unbelievable amount of fruit. They also hold a considerable serving of history. 

The myth of each of the thirteen fillings of Christmas cake representing the 12 apostles and Jesus is a fun tale, but the most interesting story is with mince pies. First, let’s clear it up – yes, mincemeat did once contain real meat. Dating back to the crusades when meat/spiced/fruit pies found their way back to Europe, mince pies evolved from rectangular “coffins” to round Christmas Pyes that were often found at bountiful Christmas feasts. They were famously held in disdain by Cromwell’s Puritan government because of the ‘more-gluttony-less-Jesus’ they seemed to represent. By the Victorian period, mincemeat was being prepared and jarred earlier and earlier in the year to allow flavours to mature, and hence, meat was left at the wayside – thankfully for us. 

These Victorian mince pies largely look like those we have today – buttery pastry, spiced fruit (and suet) filling, decoration with festive designs on top. Though their status as a delicious treat may be divisive, mince pies, with their undeniably Christmassy aroma, remind you it’s a special time of the year, and for that they fulfil their role as a Christmas food tradition. 

Whether you guzzle gravy or put away potatoes, your food has been through a lot to make it onto your table – so forget the Queen’s speech and tune into your food come Friday. 

Image credit: Wikimedia Commons.

SU criticises colleges’ reduction of vacation residence

0

Some colleges are reducing the availability of residence for students over the Michaelmas vacation. Oxford SU is lobbying to ensure international students are guaranteed accommodation for those who wish to remain, and has criticised the impact on care leavers, estranged students, and independent students.

Oxford SU passed a motion in 3rd week resolving to ask the University to guarantee all international student residence in Oxford over the vacation. The SU also resolves to push for vacation residence to be offered at 15% of usual vacation rent.

College policies do not currently fulfil Oxford SU’s requests. St John’s College has said that their vacation residence and grant scheme “will not operate as usual” during this vacation. All students have to leave, except international students whose home borders are closed and students with extended terms for their subjects.  

St John’s told students that this was to ensure staff get a break from a difficult term, and students get a break to spend some time in a “different environment” before next year.

Queen’s College emailed students saying they “strongly urge” and “expect” all UK-domiciled students to return, noting that for students with welfare concerns, the welfare services would be closed for a period over the vacation.  

They also told international students that the requirement to quarantine in their home country and in the UK is “unlikely” to be a “compelling reason” to be granted vacation residence. Queen’s said that, if borders for students’ home countries are closed, students should consider asking friends to stay at their homes. Queen’s reminded students that “there is no automatic right to stay in College”.

Oxford SU Class Act Campaign told Cherwell: “This is an issue not only for international students, but also for care leavers, estranged students, and independent students. Colleges consistently fail to provide these students with security, instead leaving individuals to negotiate with them for the right to have somewhere to stay. This is a difficult situation for everyone, but many students call Oxford their home, and must not be forgotten in this pandemic.”

One anonymous student told Cherwell: “The vacation residence policy email I received from my college was a disappointing read that placed unnecessary anxiety upon estranged students. For some of us, home life is not safe: it does not matter if this has always been the case, or if this is recent. Trinity Term lockdown was hard enough to suffer because students from other colleges were able to return – hopefully we can stay this time.

“I, like many other students, am incredibly grateful for my time at Oxford because of the freedom it gives me. It is also one of the reasons students take advantage of the vacation residence system: escape. To put it plainly, studying in college is better than working at home. We already try so hard to learn to live independently, study efficiently and strike that balance needed to be happy that if we are forced back into our older unhealthy environments no good will come of it.”

Oxford SU will further ask the University to ensure students who are required to quarantine upon return to Oxford get free accommodation, and receive food at the average price of their college’s home food.

Students who were required to quarantine upon arrival at the beginning of Michaelmas faced very varied college policies. Oxford SU’s motion stated that students were “in some cases charged extortionate rates for their accommodation”. 
Cherwell reported at the beginning of the term that Oriel College charged self-isolating international students over £700, including a nearly £30 per day food bill. Some colleges, including Hertford, Magdalen, Queen’s, and Worcester College, made accommodation free.

Image credit: Simononly/ Wikimedia Commons

Oxford University’s ties to nuclear weapons industry revealed

0

Freedom of Information requests submitted by Cherwell have revealed that Oxford University accepted at least £726,706 from the Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE), the designer and producer of the UK’s nuclear warheads, during the years 2017-19 alone.

The majority of this money was awarded to the Oxford Centre for High Energy Density Science (OxCHEDS), which advertises AWE as one of its “national partners” on its website.

AWE’s funding is mostly used by OxCHEDS to fund individual research projects and studentships, with a substantial portion (£82,863 in 2019) funding the department’s William Penney Fellowship, named after the head of the British delegation for the Manhattan Project and ‘father of the British atomic bomb’. According to the AWE website, William Penney Fellows “act as ambassadors for AWE in the scientific and technical communities in which they operate”.

This fellowship is currently shared by two professors, Justin Wark and Peter Norreys, both of whom collaborate closely with US state laboratories that develop nuclear weapons, the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and the Los Alamos National Laboratory.

AWE donations have also funded projects at the University’s Departments of Chemistry, Engineering, and Physics, a number of which are directly linked to the design of nuclear weapons. One AWE-funded paper, published in 2019, investigated fusion yield production, a vital way of testing the destructive power of a warhead prior to manufacturing, whilst another project researched methods used by nuclear weapons designers for simulating the interior of a detonating warhead.

This research also has civilian applications, and does not in itself point towards the development of nuclear weapons. A spokesperson from Oxford University stated: “Oxford University research is academically driven, with the ultimate aim of enhancing openly available scholarship and knowledge. All research projects with defence sector funding advance general scientific understanding, with a wide range of subsequent civilian applications, as well as potential application by the sector.”

However, AWE is not a civilian organisation. As Andrew Smith of Campaign Against the Arms Trade told Cherwell, “the AWE exists to promote the deadliest weaponry possible. It is not funding these projects because it cares about education, but because it wants to benefit from the research and association that goes with it”. Mr. Smith concluded: “Oxford University should be leading by example, not providing research and cheap labour for the arms industry”.

Responding to Cherwell’s findings, Dr Stuart Parkinson, Director of Scientists for Global Responsibility, described Oxford University’s ties with AWE as “shocking” and called for the work to be “terminated immediately”. He said that the findings “point very clearly to Oxford University researchers being involved in the development of weapons of mass destruction”.

In the face of this criticism, the University spokesperson claimed: “All research funders must first pass ethical scrutiny and be approved by the University’s Committee to Review Donations and Research Funding. This is a robust, independent system, which takes legal, ethical and reputational issues into consideration.”

However, there are growing concerns over the ethics and efficacy of this process, which has seen controversial donations from the Sackler family, Wafic Saïd, and Stephen Schwarzman given the green light despite internal and public protests. The committee’s deliberations are frequently subject to Non-Disclosure Agreements, meaning that they are not accountable to members of the University and to the wider public. Moreover, Freedom of Information requests submitted earlier this year revealed that the committee accepts over 95% of the funding it considers, with congregation members describing the committee as a “smokescreen” and a “fig leaf”.

In recent years, the University has faced increased opposition from student groups such as the Oxford Climate Justice Campaign and Oxford Against Schwarzman over the companies Oxford chooses to affiliate itself with through investments and donations. From this term onwards, a newly formed student group, Disarm Oxford, will be campaigning against the University’s numerous ties with the arms industry. Oxford Amnesty International is working with Disarm Oxford on the global Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, and to strive for the disarmament of the University more broadly.

Dr Rowan Williams, the former Archbishop of Canterbury and Chair of the Trustees of the Council for the Defence of British Universities, told Cherwell: “The recent publicity around university divestment from fossil fuels has highlighted the need for university bodies to be transparent about the ethical standards they apply to their funding, and it is encouraging to see this crucial question being raised also in the context of armaments-related funds and research.”

The combination of Brexit and the coronavirus pandemic has created a particularly difficult time for university research finances. In a marketised higher education system, seeking and welcoming money from industry partnerships seems like an inevitability. However, while some industries rely on academic research to save lives, others are predicated on taking them. With the UK confirmed this year as the world’s second biggest exporter of arms, the University’s significant ties to the development of weaponry has an alarming global significance which is now beginning to be called into question.

Oxford University leads ‘breakthrough’ in coronavirus treatment

A trial led by Oxford University has discovered that dexamethasone, a cheap steroid, can help reduce deaths in seriously ill COVID-19 patients.

The drug reduced the risk of death by one-third for patients on ventilators and by one-fifth for patients on oxygen.

Oxford University says: “Based on these results, 1 death would be prevented by treatment of around 8 ventilated patients or around 25 patients requiring oxygen alone.”

Chief Medical Officer Professor Chris Whitty has described it as “the most important trial result for COVID-19 so far”.

The British government has immediately authorised use of the drug in the NHS, saying “thousands of lives will be saved”. The government has secured supplies of dexamethasone in the UK, meaning there is already treatment for over 200,000 people.

Prime Minister Boris Johnson has said this is “a remarkable British scientific achievement” and that the government “have taken steps to ensure we have enough supplies, even in the event of a second peak”.

It was discovered as part of the RECOVERY trial, the Randomised Evaluation of COVID-19 Therapy, which has involved over 11,500 patients at over 175 NHS hospitals in the UK.  

About 2000 hospital patients were given 6mg of dexamethasone per day and compared with more than 4,000 who were not.

For patients on ventilators, it cut the risk of death from 41% to 28%. For patients needing oxygen, it cut the risk of death from 25% to 20%.

The drug costs £5.40 per day and treatment takes up to 10 days. Professor Martin Landray, one of the Chief Investigators, has said: “So essentially it costs £35 to save a life.”

Chief investigator Peter Horby has said: “This is the only drug so far that has been shown to reduce mortality – and it reduces it significantly. It’s a major breakthrough.”

The UK Government’s Chief Scientific Adviser, Sir Patrick Vallance, said: “This is tremendous news today from the RECOVERY trial showing that dexamethasone is the first drug to reduce mortality from COVID-19. It is particularly exciting as this is an inexpensive widely available medicine. This is a ground-breaking development in our fight against the disease, and the speed at which researchers have progressed finding an effective treatment is truly remarkable. It shows the importance of doing high quality clinical trials and basing decisions on the results of those trials.”

Peter Horby, Professor of Emerging Infectious Diseases in the Nuffield Department of Medicine and one of the Chief Investigators for the trial, said: “Dexamethasone is the first drug to be shown to improve survival in COVID-19. This is an extremely welcome result. The survival benefit is clear and large in those patients who are sick enough to require oxygen treatment, so dexamethasone should now become standard of care in these patients. Dexamethasone is inexpensive, on the shelf, and can be used immediately to save lives worldwide.”

Martin Landray, Professor of Medicine and Epidemiology at the Nuffield Department of Population Health, University of Oxford, one of the Chief Investigators, said: “Since the appearance of COVID-19 six months ago, the search has been on for treatments that can improve survival, particularly in the sickest patients. These preliminary results from the RECOVERY trial are very clear – dexamethasone reduces the risk of death among patients with severe respiratory complications. COVID-19 is a global disease – it is fantastic that the first treatment demonstrated to reduce mortality is one that is instantly available and affordable worldwide.”

Image credit to Pixabay.

Self-isolated student diagnosed with Covid-19

0

Public Health England (PHE) has confirmed that a student at the University of Oxford has tested positive for coronavirus (Covid-19) after returning home from a specified country.

The university has said that “Our immediate concerns are for the affected student and their family, along with the health and wellbeing of our university staff, students and visitors. The student is being offered all necessary support.”

The university has established that the affected student did not attend any university or college events after they felt ill, when they subsequently self-isolated. 

PHE has advised that the risk to other students and staff is very low and that university and college activities can continue as normal. They have also advised that the university and colleges do not need to take any additional public health actions in the light of this specific case.

A university spokesperson has said “We have worked with PHE to make sure that anyone who was in contact with the student after they fell ill have been notified and that they are able to access support and information as needed. PHE do not consider individuals infectious until they develop symptoms.”

The university is providing support for students, staff, and the wider community.

The University is sharing further updates on the current infection at  www.ox.ac.uk/coronavirus-advice.

BREAKING: Oxford announces record state school offers

0

Oxford University has announced that more than 69% of undergraduate offers have been made to students attending state schools. The increase of 4.6% is the “best percentage increase the University has ever seen.”

30.9% of offers were made to students from independent schools; this is over 12% higher than the 18% of students who attend independent sixth forms, according to the Sutton Trust (2018), and dramatically higher than the 7% of all UK students attending independent schools. 

78% of offers were made to UK applicants, 7% to EU applicants and 15% to Overseas applicants. The University specifies that ‘UK applicants are more likely to receive an offer.’ 

The University was unable to provide a breakdown of the split between Grammar, Comprehensive, Academy and other forms of state schools as they do not currently collect that data. The data on the inter-state school split is not published in the University’s annual data report either, however the May 2019 access report published by the University highlighted that ‘In 2018, 11.3% of UK students admitted to Oxford came from the two most socioeconomically disadvantaged groups (ACORN categories 4 and 56).’

Oxford’s successful UNIQ programme has led to 250 students being made offers this year. The offer rate to students who attended UNIQ programmes is 33.6%, in contrast to the offer rate of 21.5% across UK applicants. The increase in offers to UNIQ participants comes after the expansion of the scheme last year, which saw more than 1,350 pupils take part in the programme – an increase of 50%. This is the largest number of UNIQ participants to receive offers in the programme’s history, thanks to the dramatic development in 2019. 

This year, Students from POLAR4 quintile 1 accounted for 6.4% of UK offers – up by 1.4%. These students represent the areas with the lowest progression to higher education.

Dr Samina Khan, Director of Undergraduate Admissions and Outreach at Oxford, said: “We are delighted by this record number of offers to state school students, and to students from under-represented backgrounds. This creates a strong foundation for what we aim to achieve. We know that students from some backgrounds are not as well-represented at Oxford as they should be, and we are determined that this should change. Having taught in state schools during my career, I know the wealth of talent that lies there. We wish the students every success in their studies, and hope they flourish at Oxford.”

The number of offers made to young people from areas with the lowest progression rates to higher education have increased. Students from POLAR4 quintile 1 accounted for 6.4% of UK offers – up by 1.4% from 2019 offers.

In 2015 the University made 56.7% of their offers to students from state schools. Across the past five years, there has been an increase of 12.4% in state school offers. This comes after pioneering Oxford schemes have taken place, from the UNIQ programmes to Lady Margaret Hall’s Foundation Year and University College’s bridging scheme. It also coincides with the University’s formation of the Foundation Oxford and Opportunity Oxford schemes.

Opportunity Oxford launched at the end of the previous academic year, and this week more than 100 candidates from under-represented backgrounds received offers to study as a part of the scheme. Dr Andrew Bell, Coordinator of Oppertunity Oxford and University College Senior Tutor, has stated:

“Opportunity Oxford is a major new initiative to increase the number of offers made to UK students from under-represented backgrounds, and to provide academic support to those students to ensure that they have the best possible start to their university careers. This year, more than 100 offers have been made under the scheme across 28 colleges. We anticipate making 200 offers per year under the scheme from 2022 onwards. We’re really excited to have launched Opportunity Oxford, and we very much look forward to welcoming our first cohort to Oxford later this year.”

This article was updated at 20:02 15.1.20 to clarify POLAR.

Further clarification was made at 00:11, 16.1.19 concerning Opportunity Oxford.

Kiss My Genders – Celebrating identity with the Hayward Gallery

0

“Look.” A voice whispers – slowly, sensually.

White curtains quiver in the non-existent breeze that haunts the clinical interior of the Hayward gallery. With that slight movement, too, the image projected onto the curtain sways – Victoria Sin’s wide eyes flicker involuntarily as the camera slowly zooms into their face. In sparkling lingerie and full drag inspired by Cantonese opera, the model, laid out demurely across a satin curtain, stares back at the starers; sometimes sultry, sometimes vulnerable, always, somehow, piercing.

“Look. Look. Look – At her.”  

Victoria Sin’s A View from Elsewhere, Act 1, and She Postures in Context, three film-art pieces projected onto a curtain-enclosure, embody the spirit of the Hayward’s latest exhibition Kiss My Genders. The exhibition, made up of over a hundred artworks by thirty different international artists, centres around gender identity and fluidity. Physically enclosing their viewers in the wavering medium of cloth and projection, Sin appears to comment on the insubstantiality of gender boundaries, but in subverting perspective and viewing experience, also draws attention to the role of performance, presentation and spectatorship in all elements of identity. Hayward claims the exhibition focuses on “content and forms that challenge accepted or stable definitions of gender.” Paintings of hunter-gatherer tribes with drag elements question the West’s suppression of third-gender narratives, while sculptures made of artificial oestrogen and testosterone break down, biologically, what it means to be “male” or “female”.

But more than just gender identity, the exhibits are an expression of the individuality and the internal or cultural conflicts of the artists. Amrou Al-Kadhi teams up with Holly Falconer to explore what he describes as the “disorienting” experience of being drag as a person of Muslim heritage by modelling as drag persona Glamrou wrapped in a Persian carpet. Cloned in different poses through triple exposure to express the incongruence of these disparate cultures, Al-Kadhi demonstrates their successful unification in the persona of Glamrou. Meanwhile Juliana Huxtable’s photographic self-portraits deflect identity-labels entirely; using makeup, costumes and fantasy backgrounds, she deflects the reductive categorizations ascribed to her as a “black intersex artist” by creating personalized embodiments of mythology, sci-fi and super-heroes. Kiss My Genders thereby becomes an exploration not only of the boundaries perceived in gender – but of individuals’ cultural identity experiences.

With this exhibition, an art assistant explains, the Hayward is attempting to break the mould of LGBTQ+ and gender-related exhibitions, which often focus on the violence and oppression experienced by these communities. Instead they want to celebrate different identities. Nonetheless, the exhibition is palpably political: Zanele Muholi explores black lesbian and transgender experiences in South Africa through photography – and acts of violence are still an all too present component of that. In her series Crime Scenes she stages the aftermath of brutal murders, photographing the upturned feet of model corpses buried in sheets of plastic and litter. Paintings like YESSIR! Back off! Tell me who I am, again? combine illustration and collage to satirize the way gender transition is spoken about. The artist, Flo Brooks, depicts a fictional cleaning company scrubbing away at a therapist’s room, reflecting his experience of the “hygienic spaces” he experienced while transitioning; “spaces designed to clean, conceal and correct” things socially considered “dirty, abnormal or other” – but also addresses the way transgender issues are generalised and “sterilized” through neat clinical terms. Artists in Kiss My Genders marry the intensely personal with the social, emotional with the playful, and at the same time evoke all the contrasting feelings of pride, comfort, fear, frustration, belonging and exclusion.

The exhibition succeeds in its “celebration” and “expression” of identities – but the presentation, at times, is confusing. The works of some artists are split across multiple floors, the labelling unclear, and it is generally worth asking the art assistants to talk you through the rooms – difficult, when the gallery is at its busiest and a shame for an exhibition set on “opening doors.” Perhaps this is all the more noticeable as the exhibition appears to be catered towards an audience that identifies with binary genders – many of the artworks require the context of the theme or artist in order to be appreciated. Often, however, this is used in a positive way; many of the exhibits are truly thought provoking.

Most strikingly, Something for the Boys takes us through a spiral of ruched curtains in metallic pink – as if we are walking into a private adult show, yet at the same time, as if we were walking onto a stage. In the centre of the spiral we find ourselves in a circular womb-like room with a screen. Cutting between various LGBTQ+ spaces in Blackpool, the projected film shows an increasing disconnect between sound and image; a drag queen mouthing to “I am who I am” off-sync, interjected with a club-dance choreography, stills of gay clubs, the camera panning over pornographic videos and fetish-wear, and back to the drag queen – except this time she just mouths, and all we can hear is industrial sounds – once again connecting gender-identity and sexuality to cultural identity as a whole. But there is also something intimately performative about the display – the gesticulations and dances, unhinged from their appropriate music, seem to point to a theme of performance and spectatorship at large. And suddenly, that circular room no longer feels like a private theatre. It starts to feel like a stage, and the question crosses our minds – who is really the performer here, the drag act, or us, playing up to our female/male expectations? Just as Victoria Sin’s insistent murmurs, Kiss My Genders seduces its audience into truly looking – and becoming aware of the instability of their perspective in the process.

This year’s NUS conference – how your delegates voted

0

The National Union of Student’s annual conference took place between Tuesday and Friday of this week. Five of Oxford’s seven elected delegates were present and voting in Glasgow, with two not voting on any motions.

The voting records of all delegates are available for viewing online, whilst a list of the motions discussed over the three day event can be found here.

This conference saw the election of Zamzam Ibrahim as NUS President. Ibrahim, the former president of the Salford University students’ union, vowed in her manifesto to hold a National Student Strike, calling for free education, an improved student maintenance allowance and the return of the post-study work visa for overseas students.

Among the motions discussed, Oxford SU delegates voted to support the Mental Health Charter. This would seek to improve standards of mental health provision and funding across universities, acknowledging alarming rates of student suicide and the ongoing “mental health crisis”.

All Oxford delegates voted against the motion to revoke gender quotas within the SU. The proposer highlighted the now-increased presence of women in the organisation, since the rule’s creation in 2014, as well as the potential harm to non- binary individuals that a 50% female quota poses. The last 5 NUS presidents have identified as female, with racial discrimination featuring more often than gender inequality in this year’s manifestoes.

The conference itself was marked from the outset by sitting president Shakira Martin’s admission of the NUS’s financial trouble. Telling the conference that “we should have run out of cash”, Martin stated: “We are having problems that we need to sort out”.

This follows the November announcement that the NUS was unable to pay off a £3m deficit, cutting half of its jobs as a result. However, all Oxford delegates voted against a review of the NUS’s finances.

Closer to home, Oxford SU is continuing the hunt for a VP for Charities and Community, a position unfilled by Hilary term’s election. President Joe Inwood also penned a letter this month, calling for the university to revoke the honorary degree given to the Sultan of Brunei.

Oxford SU has been contacted for comment on the proceedings.

Tracey Emin’s A Fortnight of Tears: an unflinching study of the haunting power of trauma

It is a Sunday and some weeks since Tracey Emin’s latest London solo show at White Cube Bermondsey first opened to the public. Yet the people of south-east London have emerged in droves, so that at lunchtime the gallery is still milling with visitors – the fullest I have ever seen it. It is testament to the magnetism and celebrity of an artist like Emin that people continue to flock so dutifully to the austere, white-lit and grey-walled gallery to see a show entitled A Fortnight of Tears, when outside it is one of the sunniest days of the year so far. Outside, the faint hum of pop music floats down from the nearby park, while a yellow Labrador lolls out into the sunshine on the corner opposite. The scenes inside Emin’s exhibition, however, tell a starkly different story. 

Emin’s show is a broadly autobiographical survey of love and loss. It is a tour de force in sculpture, neon, painting, film, photography, and drawing. The artist’s uncanny ability to stage life’s ordinary tragedies, and to be entirely candid about the experience of female pain, is on display as masterfully as ever in the demanding spaces of the White Cube. Decades of dirty laundry are paraded through the gallery; the horrors of a 1990 botched abortion, rape, and the death of her mother are the dominant topics of expression. Though much of the language and subject matter has been a constant throughout her career, it is evident that Emin has come some way from her days as a party-girl enfant terrible of contemporary British art. There is a discernible grown-upness about this exhibition; familiar, ugly subjects are returned to with a new seriousness and sensitivity, though the bite is doubtless still there.

The South Gallery I houses ‘Insomnia Room Installation’. Huge Gilcée print iPhone selfies of the artist reveal a tormented Emin in various states of physical and mental injury over four years of sleepless nights. The pictures are double hung almost up to the ceiling in a manner that falls somewhere between a teenage girl’s bedroom and a French salon. Unframed and pinned in each corner, they lift off the wall slightly, a pencil signature just visible on each bottom-right corner. We are invited to share the unhappy bed. As the first room of the show this sets the tone for the rest: sad, intimate, and earnest.

Alongside the ‘finished’ works further on in the gallery, four cases containing sketches and writings on paper, maquettes, and memorabilia are exhibited from the artist’s archive. These sketches – some on notepad pages branded with the names of hotels – are reminiscent of those doodles we draw out on paper absent-mindedly, while taking a phone call or sitting in a lecture. They have a day-to-day feel about them. The cabinets are organised thematically under the topics of love, sex, death, and fear. Indeed, these are the subjects to which the artist returns obsessively, and which percolate through every room of the gallery, bleeding into each other at the edges.

Paintings around the cabinets line the wall like the Stations of the Cross. But Emin’s protagonist keeps falling down, stumbling with her proverbial cross with little sense of any eventual redemption. We are inclined to believe that these are self-portraits, though the women’s faces are almost always obscured. Emin’s girls have soft, protruding (pregnant?) bellies, clubbed feet and hands, blurry faces, and masses of dark pubic hair. The viewer is struck by the way that the swollen nipples, breasts, and genitals always seem to be most in focus.

‘I Watched You Disappear. Pink Ghost’ is the first picture in a brilliant triptych of portraits in the Ashes Room. Blurred as if captured through tears, steam, or the fogging lens of memory, a soft rosy body floats behind the canvas, which itself perhaps imitates a shower curtain. To the right a painting about the death of Emin’s mother, ‘I Was Too Young to be Carrying Your Ashes’ ruptures any impression of shy, warm womanhood that might have been offered by that tipsy pink. Thick red paint then erupts through the curtain-canvas; with a sudden and regrettable violence, this is the moment the Hitchcockian knife wielder plunges his weapon. The picture is an open wound, a bloody, weeping sore. ‘You Were Still There’ then resuscitates a dissected body. The womb is darkened with movement like the impact of a punch. The colours shift throughout from the pink-red blushes of the Madonna to the grey blackish-blue bruised body of Christ. A punishing and merciless life-cycle is acted out.

Emin proves herself here as a painter and a sculptor of bodies, rather than figures; her subjects are not idealised forms that exist outside of the self, but those that are an extension of it. In the best of these works, the intimate understanding of the body and of a personal psychology comes out beautifully raw. They are positioned firmly within the artist’s own identity, and in the bodily violence that is the source of so much of her trauma. The bodies that Emin paints are much better than the large sculptures that dominate the space because they still feel alive – trapped between soft and hard lines, pushed and pulled and beaten out on canvas and paper. Corporeal suffering is not only acted onto the body, but oozes out from within it into art.

Love, desire, and violence are intimately linked in Emin’s world. The interactions between bodies in the paintings are like the kiss in Giotto’s frescoes, where two faces collide into one, eyes open; somehow unromantic, while still wholly passionate. The word ‘longing’ seems to have come up in titles and prose again and again throughout the exhibition. In her 1996 film How It Feels – a fitting endnote to the show – Emin comments on her abortion: “I will never really get over it”. This sits at the core of all the artwork – the wanting, the not getting, and the not getting over.

“What this whole show is about is releasing myself from shame. I’ve killed my shame, I’ve hung it on the walls,” Emin claims. Women wracked with grief and desire, aching and desperate, contort themselves with it, she seems to be saying. Everything is deeply felt and then neatly hung up. The exhibition is entitled A Fortnight of Tears because, Emin claims, that is the longest she has ever cried. For all its wailing and thrashing, this grieving process has produced an exhibition of staggering emotional complexity.

Oxford Professor criticises use of gender hormones as “unregulated live experiment on children”

0

Content warning: transphobia

An Oxford University professor has come under public scrutiny after contributing to a front page story in the Times criticising the use of hormone blockers on young people as “an unregulated live experiment on children.”

Professor Carl Heneghan, a fellow at Kellogg College and the director of the Centre of Evidence-Based Medicine, provided a comment piece to the newspaper as a supplement to an investigation into the Gender Identity Development Service Clinic, which the Times described as “the only NHS gender clinic for children”.

Professor Heneghan’s appeal was made on the basis of medical skepticism over the practice, writing that: “the majority of drugs in use are frequently supported by low-quality evidence about their use beyond the usual age for puberty, or in many cases no evidence at all”.

The piece to which Professor Heneghan contributed sparked a significant outrage, with prominent figures criticising the Times for its coverage. MP for Cardiff South Stephen Doughty tweeted: “It’s not just the shocking 1980s style headline – @thetimes @TimesLucy have given us a bumper edition of prejudice against the #Trans community today. Do they have *any* idea or even care about the harm this risks causing?”.

Speaking to Cherwell, Professor Heneghan stood by his comments, saying: “the development of these interventions should occur in the context of research. Treatments for under 18 gender dysphoric children and adolescents remain largely experimental.

“There are a large number of unanswered questions that include the age at start, reversibility; adverse events, long term effects on mental health, quality of life, bone mineral density, osteoporosis in later life and cognition.”

Responding to the issue for Cherwell, transgender campaigner Fox Fisher wrote: “The University of Oxford has a responsibility to make sure all students feel safe to attend the school – behaviour of this sort should never be tolerated and jeopardises the well-being of students and the integrity of the institution.

“Look at any modern research in anthropology, sociology, biology, psychology or psychiatry – all indicates that trans children benefit massively from being allowed to express themselves.”

In a public statement regarding the article, the Oxford Student Union LGBTQ+ Campaign condemned the article and urged both members of the LGBTQ+ Community and its allies to launch official complaints to the Independent Press Standards Organisation (ISPO).

The statement read: “Transphobic, fear-mongering articles being given priority in national news is unacceptable. Although the article includes information and statements from the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) that refutes its own main line of argument, emphasis is still placed upon unsupported and dangerous viewpoints.

“The prominence of this article within the issue of The Times clearly means to stir up misinformation which will exacerbate the difficulties transgender and gender nonconforming children and teenagers face in the UK.

“The article additionally relies on a statement from Carl Heneghan, who is a senior tutor at Kellogg College. His words attempt to give credibility to a transphobic rhetoric which is harmful to transgender people both within and outside of the University. It is deeply concerning that Dr Heneghan’s attempt to sow confusion about the treatment of trans children by conflating different treatment methods and rejecting information from the GIDS itself is being legitimised by the name of the University in this way.

“Conspicuously absent from both pieces are the voices of transgender people who have used the services provided by GIDS. Ignoring the perspective of the people who matter most in this issue, transgender children, is entirely unbalanced reporting.

“As such, both pieces fail to contribute to any kind of representative discussion on gender dysphoria, perpetuating only a transphobic editorial line.”

This article will be updated as we receive more information.

OUWAFC take on the Tabs

0

On a sunny but very windy afternoon on Sunday 10th March, the Women’s Football Blues faced Cambridge in their annual Varsity match at the Hive Stadium in Barnet. The stakes were high – with their BUCS season drawing to a close, this game was the climax the team had been preparing for all season. Perhaps the fact that Oxford had already faced Cambridge twice in their BUCS run this season made the competition even fiercer; a 0-0 draw between the two sides in late January demonstrated that Varsity was either team’s for the taking.

Both teams got out of the blocks fast at the start of the game, making for an exciting first half. Although Cambridge did seem threatening at times and were putting Oxford under a lot of pressure by playing a particularly high line, the Dark Blues were able to keep them at bay and captain Lucy Harper led her defence well to snuff out any hope of glory for the Cambridge attack.

Oxford were equally keen to apply the pressure in the Cambridge half and wingers Erin Robinson and Katie Plummer made some great runs down the pitch which were difficult for the Light Blues cut out. However, with the Oxford forwards often being found offside, it was hard for them to break the deadlock and consequently the teams went into halftime with the score still at 0-0.

However, early in the second half, Cambridge were able to break Oxford’s resolve, and after a fumble in the box the ball came out to the edge of the area for Cambridge’s Ashcroft to propel a shot into the top right of the goal and put the Light Blues ahead. Two minutes later, the Tabs extended their lead after a corner that was not cleared up by the Oxford defence.

Despite this, Oxford did not let their heads go down and the next ten minutes of the game were extremely tense, with the Dark Blues desperately trying to close the gap between the two teams. Eventually, first-year duo Taiye Lawal and Rani Wermes were able to link up in Cambridge’s box, before Wermes went down from a foul and earned Oxford a penalty. Substitute Monique Pedroza stood up to the plate and smashed the ball high into the net to put Oxford level, much to the delight of the Dark Blue crowd.

Unfortunately for the Oxford team, as the match drew on they were unable to find any more luck in the Cambridge half, and at the other end of the pitch, Cambridge were awarded a penalty from a rather dubious handball and were able to make it 3-1, effectively sealing the deal and winning the game.

As the final whistle blew, Oxford were clearly filled with despair over their loss. However, such a valiant performance gave them much to be proud of, and the Dark Blues will be hoping to work harder than ever next season to claim back the trophy.

Despite this loss, the Women’s Reserves (the Furies) were able to find success against Cambridge Reserves (the Eagles) on home turf at Iffley on Saturday of 7th Week. The Furies found themselves 1-0 up after a through ball from Jasmine Savage reached the feet of captain Rebecca North who slotted the ball firmly in the back of the Cambridge net. However shortly after, Cambridge managed to breach Oxford’s defence, and after a two on one situation with Oxford’s last woman, were able to equalise with a short range shot on goal.

Going into the break the score remained 1-1, but neither team had any luck in the second half either, meaning at the end of the 90 minutes, the game went straight to penalties. The tension in the stadium was riding high, but Oxford kept their cool. After four goals from four Furies and three goals and a miss from Cambridge, the final Eagles penalty taker was hoping to keep her team in the game. However it was not to be, and an admittedly easy save from goalkeeper Emmie Halfpenny saw the Furies win Varsity for the second time in a row.

As the whole of the Oxford team sprinted from halfway to celebrate with their keeper, it was easy to see just how much this Varsity win meant for the Furies, who had worked so hard throughout the season for this moment.

With one cup spending a year at The Other Place, and the other cup held firmly in Oxford’s hands, all we can do now is wait until next year to see if OUWAFC are able to do the double over Cambridge.

OULC chairs accused of ‘misleading and unfair’ conduct over attempt to control club’s relationship with the media

0

The co-chairs of Oxford University Labour Club have issued a statement to committee members demanding that all contact with the student press be approved by the executive, Cherwell can reveal.

Aiming to centralise the executive’s control over the club’s relationship with student media, the co-chairs recently claimed that committee members were constitutionally required to consult the co-chairs on statements to the press.

In a message sent to members of the club’s committee, co-chair Grace Davies said: “If any of you guys are approached by OxStu or Cherwell please please [sic] let us know.

“We’re keen to have a say in all communication going to the media and the constitution says that you should consult the co-chairs – I’ll be quite sad if I see peoples quotes in papers and me and Arya didn’t know about it first.”

Despite Davies’ claims that it is a constitutional requirement for members to consult the co-chairs before approaching the press, Cherwell could find no evidence of such a rule in the club’s constitution.

The club’s co-chairs responded to a request for comment by claiming “The comment regarding consulting co-chairs was intended to extend to, but only to, members of the club speaking on behalf of the club. The position of co-chair is the only position which has the mandate and official capacity to speak on behalf of the club.

“There was no intention to limit comments to press when speaking on individuals’ own behalf and in a personal capacity, and the intention was instead that any comments made officially by the club were decided by the entire committee, with both co-chairs being able to gauge the position of the entire club.

“Individual members of the OULC executive making comments on behalf of the club, does not follow the convention of the Labour Club, and can lead to confusion about the official position of the club.”

“We’re upset that a member of the club felt it was an attempt to censor their personal expressions of their views and would reassure them that this in no way our intention.”

“The publicity officer is elected to manage media and communications, and as such their role is to oversee comments made to the press, working alongside the co-chairs.

“This is a well established convention. Whenever possible, we try to reach agreement about statements to the press within the OULC committee so that the entire committee has a say in our official position, rather than individuals who do not have the mandate to decide OULC’s official position to the press. 

“The established interpretation of the constitution and other documents referred to in the constitution, is that only co-chairs can be ultimately responsible for any pronouncements made on behalf of the club.”

Despite this claim, no mention is made of members speaking on the club’s behalf in the original message.

One OULC member, speaking anonymously, told Cherwell that: “Though of course I understand why the Labour chairs want to centralise a lot of communication to the press, to act as though it is a formal rule is misleading and unfair.

“Moreover, on certain issues the ability to voice dissent via the press is valuable, and the Labour club will ultimately be weaker for the absence of honest disagreement with the party line.”

Oxford Boat Clubs announce crews for April’s race

0

Oxford University Boat Club (OUBC) and Women’s Boat Club (OUWBC) this morning confirmed their crews at the City Hall, London for next month’s Boat Races.

The Men’s boat is identical to the crew that was named for last weekend’s fixture against Oxford Brookes, a race that was postponed due to high winds.

The crew weighs in at 719.6kg, 19.6 kilos lighter than the 2018 crew but nonetheless a shade heavier than their Cambridge counterparts, who weighed in at 718.3kg.

In the Women’s boat Oxford will concede roughly a 10kg swing, with the boat tipping the scales at 568.8kg compared to the 578.3kg of the CUWBC.

OUWBC will head into the race with 2 returning members of last year’s defeated crew, naming both Beth Bridgman of St Hugh’s and Keble’s Renée Koolschijn, although both have shifted position in the boat, with Bridgman moving from Stroke to position 6, and Koolschijn from Bow to position 3.

The situation is mirrored in the Men’s boat as OUBC president Felix Drinkall and Christ Church student Benedict Aldous – who last year replaced Joshua Bugajski at the eleventh hour in a decision shrouded by illness – are the only survivors in a youthful-looking crew.

The average age of the Oxford Men’s boat is 21.8 years-old, a historically low figure accentuated by the presence of four undergraduate scientists in the aforementioned duo of Drinkall and Aldous, as well as Charlie Pearson and Tobias Schroder.

This is in stark contrast with the CUBC crew, who sport an average age of 26.3, after the decision to include two-time Olympic gold medallist James Cracknell in the boat. Cracknell qualifies for selection as he is studying for an MPhil in Human Evolutionary Studies at Peterhouse College, floating the idea on Twitter as early as July 2018 alongside the hashtag “#NeverTooOld”.

The OUWBC crew have an average age of 23.9 years-old, slightly younger than the 24.3 years-old of the Cambridge Women’s crew.

The Light Blues comprehensively swept all 4 races last year, including a first victory in eight years for the Cambridge reserve boat Goldie over Isis, a dominance hitherto unseen since the move to stage each race on the same tideway in 2015.

Cambridge now lead the standings in the Men’s race 83-80, whilst they boast a greater advantage in the Women’s race, notching 43 to Oxford’s 30.

This year’s Boat Races take place on Sunday 7th April, with the Women’s race commencing at 2:15pm, followed by the Men’s race an hour later at 3:15pm.

The bookmaker William Hill has priced up the Men’s Race on their website, rating it a closely-fought affair, going 8/11 about Oxford and evens for Cambridge, with the possibility of a dead heat rated a 50/1 chance.

OUBC Crew:

Bow: Achim Harzeim, Oriel, 26yo, 88kg

2: Ben Landis, Lincoln, 24yo, 82kg

3: Patrick Sullivan, Wadham, 23yo, 92kg

4: Benedict Aldous, Christ Church, 21yo, 94kg

5: Tobias Schroder, Magdalen, 19yo, 94kg

6: Felix Drinkall, LMH, 19yo, 84kg

7: Charlie Pearson, Trinity, 20yo, 82kg

Stroke: Augustin Wambersie, Catz, 23yo, 89kg

Cox: Anna Carbery, Pembroke, 21yo, 54kg

OUWBC Crew:

Bow: Issy Dodds, Hertford, 69kg

2: Anna Murgatroyd, ChCh, 68kg

3: Renée Koolschijn, Keble, 73.8kg

4: Lizzie Polgreen, Linacre, 60.7kg

5: Tina Christmann, Worcester, 72.2kg

6: Beth Bridgman, St Hugh’s, 70.4kg

7: Liv Pryer, Teddy Hall, 77.3kg

Stroke: Amelia Standing, St Anne’s, 74kg

Cox: Eleanor Shearer, Nuffield

Corpus Christi JCR calls for Parks College plans to be stopped

0

Corpus Christi College’s JCR Executive Committee has sent an open letter to the Vice-Chancellor objecting to the proposals for a new postgraduate college. The letter argued the University had failed to engage sufficiently with University members regarding the proposals, and suggested that “this college has no goal other than increasing student numbers.”

Parks College, a new postgraduate college proposed by the University to begin accepting undergraduates in 2020, aims to “draw together researchers from different disciplines to explore some of the big scientific questions of our time.”

The new college will use the Radcliffe Science Library site as part of the library’s redevelopment. The college will also aim to provide accommodation elsewhere. The Corpus Christi Executive Committee believe that “The “co-location” of Parks College and the Radcliffe Science Library will undermine both.  Every space is temporary: a room will one day be a library, the next, a seminar room, the day after, a public exhibition.

“How can academia flourish without a permanent space? The students and fellows of Parks College will instead remain confined to their respective Departments, defeating the ideal of interdisciplinary studies.”

Students also raised concerns about their opportunities to engage with the University on the Parks College proposals. During a JCR meeting about the letter, its author, Ed Hart, said: “I think it’s important to push against the lack of communication. It is a huge project and was pushed through within three months.”

In the letter, the committee wrote: “The proposal has been made with little to no attempt to engage with University members. The proposal was first mooted in August, in the provisional 2018–23 strategic plan, and it was presumed the creation of any college would be closer to 2023 than today.

“The plan was confirmed after the end of Michaelmas term 2018, after the publication of the final Gazette of the year, preventing serious discussion of it.

“Now, it is to be rushed through Congregation, with plans to hire fellows in just three months’ time. Meanwhile, student and faculty publications fume incredulously and faculties have been left expressing surprise that an important laboratory may become a dining hall.

“We find it concerning that such a monumental decision has been made without adequate consultation of the students you claim to represent.”

The committee also raised concerns about the purpose of the college, since it does not have an overtly outreach focus.

They said: “The proposed college fails to embrace Oxford’s long history of founding colleges to include those from marginalised backgrounds and to improve the lives of those outside the College system. Consider the foundation of the women’s colleges, the foundation of Mansfield College for non-conformist Christians and the foundation of St Catherine’s and St Cross for those without college affiliation.

“Parks College fails on both counts, its website paying lip service to “[embracing] internationalism and diversity” and the benefits of college life.”

“120 years ago, Ruskin College, Oxford, was founded to expand education access to adults with few or no qualifications. It embodies many of the qualities admired in the University’s own colleges. Parks College has none of them.

“The University offers nothing – a half-hearted college, cynically preying on outsiders’ unfamiliarity with Oxford – in return for self-aggrandisement and tuition fees. This proposal demeans the University and the Colleges. It must be reconsidered.”

Responding to the letter, Professor Lionel Tarassenko, Senior Responsible Owner for the Parks College Project, said: “Parks College addresses one of the key education priorities in the University’s Strategic Plan, which is to increase the intake of graduate students across all four divisions by up to 850 a year by 2023, while maintaining quality.

“It will enable the University to grow the number of graduate students, but without upsetting the balance between undergraduate and postgraduate student numbers in mixed colleges or imposing unrealistic targets for growth in the existing graduate colleges.

“The proposed new graduate college will actively promote interdisciplinary exchanges between researchers from across the four academic divisions. It will offer graduate students a rich and stimulating intellectual and social experience, on a par with that at the other graduate colleges.

“And, as with other graduate colleges at Oxford, it will have an outward-looking and inclusive ethos, which embraces internationalism and diversity. As with St Cross College when it was founded, the Fellows of the college will be University professors and researchers who do not currently have a college affiliation.

“Far from leading to a loss of library facilities, the Parks College project presents an exciting opportunity to redevelop the science library and its services to align more closely with the needs of scientists in the 21st century – students, researchers and other academics.

“The proposals for the new college have been discussed with graduate student representatives, the staff of the Radcliffe Science Library, and at meetings of numerous University committees, including the Curators of the University Libraries, Education Committee, Conference of Colleges Graduate Committee, Conference of Colleges, Finance Committee, Personnel Committee and Council. Throughout this consultation process, the plans have been gradually evolving to take on new ideas and to ensure that concerns raised are understood and addressed.

“The plans for the new college and the allocation of space were approved by Council on 11 March, and will now be put before Congregation in early Trinity term. The OUSU VP for Graduates is a member of the Programme Board which is responsible for the development of the plans.

“We are actively encouraging students to participate in the planning for the new college. We have been running Q&A events for students in partnership with OUSU, and we are inviting students to help shape the academic blueprint of the college at a series of focus groups, which will take place in late April and early May.”

In the motion for the JCR Committee to sign the letter, the Corpus JCR President Rhiannon Ogden-Jones was also mandated to discuss the issue with other JCR presidents and the Corpus MCR to seek their support. The motion was passed with 13 votes for and 2 against.

The University have been contacted for comment.

Lord Adonis: I “can’t wait” to debate Nigel Farage at the Oxford Union

0

Cherwell can reveal that Nigel Farage is expected to speak at the Oxford Union on Thursday’s eighth week debate on Brexit.

The announcement of Farage’s appearance had not yet been made by the Oxford Union, but instead was pre-empted by Labour peer and People’s Vote supporter Andrew Adonis, who this morning tweeted: “I’m debating Nigel Farage at the Oxford Union on Friday. Can’t wait”. Given that Oxford Union debates are, under normal circumstances, held every Thursday of term, and that the Union’s term card places the Brexit debate on Thursday 7th March, it is not known whether the date announced by Lord Adonis is correct.

The specific motion that will be debated at the upcoming Brexit debate and which speakers would be attending has been kept a secret from the Union’s members throughout the term. The Oxford Union’s website has for weeks read “speakers to be announced”.

Cherwell has contacted representatives of Nigel Farage, Andrew Adonis, and the Oxford Union for comment.

It is not yet known which other speakers from the student body or elsewhere have been confirmed to speak at the event.

Along with the Union debate, Adonis also announced on Twitter he would be speaking at Leeds, Eddisbury, Oxford, Llanelli, Swansea, and Wrexham in the upcoming week.

The Oxford Union organised a now-famous debate on Britain’s membership of a European community in 1975, two days before the referendum which saw Britain’s voters consent to membership of the EEC. Speakers in proposition included Edward Heath and Jeremy Thorpe, while Barbara Castle and Peter Shaw spoke in opposition.

More on this story is expected to follow.

Controversy over Pride flag at Queen’s College

0

There has been significant disagreement between staff at Queen’s College over the decision of the college to fly an LGBTQ+ rainbow flag in recognition of LGBTQ+ History Month, after the college Provost, Professor Paul Madden, opposed the move.

In a meeting on the 13th February, which was attended by representatives from the JCR and MCR and a number of college fellows, the Governing Body passed the unreserved motion to raise the flag for the remainder of the month with a vote of 18-3.

The vote came after the Provost had excused himself from debate on the matter.

However, Cherwell understands from sources present at the meeting that, following the vote, the Provost ruled against the majority, instructing that the flag not be raised for more than the originally planned one week.

No statement has yet been given to explain this decision.

Upon the Provost’s overruling of the vote, Cherwell understands that a fellow left the session in protest at the decision, not returning for the duration of the meeting.

A few days later, an email was sent to the JCR President and Vice President by the Dean, informing them of a change of college policy, stating that the flag would fly for the month as a whole.

When contacted for comment, the Provost did not offer any explanation of his decision. Both the Senior Tutor and Dean also declined to comment personally.

Speaking to Cherwell, a spokesperson for the college said: “As has been customary for a number of years, instruction was given by the Provost to fly the rainbow Flag in the first week of February.

“After it was taken down, the Provost received representations that, in view of the observation that it had become customary among the colleges for the flag to be flown throughout February, the College’s position seemed anomalous.

“He therefore reviewed the decision and gave the instruction that the flag should fly for the whole month and it was remounted on the morning of Thursday 14th February.”

The decision stands in the context of the fact that all other colleges on the high street have flown the rainbow flag for at least a week in February, with many flying it for the whole month.

The disagreement comes just a couple of weeks after Cherwell’s revelation that more than 100 serving Oxford clergy have signed a petition opposing a call by local bishops for “an attitude of inclusion and respect for LGBTQ+ people,” with staff from two Oxford colleges among the signatories.

Responding to the issue, Queen’s JCR President Ebrubaoghene Abel-Unokan said: “The original decision not to fly the LGBTQ+ flag for the entirety of LGBTQ+ history month was, in my opinion, an oversight by the College. It was an anachronism from the College’s past that does not reflect our varied and inclusive community of students and staff or acknowledge and value the contributions they make to the life of the College.

“It is a de facto tradition for the LGBTQ+ rep of our JCR to request that the College fly the flag for the entire month, and I’m incredibly pleased to see that this year Florence Darwen was successful in lobbying the College to change its policy.

“I’d also to thank the Senior Tutor, Nicholas Owen, and the Dean, Chris O’Callaghan for the roles they played in securing the change.

“The JCR has always championed progressive political beliefs, and I would like to think that this is but one step in the consolidation of those views into the College’s practices.

“I have little doubt that this will continue as Queen’s welcomes Dr Claire Craig CBE later this year, who will be the first woman in the College’s history to hold the position of Provost.”

Oxford University LGBTQ+ Society told Cherwell: “While we haven’t been contacted directly by Queen’s students regarding this issue, and are therefore uncertain about the nuances of this particular situation, we as a Society strongly encourage colleges to fly the LGBTQ+ Flag for the duration of pride month.

“It is an important symbol of tolerance and acceptance, which promotes the wellbeing of LGBTQ+ students.

“It is extremely disappointing when college officials do not understand the value of celebrating their LGBTQ+ students and sending a welcoming message to potential applicants.

“We run a campaign service to help students enact change in their colleges, and would strongly encourage Queen’s students to get in touch with us, with the aim of improving provisions for LGBTQ+ students by rectifying this issue.”

McGrath and ‘Together’ slate sweep Michaelmas 2019 Union election

Brendan McGrath will be Union President next Michaelmas after receiving 84 more first preferences than rival James Lamming.

Candidates on McGrath’s ‘Together’ slate also secured the positions of Librarian-Elect (Mahi Joshi), Treasurer-Elect (Shining Zhao), and Secretary (Amelia Harvey).

Three out of the four Standing Committee candidates nominated by the ‘Together’ slate also won election, compared to two of Lamming’s six candidates for the ‘Engage’ slate.

Two independents, Mo Iman and ex-Logistics Officer Nikhil Shah, complete the seven-member standing committee.

However, ‘Engage’ had some success in the election, as the most popular candidates in both the Standing Committee election (Spencer Cohen) and Secretary’s Committee election (Chengkai Xie) were from the slate.

Speaking to Cherwell about the result, James Lamming said: “Whilst this obviously was not the result the Engage team had hoped for, I can without any doubt say that Brendan will put together a fantastic term card, as one of the most diligent and dedicated members of Union committee I have ever worked with during my time at Oxford.

“I am immensely proud of the team myself and my officers put together.”

The election of Brendan McGrath as president of the Oxford Union comes after a turbulent term for the current Librarian, after members saw a motion for impeachment being filed against him, and his first candidate for Treasurer, Lee Chin Wee, being disqualified from running for the position.

McGrath declined to comment to Cherwell on the election result.

Those members elected will be expected to follow through with the pledges made in their manifestos. The ‘Together’ slate claimed that it would introduce member-speaker roundtable events, make the Union’s financial accounts transparent by publishing a fully audited account online, and implement a strict ‘zero tolerance’ policy on bullying. The ‘Engage’ slate’s pledges included a bar happy hour with pints costing £1, livestreaming events on the Oxford Union app, and holding more female-led debate events.

McGrath, Joshi and Zhao will serve their terms as officers in Michaelmas Term 2019, while Secretary-elect Amelia Harvey will assume her post next term in Trinity.

New data reveals suspension gender gap among postgrads

0

New data shows that 8.7% of female postgraduates suspended their studies in 2016/17, one-third higher than the rate for men (6.5%). The gender discrepancy was mirrored in withdrawal rates, which were 1.37% for men compared to 1.64% for women.

The data, obtained from the University by Cherwell, reveals a consistent gender disparity in suspension and withdrawal rates over the previous 8 years.

Suspensions are when a single student pauses their study during a given year, with one student potentially accruing multiple suspension ‘counts’, in the rare event that they do so more than once.

Withdrawals are when a student completely withdraws from their programme of study. This does not include those that have been transferred to a different programme of study.

A spokesperson for the University told Cherwell: “These numbers are relatively low so we should be careful about drawing conclusions from them without understanding the context. We offer high levels of academic and pastoral support to our graduate students through their departments, colleges and central University services.

“There are many reasons why a student’s status might be suspended, including health, maternity or paternity, personal circumstances, academic difficulties and disciplinary matters. Suspension is often a voluntary decision by a student, and in most cases students return from periods of suspension to successfully complete their course.”

A History Masters student at St Catherine’s, Hannah Grange-Sales, told Cherwell: “Women are conditioned to believe they are less intelligent than men, therefore there is both a real and imagined need to work harder to be considered men’s intellectual equals.

“Girls and women are also taught from an early age to internalise ‘unbecoming’ emotions, such as anger, frustration and hopelessness.

“Considering the historic argument against women’s right to education that they do not hold the mental rigour to undertake study, there is a double pressure to overcome this stigma and maintain a facade of capability when, for a variety of personal reasons not linked to their intellect, this may not be the case.

“The increased pressure for women to prove themselves intellectually coupled with the internalisation of emotion can surely be considered a factor in the higher rate of mental health issues amongst female students.”

The overall suspension rate for all postgraduate students has also increased year on year from 2013/14 to 2016/17 from 5.98% to 7.93%, although there was a slight decrease last year to 7.5%.

The withdrawal rate has remained consistent at about 1.5%, peaking in 2013/14 at 1.82%.

There was also a marked contrast between those on research and taught postgraduate degrees, with the former having consistently higher levels of suspension and withdrawal. In 2016/17 just under 10% of research graduates suspended their studies compared to 6% of taught graduates. This figure decreased slightly to 9% last year.

Cherwell understands that the disparity in the figures could be due to the length of postgraduate research degree, which are typically three years. Taught degrees can be as short as 9 months, meaning that there is less opportunity for students to suspend or withdraw from their studies. Just under 52% of enrolments in 2017/18 were in taught degrees.

Oxford SU VP for Graduates, Alison D’Ambrosia told Cherwell: “It is a ticking time bomb the issue of graduate student welfare. With a huge increase in graduate numbers over the past several years, we have seen minimal investment in their welfare provision and support.

“From a counselling service that is only open during term time to students been pushed from college to department to seek help, more needs to be done to properly support the graduate student body. It seems that the first call of action is for students to suspend rather than tackle the causes of suspension and offer proper support for students.”

According to the SU’s recently published counselling report, postgraduate students were proportionally less likely to seek help than undergraduates, with 10.8% of postgraduate researchers and 9.2% of taught students receiving counselling to 12.3% of undergraduates.

The report added that the lower take up of provision could be due to cultural differences. In 2016/17, 64% of graduates were non-UK students.

University offers no deal Brexit advice for EU students

0

The University has released advice for EU staff and students in preparation for a no deal Brexit.

The new website explains that the University is now “making preparations” for the possibility that Britain leaves the EU without a deal, which will go ahead if no withdrawal agreement is in place by March 29th.

A no deal Brexit would be likely to include EU citizens entering the UK being treated as third country nationals, no longer subject to EEA immigration rules and requirements. This would mean EU students would pay higher tuition fees than they do now and may need new visas to conform with new immigration laws.

Research staff may lose the opportuning to access EU research funding, which totalled £78 million in the academic year 2017/18. The University may also lose the opportunity to participate in pan-European collaborations.

Given the growing uncertainty, the University is now advising EU students to ensure they have all relevant paperwork up to date.

The University stresses that EU citizens will still be able to apply to study at Oxford, and that “all Oxford University staff from the EU will have the same right to work in the UK whether a withdrawal deal is agreed or not.”

A spokesperson for the University said to Cherwell: “Given the ongoing uncertainty about the implications of the UK leaving the EU, the University is working hard to understand and manage the impact on our staff and students.

“Dedicated web pages with the latest information about the implications of Brexit have been set up for staff and students and these will be updated regularly. The pages consider all possible outcomes of the current negotiations, including the possibility of the UK leaving without a deal.

‘Whatever the outcome of current negotiations, the University of Oxford is, and intends to remain, a thriving, cosmopolitan community of scholars and students united in our commitment to education and research.

“The departure from the EU will not change this; our staff and students from all across the world are as warmly welcome as ever.”

The Students’ Union reaffirmed the need for advice, stating: “Students need guidance as soon as possible. If a no deal Brexit does happen, students want the University to quickly provide information about the impact it’s going to have on them.

“Graduate students from the EU could face serious disruption, particularly those studying for 1-year masters programmes. There are major issues outstanding, especially around the future of the Erasmus programme and future prospects for research students. The only way to avoid this mess is a People’s Vote with the option to remain.”

With just over six weeks left until the Brexit deadline, the University will continue to update their page with more information as it is available, and individual colleges may be providing specific information directly to students before the end of Hilary Term.

For more information, or to keep up to date on the University’s advice, visit the University’s Brexit advice page for students and for staff.

Union Librarian Brendan McGrath avoids impeachment

0

Brendan McGrath, against whom a motion for impeachment was filed on Thursday 7th, has won his vote not to be impeached by 400 votes to 189.

A notice has been pinned on the Oxford Union noticeboard that reads “The Librarian remains in office. The Motion of Impeachment is unsuccessful”.

The 68% vote in favour of McGrath comes after the 12 hours of deliberation that an impeachment motion in the Oxford Union entails. On the day of the vote supporters and allies of McGrath mobilised a “Vote No” campaign on Facebook, posting social statuses that presented McGrath’s potential impeachment as symptomatic of ‘toxic politics’.

More on this story is expected to follow.

Fixed-term contracts disproportionately held by women and minority groups

0

A greater proportion of women and those from BME backgrounds hold fixed-term contracts at the University.

In 2018, the proportion of women in fixed-term contracts was consistently higher across the academic divisions, with the sharpest disparities in the Social Sciences where 56% of women were in fixed-term contracts compared with just 45% of men.

In the Medical Sciences Division, 85% of those from BME backgrounds were found to hold fixed-term contracts in 2018 in comparison to just 68% of those who identify as white.

For Social Sciences the respective figures were 66% to 45%, and in the Maths, Physical, and Life Sciences, the figures were 74% to 43%.

Overall, the proportion of all those of fixed-term contracts has increased significantly from 2008 across all divisions apart from Medical, with the Humanities Division seeing the biggest increase in the use of fixed-term contracts, from 23% to 32%.

In 2018, just under 50% of staff from the Maths, Physical, and Life Sciences, Social Sciences, Medical, and Humanities divisions, were on fixed-term contracts.

The University’s policy on ending fixed-term contracts requires dismissal to be “fair and transparent.”

Employees are informed three months before the end of their contract is “at risk”. When it is not possible to extend or renew the contract, an employee will be informed of the fact a month before its termination.

A University spokesman told Cherwell: “Oxford is the UK’s most successful University in attracting external funding to support our world-leading research. The funding packages support jobs for researchers at every career stage, including fixed-term posts. The larger number of fixed-term contracts results from this increased funding success, opening more opportunities for the next generations of world-class researchers. We have had particular success in attracting talented women to progress their careers with us, including those areas of the sciences where they have been traditionally under-represented.

“We do recognise that fixed-term work can create uncertainties and practical difficulties. We make extensive efforts to support staff on these contracts, including through personal and career development opportunities.

“All staff at Oxford, whether on permanent, open-ended or fixed-term contracts, benefit from our generous employment packages and support for future development. We are also working hard on moving staff onto open-ended and permanent contracts wherever possible. A growing proportion of these contracts are held by women, while the proportion of all staff on open-ended contracts in the sciences is now growing faster than those in fixed-term posts.”

The University’s policy is to ensure departments are “keeping contracts under active review and transferring staff to permanent or open-ended contracts wherever funding permits.”

The proportion of staff working on open-ended contracts in the sciences is now growing faster than those on fixed-term contracts. For example, in 2008, 75% of staff in Medical Sciences were on fixed-term contracts and 4% on open-ended contracts; By 2018, fixed-term contracts had fallen to 72% and open-ended contracts risen to 8%.

The proportions of women in permanent and open-ended positions has increased in some sectors. In Medical Sciences in 2008, 45% of permanent contracts and 53% of open-ended contracts were held by women. By 2018, women held 52% of permanent and 57% of open-ended contracts.

However, in a 2016 report the UCU also included open-ended contracts within their definition of insecure contracts, because their “employment is dependent on short-term funding.”

Their report read: “Employers like to emphasise the degree of choice and agency available to workers on casual or as they like to call them ‘flexible’ contracts, but it is obvious that your enjoyment of choice and flexibility will be shaped by which category you are in.

“It’s simply impossible to imagine that a workforce of this magnitude is comprised entirely, or even largely of the people who conform to the employers’ caricature of the jobbing professional who relishes the flexibility.”

Oxford UCU representative Patricia Thornton told Cherwell: ”Regardless of whether the University wishes to accept the UCU’s calculation of the HESA data on precarious contracts or not, it’s clear that in many divisions, the numbers of staff on casualised contracts have been rising.

“It’s important to note here that “open-ended externally funded contract” staff, whilst sometimes not counted as casualised, effectively face the same level insecurity: their employment is terminated if and when the external source of the funding is withdrawn. The key difference here is that, whereas a fixed-term contract employee is given an end date at the point of hire, the staff member on an open-ended externally funded contract is not; which is arguably even less secure for the member of staff, whose employment can come to an end suddenly and without sufficient warning if the funding is withdrawn.”

Just under 5% of staff in the Medical, Maths, Physical and Life Sciences, Social Sciences, and Humanities cumulatively are in open-ended or externally funded contracts in 2018. The figure was just 2.3% in 2008.  

Thornton continued: “Casualised contracts not only create a two-tier workforce within the university, with casualised members of staff effectively carrying out many, if not all, of the same duties as their permanent counterparts on a day-to-day basis, paid lower salaries and afforded a greatly reduced level of protection (and fewer benefits), but they also magnify pre-existing inequalities within the workforce, like the gender pay gap and the persistent underpayment of minority ethnic staff.

“There is a significantly higher proportions of women than men in fixed-term contracts across the divisions, and, disappointingly, that proportion has actually increased marginally since 2008 in the Social Science and MPLS Divisions, and increased significantly in the Humanities Division.

“Equally disturbing is that, despite Oxford UCU’s persistently raising this issue with the administration, and despite various commitments that have been verbalised across the university, the percentages of staff on fixed term term contracts have instead risen since 2008.”

One representative of the ‘Academic Precariat’ group, pointed out that these figures fail to account for those that have already left the sector due to casualisation.

They told Cherwell: “There are plenty of us around, but very little data or interest in us. I left the sector for a range of reasons, but most of them related directly to insecure employment and its consequences: a two-tier system in which casual teaching and research staff undertake work that mainly just enables senior academics to bring in big money projects, lack of respect for intellectual ownership of teaching/research materials produced on these contracts, feeling and being utterly disposable, lack of investment and interest in supporting career progression (why should they, when to offer us more secure employment would be to remove the props fora system which values REF and big grant money above all else?).

“Another big factor in my decision to leave after my short-term postdoc was the minimal prospect of ever being able to secure a contract long enough to actually qualify for maternity pay in the near future.”

A guide to Oxford’s music scene

0

Setting foot in Oxford three years ago felt a little like looking through a kaleidoscope: its music scene – sprawling, dynamic and eclectic – revealed so many more colours and shapes than I had expected to find. What follows, though not exhaustive, is an introduction to this remarkably varied scene.

Whether housed within individual colleges or organised by Oxford University Music Society (OUMS), the numerous classically oriented orchestras and choirs constitute a cornucopian landscape. OUMS alone encompasses two symphony orchestras, a jazz orchestra, and a choir, alongside numerous other ensembles catering to a range of abilities and commitments. Performances take place across the city, from college chapels and auditoriums to historic venues such as the Sheldonian Theatre and the Holywell Music Room.

Yet, contrary to many students’ expectations, while classical music-making flourishes, it does not dominate the scene. In fact, there isn’t really a single genre or style that does. Budding DJs can perform their debut sets at low-stakes college bops and hone their knob twiddling for open decks nights run by the Electronic Music Society; Pitch Perfect and The Sing-Off enthusiasts can sing their hearts out in one of the University’s seven a cappella groups; and those who revel in the jubilant clang of pitched percussion can ring bells with the Society of Change Ringers or try their hand at Javanese Gamelan with the Oxford Gamelan Society.

The theatre stage offers yet another musical outlet. Primarily spearheaded by Oxford University Dramatic Society, numerous musical theatre productions take place each term, with casting calls posted on Facebook and Instagram. Yet, if singing under the spotlight isn’t quite for you, playing in a production’s band might be more up your street.

Oxford’s experimental music scene is equally well served by groups like the Oxford Improvisers and Professor Walshe’s Creative Labs, an open forum where anyone can share works in progress to workshop with others. For those more inclined to listen, however, the termly Experimental Music Oxford (EXMO) concert series hosted in the auditorium at St John’s College is your best bet.

Of course, no music scene is complete without nightlife. Thankfully, there is no shortage of clubs, bars and pubs hosting live music events. In the city centre, student clubbing staples include the LGBTQ+ venue Plush, the Varsity Club, and Bridge, most popular on Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday nights. Friday nights have more to offer, with Reggaeton Nights every week at the Oxford Retreat, and, for those willing to walk a little further to Cowley Road, monthly Indie Fridays at the O2 Academy or Bossaphonik’s jazz-world events on the third Friday of every month. Cowley Road’s offerings don’t end there, with the record shop Truck Store and the pub The Library hosting regular live music, alongside The Bullingdon, a popular clubbing and gigging destination for Oxford’s students. Meanwhile, venturing north towards Jericho might land you in the longstanding Jericho Tavern, where Radiohead played their first-ever gig; Common Ground, a community hub and café with a great vinyl collection; or the recently opened The Nest, home to the Young Women’s Music Project in Oxford.

A special mention deservedly goes to the recently formed Hot Mess Project, an intersectional feminist arts collective blending music with everything from poetry to dance. The project’s musical offerings include themed club nights proudly powered by all-female DJ line-ups.

Finally, for those who prefer putting pen to paper rather than bow to string, Oxford offers numerous opportunities to write about music. Phaser, the university’s student music magazine, publishes in print once a term, posts regularly on Substack, and hosts its own nightlife events. Meanwhile, Oxfordshire Music Scene looks beyond the university bubble, profiling local bands and promoting gigs across the city. Though free to read online, I much prefer picking up a copy over an ice cream at G&D’s on Little Clarendon Street!

I’m certain that Oxford’s colourful music scene can offer at least one thing to tickle your fancy. Ultimately, though, if what you’re looking for doesn’t exist, then take that as your green light to start it! After all, a music scene is what you make of it.

This House believes the Oxford Union can debate better

0

There is a familiar moment during an Oxford Union debate. One speaker finishes, the chamber applauds, and the next speaker approaches the despatch box, likely prepared with several pages of remarks. They thank the President, perhaps make a joke, and begin their speech. 

There is nothing inherently wrong with this. If one is stepping into a chamber that has a 200-year history of hosting monumental debates, it would be foolish not to have come prepared. Nevertheless, after attending several Union debates, I started to get the sense that nothing anyone said could substantially affect what came next. 

The speeches were sometimes interesting. The speakers (obviously) disagreed. Sometimes, they even directly challenged one another. But I increasingly found myself wondering whether I was watching an actual debate or simply listening to several people deliver their individual arguments on the same subject. 

This is not an entirely new complaint. During the Union’s debate on youth activism, Oliver Carter criticised audience members who left after hearing the particular speech they came to see. His objection was straightforward: members were supposed to be discussing a motion, and leaving halfway through meant missing the entire argument. 

While his point is certainly well taken, it invites another question: if every speaker had filmed and submitted their contribution the previous afternoon, how much would the debate actually change?

What is a Union debate supposed to do?

The Oxford Union was founded in 1823 and developed as a forum for discussion independent of the University’s constraints. Its establishment provided students an independent space to debate subjects they could not otherwise discuss freely. Two centuries later, the Union continues to place freedom of expression at the centre of its institutional identity. 

That history still shapes how people inside the institution understand its purpose. Arwa Elrayess, a former Union President, described a gap between what the wider Oxford student body rewards and what she believes the office of the President demands. A President could organise a term around relatively ‘safe’ debates and probably receive less criticism. But, she argued, this would miss the point of running a “historic debating society, whose entire purpose is to be able to have those discussions, have those debates, that you would otherwise never be able to have”.

Controversy, therefore, is not an end in itself. However, it can be the consequence of taking disagreement between viewpoints seriously. “If a motion leaves everyone in the room in agreement,” she says, “then nobody held a view strong enough to argue”.

Antonio Reis, President-Elect of the Oxford Students Liberal Association (OSLA) and a member of the Union’s Secretary’s Committee, offered a useful distinction. Inviting Einstein to give an individual address would be justified by his expertise alone. Inviting him to a debate would promise something else: an argument tested against opposition.

As Reis put it: “If they’re coming to a debate, it’s because we want to hear an argument.”

A Union debate need not consist mainly of rebuttal. Invited speakers have perspectives that deserve to be heard in their own right. Nevertheless, the opposing case should be capable of imposing demands on their speech. At some point, a debate should make what one speaker says consequential for what the next speaker has to say. 

I wanted to know how often that happened. To determine whether speeches actually ‘debated’, I spent 30 hours (of my life that I will never get back) watching 133 speeches across 17 Oxford Union debates from the 2025-26 academic year. I examined whether speakers responded to arguments previously advanced by their opponents, introduced new arguments, repeated material already presented by their own side, and received points of information (POIs).

I rated each speech on a four-point scale, from no engagement with earlier opposing arguments to extensive engagement with several. Contrary to my initial impression, of the 116 speeches capable of responding to a previous opponent, 82 (or around 70%) were coded as containing at least one substantive response. That hardly suggests that speakers universally ignore one another.

But a headline that reads “seven in ten Oxford Union speakers substantively respond to other speakers” would be misleading. A speech qualified if it substantively addressed just one opposing argument, even briefly, with few speeches consistently engaging with previous speakers’ points. Further, I could not reliably distinguish an improvised response from a rebuttal anticipated before the debate. 

This revealed a problem with the question I had initially asked. Counting rebuttals could tell me whether a speaker had responded to an opponent. It could not establish whether anything the previous speaker said had materially changed the direction of the discussion.

A debate can contain rebuttals without its arguments meaningfully developing.

The problem with points of information

Ideally, this is where POIs would come in. Unlike a prepared rebuttal, a POI allows an opponent to challenge a speaker while they are speaking. It lets the argument develop in real time rather than waiting for the next scheduled contribution. 

Reis described POIs as “super important”, explaining that they force speakers to think on their feet. Akheel Kale, another member of the Union’s Secretary’s Committee, similarly identified them as an important means of facilitating direct interaction between speakers.

The figures, however, complicate this picture. Across the 133 speeches, I identified 216 POI offers. Yet 74 speeches received none at all. In more than half of the speeches I watched, there was no identifiable attempt to interrupt with a question. The Union’s most concrete way of forcing a confrontation of views was alarmingly absent. 

Furthermore, the distribution was highly uneven. The debate on whether the West was right to be suspicious of Islam accounted for 110 of the 216 identifiable POI offers across the entire sample. At first glance, this might suggest an exceptionally interactive debate. Yet Kale, recalling the event, described people speaking over one another and an extraordinary number of declined interruptions. His recollection highlights another distinction: confrontation is not necessarily deliberation.

An evening in which opponents repeatedly attempt to interrupt one another might be considerably more confrontational than an evening of uninterrupted speeches. But if speakers consistently refuse those interventions, or if interruptions produce little substantive exchange, the additional confrontation does not necessarily improve the discussion. The findings say something about the purpose of POIs. Their existence cannot guarantee genuine engagement. Their effectiveness depends on whether speakers are willing to allow their opponents to interfere with the arguments they came to deliver.

Responding without really debating

 Perhaps an even more revealing question is whether the two sides are addressing the same disagreement in the first place.

Consider the Union’s debate on whether politics should be kept out of sport. The proposition initially approached the motion relatively narrowly, concentrating on the institutional and geopolitical use of sport for political purposes. The opposition, meanwhile, repeatedly invoked a broader understanding of politics, encompassing athlete activism, national identity, and political expression. The distinction matters. The opposition’s use of Tommie Smith and John Carlos, who famously raised their fists at the 1968 Olympics, illustrated the importance of political expression in sport. But defending their protest does not necessarily rebut the argument that governments exploit international sporting competitions for geopolitical purposes.

The two sides could appear to be rebutting one another while operating under different definitions of the motion. Of course, arguing over what counts as ‘politics’ can be productive. The problem arises when speakers use those different meanings without confronting the distinction. As Jacob Rees-Mogg put it: “That is often a problem with the Oxford Union Society. That when a motion says one thing and a speaker thinks something else, he tries and talks around the subject.” 

Elrayess identifies a structural reason as to why this can happen. Union motions, she explained, have to be “snappy and quick to the punchline”. Nuance is inevitably lost. Sometimes, she said, “the core idea of the debate gets lost on the speakers who get caught up in the technicalities of the wording”. She also sees value in provocative wording: pushing a proposition towards its limits can force members to discover where their own views lie. But a motion that creates disagreement is not necessarily one that helps speakers locate the precise point of disagreement.

The paradox of the excellent speaker

There is a more fundamental obstacle to making speeches responsive: the Union’s greatest attraction may also discourage improvisation.

The Union certainly possesses an extraordinary ability to attract prominent politicians, academics, journalists, and other public figures. Its members can hear from people with years of experience in subjects they might otherwise encounter only through newspapers, books or television. It would be unreasonable to suggest that these speakers should abandon their prepared arguments simply to respond to whatever the previous speaker happened to say.

Elrayess described the difficulty of assembling opposing benches when invitees object to a motion or to sharing a platform with another speaker, highlighting a fundamental constraint on any attempt to construct a debate: a President cannot create opposing benches if potential participants refuse to sit on them. Her defence of controversial invitations follows from the same principle. “Speakers are invited because their views are influential enough, are listened to enough, that they deserve to be scrutinised,” she told me, “not because we wish to give them a badge of honour”.

That defence depends, in part, on what happens once the speaker arrives. A debate can scrutinise a controversial argument in a way that an individual address cannot, but only if the speaker engages with the arguments made in front of them. Yet the qualities that make somebody worth inviting can also make their contribution more self-contained. An eminent guest might have spent years developing a particular argument. They arrive with a prepared speech, knowing that their performance may be recorded and scrutinised by an audience far larger than the one sitting in the chamber.

Reis suggested that these pressures can discourage spontaneous interaction. With so much riding on a Union appearance, speakers may be reluctant to depart from prepared material or accept challenges that could take their speech somewhere unexpected. Contrast that with a debate night at one of Oxford’s many political societies, like OSLA’s Liquor and Liberalism. There, Reis explains, the lower-stakes environment allows more back-and-forth, even if the ensuing debate may be less polished. 

The answer, then, cannot simply be to replace speeches with conversation. The Union should preserve the expertise and preparation that make its guests worth hearing, while ensuring that their arguments face meaningful scrutiny.

Importantly, these ambitions are not mutually exclusive. Prepared speeches and spontaneous responses can coexist. Kale recalled an India-Pakistan debate in which a speaker delivered an effective prepared speech while also responding substantively to challenging POIs. For him, the combination illustrated what the Union’s format can achieve: the benefits of preparation without sacrificing direct engagement. 

Debate by design

Asked what she would change if she had unilateral power over the Union, Elrayess suggested experimenting with “different debate structures that allow for more fluid back-and-forths, rather than the speeches we often see”. A more fluid format, she argues, “prevents monologuing that does not serve the instrumental purpose of debate”.

An instructive historical comparison can be made. The famous 1858 debates between Abraham Lincoln and Stephen Douglas were political spectacles, attracting enormous audiences and considerable press attention. Nevertheless, their structure protected something that the Union’s format does not always guarantee: time specifically allocated to responding to an opponent. Each encounter began with a sixty-minute speech, followed by a ninety-minute response from the opposing candidate. The opening speaker then received thirty minutes to reply.

The Union need not reproduce a nineteenth-century two-person contest. It could experiment with a short, protected response period after opening speeches, or a moderated exchange between opposing speakers before the floor debate. Neither would require abandoning prepared remarks. Both would make it harder for speakers to avoid the strongest argument against their position.

Such changes would carry risks. More interruptions could reward theatrical confrontation; rigid rebuttal periods could crowd out expert explanation. But the Union already experiments with whom it invites and which motions it chooses. There is no reason for its format to be beyond experimentation.

A platform for free speech or a forum for debate?

Ultimately, the Oxford Union’s Thursday nights bring two of its institutional ambitions into tension.

The Union takes great pride in repeating former Librarian of the Union Harold Macmillan’s claim that it is “the last bastion of free speech in the Western world”. It also, however, claims to be the “world’s most prestigious debating society”. These two aims need not be inherently contradictory, but one does not automatically fulfil the other.

Allowing somebody to express an argument fulfils an important free-expression function. Inviting somebody else to express the opposite argument creates ideological diversity. Choosing a sufficiently contentious motion ensures they have something meaningful to disagree about. A debate adds one final requirement: those arguments should meet.

The Union is remarkably good at creating the conditions for disagreement. It chooses contentious motions. It invites people from opposing political traditions. It tolerates views that other institutions might refuse to host. It puts those people on opposite sides of the same chamber.

The prepared pages in a speaker’s hands are not the problem. Nor are prominent guests, provocative motions, rhetoric, or preparation. The question is whether anything that happens in the chamber can force the person holding those pages to depart from them.

Elrayess argues that the Union possesses a rare freedom to host conversations that otherwise might not happen. But creating the conditions for a conversation is not the same as ensuring one takes place. The Union has proved exceptionally good at getting opposing arguments into the same room.

A better debating society would make them collide.

Too Good To Go, or too good to be true?

0

As Prime Minister Andy Burnham constantly reminds us, we are in a cost of living crisis, with the price of nearly everything rising. So, on a limited student budget, and hoping to vary my food beyond Tesco meal deals and late-night kebabs, I decided to give Too Good To Go a go. 

Too Good To Go is an app that allows users to pick up so-called ‘surprise bags’ of surplus food from shops and cafés at a reduced price. At Oxford, a number of places take part –  including chains like Gail’s and Costa, supermarkets like M&S and Co-op, and independent businesses like Taylor’s and Knead. Depending on the time of day, you can check the app’s map to see what bags are available, which range from leftover pastries to fully cooked meals, along with their respective collection windows. 

I got my first Too Good To Go a few weeks ago, from Tortilla on my way to London. At £4.40, I picked up a burrito bowl alongside tortilla chips with guacamole, which would ordinarily cost £15.75. While the burrito bowl wasn’t my typical order – since it replaced beans, corn, and salsa with grilled vegetables, grilled vegetables, and more grilled vegetables – I couldn’t help but appreciate the value of my order as I sat on the Overground, making my way home. 

My next order came a few days later, at Paul on High Street. Although at £7, it was a bit pricier,  I still got my fair share of goods: a croissant, a chocolate croissant, an almond croissant (just all of the croissants), a cinnamon roll, a cheese twist, and two cheese and salami baguettes. Needless to say, my meals were covered for the next few days. 

Before long, I got hooked on the app,  replacing my late-night Instagram doomscroll with, of all things, yellow-sticker food. I refreshed the app a few times a day, looking for what might be called a ‘rare find’. For me, that was the M&S bakery bag – I mean, who wouldn’t want the latest drop of Kathryn Turner-recommended cornflake cookies?

After turning on my M&S notifications and searching up M&S’ drop times, I got my hands on a bakery bag after two weeks of trying (I’m locked in like that) – and it did not disappoint. At £3.80, I got a box of mince pies, two doughnuts, two ‘Yumnuts’, a cheese pretzel, a sausage roll, and an apple turnover. Although I might’ve missed out on the M&S cookie craze, I couldn’t have been happier. 

In a way, the more I used the app, the more it became a game – racing other users to get the best bags (M&S or otherwise), followed by the adrenaline rush in seeing what I ‘won’ in my surprise bag. In an age of shrinking attention spans and AI slop, perhaps it makes sense that buying leftover food has also become a form of entertainment for me. The issue with ‘gamifying’ surplus food, however, is that it might defeat the very purpose of the app. 

Founded in 2015, Too Good To Go was set up to fight food waste – which, in the UK, is upwards of 10.7 million tonnes per year. When the whole appeal of the app is the surprise, there’s a fair chance you won’t get what you want, and the food will go to waste regardless. In my case, I learnt this the hard way after picking up a ‘sweet and pastry bag’ at Starbucks where I got, of all things, three boxes of porridge; if my brother hadn’t been willing to take the porridges for himself, I likely wouldn’t have had them. Searching across social media, gripes similar to mine with Too Good To Go aren’t uncommon – people complain that “they really put the ‘surprise’ in surprise bag”, while others throw away goods they don’t like, whether an egg mayo sandwich or some other item. When a significant amount of the food ends up in the trash anyway, it’s hard to see what the point of the app really is. 

There’s also evidence for Too Good To Go’s wider problem. A 2025 study using mathematical models found that surprise bags, much like ordinary end-of-day discounts, could actually increase food waste. According to the study, leftovers could not only tempt businesses to overproduce – knowing they can sell off surplus later – but buyers might end up throwing away food they never wanted in the first place. 

This paradox puts Too Good To Go in a strange position. Their business model relies on there being surplus food to sell – the very thing it is also trying to get rid of. But then it doesn’t so much get rid of food waste as move it to our kitchens and homes, which, given households make up 60% of the UK’s food waste, isn’t exactly the most promising space for it to end up. 

So, is Too Good To Go too good to be true? Not entirely. For us students, it is genuinely good value – a £3-4 surprise bag can cover meals for a day or two. But the dopamine hit that comes with refreshing the app and searching for the next best thing makes it all too easy to forget why the app exists. After all, a surprise bag only matters when someone actually eats what’s inside. 

As for me, although I’ll keep trying for the next M&S surprise bag, I might think twice before reserving another one I might not like.

‘Ghosts: The Possession of Button House’: A fond farewell

0

When I sat down to watch Ghosts: The Possession of Button House at the Phoenix Picturehouse, I was just as excited as the other cinema-goers to see the beloved characters from the TV series Ghosts one more time. I was not disappointed – the film offers another opportunity to see the well-loved characters in both familiar and new contexts as the ghosts explore the world beyond Button House. 

The film continues the story of the TV series Ghosts, which began in 2019 and ended in 2023, following the lives (so to speak) of a group of ghosts who are trapped in Button House, having died at the site. Married couple Alison (Charlotte Ritchie) and Mike (Kiell Smith-Bynoe) move into the country house at the beginning of Series One; to the ghosts’ initial horror, Alison can see and interact with them. Across the five series, Alison, Mike, and the ghosts adapt to living side by side and get used to each other’s quirks and habits; Fanny (Martha Howe-Douglas), for instance, has a daily habit of unconsciously reenacting her death by jumping out of her bedroom window. Each ghost comes from a different period of history – Robin (Laurence Rickard) is a caveman, Pat (Jim Howick) is a jolly scoutmaster who died in 1984 after an archery incident, and The Captain (Ben Willbond) is an officious Second World War army captain. Despite the tensions among the characters, we see deep friendships form. 

If the relationships on screen feel warm, another level of comfort might come from the fact that six of the principal actors starred in the film’s original Horrible Histories series. A popular children’s educational comedy, the cast of the first few series of Horrible Histories were important figures in the childhoods of many current university students. You only have to look at the incredible welcome Mathew Baynton received in 2022 when he spoke at the Oxford Union to a chamber full of keen fans who sang Charles II King of Bling in unison. 

The film is set shortly after the final TV series, when Mike and Alison, with their newborn baby, have moved out, and Button House is set to become a hotel and golf resort. New life is quite literally breathed into Ghosts: The Possession of Button House. A group of teenagers, including Jack (Scott Ellis Watson), attempt to communicate with the ghosts, resulting in Jack and Julian (a Tory MP ghost played by Simon Farnaby) switching bodies. This new ability, unseen before in the TV series, creates an intriguing plotline and allows all of the ghosts the opportunity to experience being alive again. 

It is amusing to see the ghosts in the clothes of modern teenagers, rather than the outfits they have worn, in some cases, for hundreds of years, and which make each character so distinctive. What’s more, their wonder and shock at aspects of modern life, for instance Julian’s bewilderment at the cost of train tickets or The Captain’s surprise at seeing how computer files are organised, is heartwarming and comedic. The film’s humour comes, for the most part, from the ghosts’ naivety, and it is this innocent pleasure that makes the audience warm to the characters. Kitty (Lolly Adefope), a Georgian noblewoman ghost, gets pleasure from friendship, dancing, and singing; her attempts to befriend Jack might initially be unsuccessful, but at the end of the film he puts on music and dances with her, delighting Kitty, who is able to indulge in a new hobby and enjoy a new friendship. While it is amusing to witness her foolish attempts at ‘getting down with the kids’, it is overall a moving plotline. 

In fact, Jack, a teenager living with his foster parents, is evidence of one of the film’s aims – to show that we can learn from one another, in spite of our differences. We might not expect a 21st-century teenager and a Regency-era poet ghost to engage in a meaningful conversation about love and trust, but they do. The choice to depict a group of ghosts from disparate parts of history enables some of the key comedic moments as the ghosts are often aghast at or in admiration of each other’s traditions and technologies. On a deeper level, however, they also learn from one another and become more well-rounded, developed characters. 

Although the other ghosts often underestimate caveman Robin, he consistently shows them that he is not, in his own words, “just a pretty face”. As the oldest ghost in Button House, Robin has a certain wisdom and resourcefulness when it comes to solving the many problems they encounter. Indeed, in this film, he displays his unique methods of problem-solving, bashing a computer on the table to make it work, and his moral compass, as he succeeds in undoing the deceptive work of a local politician.

The film might be more enjoyable if you have already seen the TV series and understand each character’s quirks and the relationships which have already been developed. For example, Pat’s delight in eating a Scotch egg makes more sense if you have seen his oft-repeated love of this food. Nevertheless, this film is a fun, heartwarming story in its own right and one which may encourage new fans to watch the original TV series.

Protests start outside Oriel College ahead of Nathan Cofnas event: Live updates

0

Reporting by Mair Andrews, Stanley Arlidge, Oskar Doepke, Emma Heagney, Orla McMahon, and Freiderikos Vassos.

Additional reporting by Gavriella Epstein-Lightman and Madison Garrett.

Update: 21:00

Cherwell has ended its live coverage.

Update 20:45

Cherwell understands that police are informing protestors that Cofnas has left the building. Onlookers told Cherwell that he exited through a tunnel on King Edward’s Street.

Students in Magpie Lane accommodation are leaning over the walls and playing Bella Ciao for the barricading  protesters.

Oriel Square has now been cleared of demonstrators. Cherwell understands that students in Oriel are yet to be allowed out of the College. 

Update: 20:30

Concluding the Q&A, Cofnas said: “What I advocate is simply exposing the lie that underlies the ideology of modern day leftism, and making it impossible for DEI.”

Cherwell understands that the police have run out of Oriel College towards the High Street, and that Cofnas has now also left Oriel.

The President of Reform society has declined to comment.

The second Oriel JCR protest is expected to start shortly. One Oriel student told Cherwell that they disagree with earlier characterisations of the JCR’s response as “virtue-signalling”. The student, echoed by others, said: “The JCR and especially the executive committee have done everything in their power to make sure our views are listened to and actioned upon as much as they could.”

Update: 19:45

In the talk, Cofnas said that he argues “that the anti-hereditarian hypothesis in pseudoscience in the Lakatos sense”. He added, “just in terms of overall brain size, there are substantial differences, with Africans having the smallest and East Asians having the largest”. Cofnas then claimed that this aligned with IQ trends. “They can scream all they want, they can throw stuff at us, but that’s how it is”.

“What DEI means is that we hire Jason Arday and demand that you say he is a genius, and if you don’t, we flood you with death threats and stop people from coming to your talks.”

Police have now secured Oriel’s main entrance, pushing protesters off. Protesters still have the Oriel side entrance on Magpie Lane barricaded. At least five police vans are outside Oriel, and 17 officers have entered the college. Montgomery Toms has been escorted down Merton Street by the police.

In the Q&A portion of the event, the first question was asked by a journalist from The Guardian: “Would you like to apologise to Jason Arday’s family?”

Cofnas replied: “The implication is that I’ve done something wrong by pointing out corruption by a powerful public figure who sought power and fame. The implication is that we shouldn’t criticise public figures. Something bad happened, so therefore we shouldn’t talk about it. Is that what your point is? [Cambridge administrators] knew he was a fraud in 2023. They knew for three years. They chose to shut people down and intimidate people.”

Update: 19:30

Inside the talk, Cofnas stated: “The heritability of IQ is high. This is not a controversial fact.”

Outside, protesters are chanting: “Racist in a box.” At least seven have climbed over a wall into Oriel.

Cofnas then said: “Racism has fallen in the past few decades, and yet the IQ gap has remained constant for decades.”

Cherwell understands that protesters are now gathered near most of Oriel’s student accommodation.

Several police cars and an ambulance have also just arrived at Oriel Square. Over 15 officers are trying to get through the protesters, who are shouting “shame on you” at the police. Protesters are now barricading themselves in and the police out. Cherwell understands that the protesters are throwing the barricades back into the crowd and onto the police, who are joined by Montgomery Tom.

According to a student inside the talk, the Reform society president has asked Cofnas to wrap up in the next five to ten minutes. Cherwell understands that Cofnas is now discussing a constructive argument for race realism.

Update: 19:15

The President of Oxford Vegan Society, Freddie Nelson, told Cherwell: “He [Nathan Cofnas] can think whatever he wants, and no one’s going to stop him from saying things in the street. But Oriel College have a duty not to platform people who cause danger and hate toward their students, and that includes people of colour.” 

A representative for the Socialist Workers’ Party told Cherwell the protest is about “stopping fascism, stopping the far-right”, and that the protest will continue until “they stop hosting racists”. 

According to a student inside the talk, the protesters can be heard very loudly, with many members of the crowd looking towards the windows. Cofnas, now using a microphone, has said that there “is no scientific consensus on racial equality”.

Cofnas also stated: “If Cofnas’ nose is big, that doesn’t tell you that he’s Jewish. But if I tell you he has a big nose, and he has curly hair, and he’s from New York, then the probability goes up.”

Protesters have now returned to Oriel Square. On adjacent Oriel Street, they are banging on the college’s doors. One security guard stands between the protest and the entrance. Cherwell understands that several people are trying to scale Oriel’s walls, and that four people have made it over.

Update: 19:00

Oriel students can no longer enter through the main entrances. An email sent by Oriel’s JCR President says “students are advised to only enter/exist if strictly necessary”, with one side entrance still open to students. According to the email, Merton College’s porters’ lodge has agreed to shelter Oriel students until the protesters clear. 

An Oriel student told Cherwell that the JCR “have done what is within their power” regarding the protest inside Oriel. Another told Cherwell the JCR “has done a good job at keeping us safe”, although another critiqued that the student body does not have “much power”. 

According to a student inside the talk, Cofnas said he believes DEI is the “ideology of taking the equality thesis seriously”. Explaining what the “equality thesis” entails, he describes it as the belief that “everyone has the same potential”.

He then said that “none of them will publicly admit that [Jason Arday’s work] is a plagiarised text”. He added: “All of the evidence is on the hereditarian side.”

Cofnas also said John Locke originated the claim that people would be different if they were born elsewhere. He says: “It is not a coincidence that the father of liberalism was also the father of blank-slateism”, and later added that the supporters of the “equality thesis” do not have scientific evidence to claim that people are naturally equal. Cofnas also condemned the Nazis as anti-scientific and stated that it is “against scientific consensus” to claim that “there is no such thing as race and that all races are the same”.

Cofnas then described the protesters as “a mob trying to murder us just for talking about this stuff”.

Update: 18:45

Cherwell understand the Cofnas event has begun. Cofnas has introduced himself to attendees and said that “DEI is an ideology that is built on a lie”, according to a student inside the event.

Another student who wanted to attend Nathan Cofnas’ talk told Cherwell that Cofnas was “largely justified in publishing the obvious fraud on Jason Arday’s case”, and that “the affair wouldn’t have become so big if Jason Arday hadn’t threatened many journalists from mainstream newspapers with a police investigation”. 

The student continued: “I don’t get what these protests are helping or what they are for. Sure, people feel virtuous acting like animals, showing how strong they are, occupying a small street in a city, but no one is going to come to this and say, ‘oh, I was a raging fascist, but look at this, there are protesters blocking me from attending an event, I guess I am going to read Marx or something.’”

The student added that protesters “shouldn’t be allowed to block private property”, and that they are not sure “why that is legal”. The student was unable to enter the building for the event at the time of publication. 

Joylon Maugham of The Good Law Project spoke at the protest in Oriel Square. He said that “disabled, trans people, and immigrants are their targets. We resist together.” He also criticised the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act of 2023, saying that it has become “very hard for universities to stop the far right coming to your place of study and work”.

Referencing the American Declaration of Independence, he then stated: “Some truths are self-evident. Black students at Oxford deserve better. Black academics at Oxford deserve better.”

Cherwell understands that Montgomery Toms, an influencer closely affiliated with Restore Britain, is also near Oriel.

Update: 18:30

Oxford Resists is chanting “I believe that we will win”, referring to “this is not the end”, as Cofnas might return for another event. 

The national organiser of Black Lives Matter UK told Cherwell that the organisation is attending the protest to support the students who have asked them to be there. “Oxford University has always been a racist institution,” he says. “Students are disgusted that [Nathan Cofnas] gets to do a victory lap at Oxford University.”

Cherwell understands that Edward Dutton, a pseudoscientific “race scientist”, is also inside the event. Dutton, who posts on YouTube as “Jolly Heretic”, was removed from his post at the University of Oulu, Finland, after he plagiarised a student’s dissertation. He sits on the advisory board of Mankind Quarterly, a pseudoscientific journal, and is reported to be employed by the Human Diversity Foundation, an organisation promoting race science. 

Cherwell understands the event is about to start, although only 26 people are in attendance, including one Oriel welfare representative.

Update: 18:15

Cherwell understands that Cofnas’ talk has been delayed after protesters blocked entrances. According to a student inside the room, only 25 people are in attendance at the moment. 

An anonymous student told Cherwell: “When it comes to free speech, we kind of disagree on so many things, but we can never disagree on the value and the dignity of Black lives. That’s why I’m here.” Another student, with a background in genetics, adds: “Whatever he says is not backed by science. It’s pure racism. I really wish the genetics community would spread [this message].”

A parent of an Oxford student told Cherwell that “free speech has been put above the safety of Black students, at Oxford and elsewhere”.

When asked how the Cofnas talk makes her feel, another student said: “Like we are back in the 1930s.”

An Oxford City Green Councillor told Cherwell: “We can no longer allow Black people to be pushed into ever smaller spaces of safety.”

Update: 18:00

The Oxford student who organised a petition signed by over 32,000 people against tonight’s event has told the crowd that the Reform society has “wasted the platform they think they have”. He also condemned the University’s senior leadership, who have not spoken out against the event in their personal capacity. “This University means nothing if it is not willing to turn and say this is not welcome in our time. Tonight, Nathan, I say this to you: you are not worthy of our time.”

A lecturer at Oxford and a member of Oxford UCU, the bargaining representative, also spoke to the crowd: “We, the University workers, want no part of this racist nonsense.”

A student who attended a protest inside Oriel told Cherwell: “They are not doing enough… the JCR has neutered it.” The student added: “The student body wants to block this from happening. No one approves of it.”

“The JCR obviously opposes it and has to work with the college [Oriel] to some extent, but I think it has fallen short of representing the student body’s disgust at his speech. The protest is ineffective… it’s kind of virtue-signalling.” 

The student continued: “The University has really failed Oriel as a college and the entire community by allowing this event to happen.”

Cherwell understands that internal gates prevent Oriel students from accessing the areas attendees of Cofnas’ talk will use. The student also added that Oriel’s planned celebration during the event is just a “pizza party” and a “ridiculous waste of time and money”.

Update: 17:45

Cherwell understands that Corpus Christi College, Christ Church, and Merton College have closed their Merton Street entrances due to the protests. Corpus Christi has also stationed a security guard outside of the college.

Misan Harriman, one of the most widely-shared photographers of the Black Lives Matter movement, also spoke to the crowd. 

Around 75 protesters have gathered inside Oriel. Nathan Cofnas has not yet arrived, but protesters chanted “c*nt” at Vittorio Cuneo-Flood, the president of Oxford’s Reform society and organiser of the talk. Protesters inside Oriel can also be heard from Oriel Square, and have allegedly chanted “DEI makes us better”, “get Nathan Cofnas out of here”, and “is your mother proud of you?”

Signs underneath Oriel’s Rhodes statue read: “f*ck you Oriel”, “700 years of being sh*t”, “Rhodes must fall”, “free speech my a**”, and “save the UPP”.

Update: 17:30

Protesters outside the event have begun to chant: “Oxford University, you will always be stained with shame”, and “Nathan, you’re a wasteman. We all hate your guts. You think your pale complexion makes you better than us.”

Weyman Bennett, the joint convenor of Stand Up To Racism, told Cherwell that the speaker event “tells Black people that they are not welcome here”.

Cherwell understands that entrances to Oriel Square are now being blocked off. 

The right-wing YouTuber Young Bob, who frequently sets up debating stalls in university towns and campuses, has been followed through the middle of the protest, with people chanting “fascist scum off our streets”. Earlier in the day, he had set up a stall on Cornmarket Street with a large banner reading “DEI Murdered Jason Arday”.

The national organiser for Stand Up To Racism, Samira Ali, has given a speech, stating that the Oxon Universities’ Reform Society is “a danger to Black students and diversity on campus”. After reminding the protesters that they are there to remember Professor Jason Arday, “who should be [there]”, she added: “We are here to shut down that meeting. Reform society, we are coming for you, and we will shut you down too.” Protesters then began to chant: “Shut it down.”

Background

Nathan Cofnas, a self-described “race-realist”, will speak at Oriel College at 6.00pm today at an event titled “Does DEI undermine higher education?”, organised by the Oxon Universities’ Reform Society (OURS). Protests are expected ahead of the event, starting at 5.00pm, following a petition by Oxford Students’ Coalition Against Racism, which has received over 32,000 signatures by the time of publication.

Oriel has stated it is obligated to host the event under the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023, even as Oriel’s JCR, MCR, and SCR have condemned Cofnas’ views. Cherwell has written a summary article covering the background to the event, the reaction from across the University, and the security arrangements in place ahead of the expected protest.

Nathan Cofnas to speak at Oriel College: A summary of events

0

Read Cherwell’s live coverage of the talk and protest.

CW: Racism, discrimination, death.

This evening, Oriel College will host a talk by Nathan Cofnas titled “Does DEI undermine higher education?” His presence in Oxford, following an invitation from the student-run Reform society, has been met with considerable objections from students and staff. The University must balance Freedom of Speech legislation and its commitment to protecting the welfare and rights of its students against racism and harassment. 

Cofnas, a self-described “race realist”, is a postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University, but was previously dismissed by Emmanuel College, Cambridge, after writing a blog post claiming that the number of Black academics would “approach zero” under a meritocracy. Cambridge’s internal investigation later found that his comments did not constitute discrimination or harassment. 

In July, Cofnas posted on Substack accusing Jason Arday, who became Cambridge’s youngest-ever Black professor in 2023, of plagiarising his doctoral thesis. Arday, who denied plagiarising, resigned from Cambridge after weeks of media scrutiny and was found dead on 14th August. Liverpool John Moores University, which awarded the doctorate, concluded Arday’s doctorate should stand.

The newly registered student society, Oxon Universities’ Reform Society (OURS), organised the event. The society bears the name “Oxon” because it has not yet been registered with the University Proctors for long enough.

The OURS are not affiliated with the national party Reform UK. In a statement to Cherwell, Jack Eccles, the president of Reform’s student branch, said he “will contact the group personally… and ensure that they do not falsely claim to speak on behalf of the party”.

Eccles’ statement comes after antisemitic writings by the OURS President, Vittorio Cuneo-Flood, were uncovered by Stand Up To Racism and subsequently in Cherwell. Cuneo-Flood had written that “Satan sow[s] confusion and spread[s] perplexity” through “the false notion of ‘Anti-Semitism’”, adding that Jewish people were “promoting Satan’s plan”. He also stated that the “denial of equal rights between Catholicism and Judaism” is “right”. These statements have been described by Stand Up To Racism as antisemitic, and fall under the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, which the University of Oxford has upheld since 2016.

After Cherwell’s report, The Times published photographs provided by the antifascist group Red Flare showing that Cuneo-Flood attended a conference held by Homeland last year. Homeland has been described as the “biggest fascist, neo-Nazi party in the UK”, but it denies these claims. Cuneo-Flood did not respond to Cherwell’s request for comment.

OURS has also not responded to Cherwell’s request for comment since its initial Instagram statement, which said it was “committed to broadening participation in University life by removing systemic barriers for marginalised voices”. The society added: “Nathan Cofnas has been repeatedly victimised with stigmatising language and structural apartheid by those with institutional power and privilege.”

Responding to initial social media backlash, the society shared a post by Cofnas saying that Stand Up To Racism’s planned protest was a “predictable response by the epistemic oppressors”. OURS have also condemned calls for violence against Cofnas circulating on social media in relation to the event.

The society added: “Constituent colleges of the University are under a legal obligation to host events like ours by virtue of the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023.”

Cuneo-Flood is a student at Oriel and is responsible for organising today’s event. In response to the event’s announcement, Oriel stated it is the College’s policy to permit events booked by students who are committee members of registered societies, but that “permission does not imply endorsement by the College”.

Oriel’s JCR, MCR, and SCR – the organisations representing Oriel undergraduates, postgraduates, and academics – have all released statements condemning Cofnas in the past week. The JCR statement, approved by 90.61% of voting students, says that “the shock and distress that this event has inspired is difficult to express” and “we consider them [Cofnas’s views] despicable”. 

However, it goes on to accept that the Act means the college is legally required to allow this talk to proceed and “further recognise[s] the College’s commitment to ensuring that the University of Oxford remains a forum for free speech”, citing the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023 to say that “the College is legally required to allow this talk to proceed”.

The statement also expresses “deep anger” at Cofnas and the OURS, which it describes as “the two actors benefitting most from the controversy this event is causing”. Oriel JCR said that the OURS’ invitation and “attempt to offer legitimacy to his views deliberately creates division and is intentionally inflammatory”. “We believe that they are acutely aware of the impact that their decision has had, particularly on this community,” it adds.

“This College is our home and should not be defined by the speakers it is legally required to host. It is defined by the values and actions of its members, and we ask that we be judged on these terms.” 

The JCR statement also praises the College for its communication and involvement in protecting student welfare and “accommodating the rights of students and individuals to exercise their freedom of speech in opposition to Cofnas”. It continues: “We are also disheartened by the inaccurate claims propagated online and in-person that Oriel College, and by extension its members, support the content of this talk.”

Oriel’s Governing Body and student representatives have taken measures to protect students. Due to safety concerns for students who live on the same site where the talk was planned to be held, the event has been moved from the Harris Lecture Theatre to the library building. Oriel students have also been notified of a security presence within the college from this afternoon, including limiting access to the main gate only and requiring university cards on entry.

Thames Valley Police are responsible for ensuring public safety for events happening outside University premises, such as the Oriel Square demonstration. Oriel has reassured students that it is in “regular contact” with the police about their arrangements and monitoring the situation.

In response, Oriel student representatives have worked alongside the Deans and Domestic Bursar to organise a corresponding demonstration for students to express their views within the College: an on-site demonstration area designated for students to do so safely and in line with the College’s Code of Practice on Freedom of Speech. Students will be permitted to protest within the College prior to the talk and afterwards, and once the talk has started, there will be an ‘Oriel Celebration’ in the bar, with board games, crafts, an open bar, hot drinks, pizza, sweet treats, and snacks to “celebrate the Oriel community”. Non-protesters, including staff, students, and the SCR, are welcome to attend. The JCR “recognise that many find the speaker’s views, and the subject of the talk, distressing” and have identified a room where students can take refuge if they feel overwhelmed by the events.

Over the weekend, Oriel JCR hosted a placard-making session, and Oxford City Councillor Alfie Davis met with students to discuss security arrangements for this evening. Speaking to Cherwell, Davis said: “The JCR community have themselves stepped up to lead and protect each other, even though they shouldn’t have had to.”

Statements released by several colleges and societies have also objected to the event, and the SU and Common Rooms’ joint statement, decided at the Universities’ Extraordinary Conference of Common Rooms, “unequivocally” condemned the talk. This morning, the Board of the Faculty of Philosophy also released a statement via email reiterating its commitment to addressing racism and harassment and that, though it acknowledges the University’s commitment to free speech, it “does not indicate endorsement of Dr Cofnas’s views.”

Last Thursday, activist group Led By Donkeys also placed a KKK hood and a sign reading “Racists welcome here” on Oriel’s controversial statue of Cecil Rhodes. In response, the Provost of Oriel College, Lord Mendoza, told members of the college in an email: “Your college will not be intimidated. We will continue to support the work of our outstanding staff to make it clear that Oriel College is a place where all members of our community belong.”

A protest in Oriel Square is expected to begin at 5pm today, following a Stand Up To Racism petition signed by over 30,000 people. Prominent figures including Diane Abbott, Zarah Sultana, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, and Jeremy Corbyn have signed a further Stand Up To Racism statement. Cherwell understands that facial recognition cameras have been installed outside Oriel, following an announcement by Thames Valley Police last week.

Joylon Maugham of The Good Law Project, who is expected to speak for Stand Up To Racism at the protest, told Cherwell: “I could weep at the harm Bridget Philippson has done. The immense hurt this event is causing to Black students and academics; the damage to our university system; the undermining of important, recent anti-racism work done by Oriel; the centring of a far-right racist agenda in Britain’s most important seat of learning – all of these harms are attributable to her unfathomable embrace of the last Government’s attack on the dignity of minoritised groups.”

However, some have supported the Nathan Cofnas talk. An open letter signed by over 170 academics worldwide, including eight from Oxford, thanked Oriel for “standing firm in the face of calls to cancel Dr Nathan Cofnas’s talk”, citing freedom of speech and academic freedom as “fundamental to the mission of the University”. One signatory, Abhishek Saha, who is a Professor of Mathematics at Queen Mary University of London, told Cherwell: “The proper response to ideas one considers false, offensive, and in this case, many have talked about safety or dangerous ideas, is in every case to subject them to the same things: criticism, evidence, argument, counter-speech, and not to prevent them from being heard.”


Saha also praised the 2023 Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act, which Oriel has cited as informing its decision not to cancel the talk. The act strengthens universities’ and colleges’ duties to protect free speech, especially for visiting speakers. Both Oriel and Oxford’s code of practice on free speech are informed by the duties the act places on them.  Saha, a longtime advocate for the act, said: “This is exactly the kind of thing the act was designed to protect… freedom of speech means very little if it only protects ideas no one finds controversial.”

Since the announcement, the University has hosted several events emphasising the role of diversity in higher education. Directly opposing the proposed content of Cofnas’ speech,  Mansfield College hosted a talk titled “How diversity and pluralism enrich higher education” yesterday evening, though speakers expressed a desire to focus on the “values” of higher education rather than “one single event or individual”.

Helen Mountfield KC, Principal of Mansfield College, noted this event had not been phrased as a question. All speakers stated that diversity and inclusion are integral to the University. Lord Mendoza said Oxford is enriched by its diversity. Though all speakers agreed with this point, Baroness Amos disagreed with Mendoza’s conclusion: “If we are going to be at the top of the rankings then we need to be at the top of all kinds of things, including equality”. Regarding Oxford’s existing approach to DEI, she said: “Collectively, as Oxford, our response has been wanting.”

Baroness Amos praised the statements from Governing Bodies and student Common Rooms: “You are calling for us to be better.” She emphasised that policy changes only come under pressure and that pressure is necessary to create acceptable, fitting legislative frameworks. 

Legislation protecting freedom of speech and student rights against harassment and discrimination has been at the forefront of these talks. Current free speech legislation, Amos said, was drawn up with “no consideration of human impact”, and that people are “frightened” of and “hiding behind” it. David Ruebain noted that a “false dichotomy” between free speech and inclusion has been “positioned by bad actors”, saying that the University is “having to grapple with this when people have another agenda”. 

University members raised concerns about the impact of this event on Black students in Oxford.  Answering the final question of the talk, Helen Mountfield said debates surrounding sensitive topics can take place “in good faith” if respect is paid to those implicated in the discussion. 

Regarding this evening’s event, Amos encouraged students to attend: “If you feel strongly enough, go over and challenge. It is not easy. It is emotionally tiring. It takes away from your sense of who you are and your sense of belonging in your relationships in every possible way.” 

Oxford’s termly Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion Roundtable coincided with today’s event. This morning, academics, staff, and students attended panels and discussed the theme “Progress and pushback: The contested future of equality.” Tim Soutphommasane acknowledged that though this event was scheduled as part of the programme, which has been running since 2023, the discussion was “in light of events happening today”. The Diversity Officer recalled how students have come forward to express their distress and the impact this event has had on the sense of belonging for “students and staff who have had their place in Oxford questioned”. He spoke about successes in the University’s goals towards EDI, and stated that “the University’s protection of free speech does not extend [to violations of human rights and legislation against harassment]”.

‘If there’s one baby in this world who is alive as a result of our screening test, that will be enough for me’: Professor Sally Collins on maternity care, entrepreneurship, and Oxailis 

0

We begin our conversation somewhat unconventionally, discussing Professor Sally Collins’ love for acting. Striking a deal with her father, anxious about her future security and wanting her to have a “proper” degree to fall back on, Collins studied chemistry at the University of East Anglia: “It was always acting, but science kept my father happy.” After three years, however, her need to perform remained. With her father’s support, Collins completed a postgraduate diploma in theatre arts and spent her twenties working across film, television, advertisements, and theatre. 

Then came what she calls a “Damascene moment”, a turning point familiar to many navigating early adult life. While watching a play in Oxford, she overheard a highly successful actor complaining about his Hollywood career, agent, and pay. Even so many years later, Collins relates this anecdote with a palpable sense of indignation, still aggrieved by how the actor’s dissatisfaction sat against the circumstances of her friends in the industry, talented people who had devoted a lifetime to theatre, yet remained on minimal pay. 

His discontent led to unexpected self-reflection: “He’s got everything I think I want. He’s got this career that I think I want. Am I just going to end up as sad and self-interested and horrible as he is?” This encounter marked a radical change of direction, and Collins found herself pulled back towards science: “The only other thing I’d ever wanted to do in my life other than be an actor was to be a doctor.”

Collins’ career has been shaped by unexpected turns, each a testament to her willingness to embrace challenges and venture into new territory. Graduating from Oxford Clinical Medical School in 2002, Collins trained in obstetrics and gynaecology at the Thames Valley Deanery. When choosing her speciality, foetal medicine held a special attraction: “My mum was a lifelong nurse and midwife, and she made no secret of the fact that midwifery was her love… and I suppose that just lodged in my soul.”

Looking back, Collins sees her work as an actor as an important preparation for her clinical career: “I am glad I didn’t do medicine at 18 because I had a lot of growing up that I had to do. Being an actor, living on income support between jobs, helped me understand why people make the dodgy choices in life that they do”, something she felt her colleagues from more privileged backgrounds sometimes struggled to appreciate. Nor does she see the arts and medicine as opposed as one might expect: “You’ve only got to go to the hospital orchestras and see the medical school student shows to just know there is something about performance and caring that crosses over… there is something that I think is giving of yourself in performance and medicine that is very similar.”

Having her first child shortly before her final medical school exams, Collins says people assumed she would become a GP, a path that perhaps lends itself more to family life than obstetrics and gynaecology.  However, Collins knew that general practice wasn’t for her: “GPs have to know a little about everything, and that’s not really my forte. I’m much better at knowing a lot about much less.”

Her self-knowledge has proved invaluable to medicine. Collins is one of the world’s leading experts on placenta accreta spectrum, a potentially life-threatening pregnancy complication in which the placenta attaches too deeply to the uterine wall. Her doctoral research focused on using ultrasound to examine the placenta in the first trimester of pregnancy in order to predict foetal growth restriction, one of the leading causes of stillbirth: “If you’ve had to look a woman in the eye and tell her baby’s dead, you know you really don’t want to do that very often.”

The challenge, she explains, is to identify women whose babies are at risk, monitor them closely in the later stages of pregnancy to decide to deliver the baby in the case of growth restriction. Yet clinicians lacked an effective way to identify these pregnancies early enough. 

This is where Oxailis comes in. The culmination of more than 17 years of research and 2 large clinical trials involving over 7,500 women, Oxailis is an AI-based decision-support platform developed by Collins and her team. It uses ultrasound images alongside a risk stratification algorithm to detect vascular perfusion, which Collins found to be a critical marker of disease.  

Crucially, Oxailis is a “very simple technology. It’s just software that analyses ordinary images. We don’t need any extra or different hardware. We just use the ordinary ultrasounds that come off ultrasound machines”. In a health service where financial constraints and limited access to equipment can pose significant barriers to adopting medical innovations, this is a significant advantage. 

And the results so far are highly encouraging. Collins speaks proudly of the software’s performance against current screening tests: “For the same false positive rate, we detect almost twice as many growth-restricted babies.” Collins’ initial breakthrough in obstetrics now also has potential applications beyond pregnancy, in ovarian and prostate cancer screening and in nephrology. 

Oxailis officially spun out of the University late last year, and it is nearing the close of its first angel investment round while making progress towards regulatory approval. This is a significant milestone for Collins and her husband, who have poured their life savings into the venture, demonstrating their commitment and belief in its value. Collins acknowledges the University’s integral role in the company’s success as Oxailis received a substantial grant from its Strategic Innovation Fund. However, she also emphasises the importance of continued institutional support for innovation, particularly amid the extensive financial cuts to research. “Oxford has more brilliant scientists and more great ideas and more phenomenal research than just about anywhere … the University probably needs to invest a little more in supporting them.” 

I ask Collins what she has learnt from navigating fields as diverse as drama, medicine, and now entrepreneurship, and what has sustained her through the inevitable rejections and setbacks. “If you’re too frightened of failure to try something, then you’d fail. Inherently, you’ll fail. You have to try. The only way that you won’t end up on your deathbed, regretting things is to give it 110% when you have the opportunity and stop when it’s not happening and move on and don’t let it stop you from trying again.”

Earlier this year, Collins retired from clinical practice. The delivery of her final baby proved more emotional than anticipated: “I was more emotional about it than I expected I would be. But I have to admit, I’m quite glad to be out. The NHS is a hard place to work at the moment.”

Our conversation did touch on the pressures facing maternity services. Years of negative headlines, staff shortages, financial strain, and rising litigation have, in Collins’ view, eroded public confidence in healthcare professionals: “By the time I retired this March, I just felt like they had totally lost faith in us. And that’s really sad because maternity is packed full of people who just want to do their best.”

Indeed, part of Collins’ research has been focused on looking at post-traumatic stress following childbirth.  Having had two children herself and cared for thousands of women, she is particularly troubled by the fact that emotional wellbeing is often among the first things sacrificed when services come under pressure. She recalls how just a few sentences could make the difference to a woman’s experience of childbirth, particularly after an assisted delivery: “When I did a forceps delivery, I always used to say to the woman: ‘I know I delivered your baby with forceps, but you did the hard work. You laboured to full dilation. You pushed this baby down low enough that I could help you at the very last minute. You have not failed. You did brilliantly.’” Yet in a system stretched to its limits, the time and space needed to offer this reassurance are increasingly hard to find.

Despite these challenges, Collins has no regrets: “I’ve been there at some of the most amazing moments in people’s lives, and I’ve been there at some of the absolute worst times in people’s lives. You can’t stop awful things happening to good people; that happens every day. But if you can make a little bit of a difference and make it more bearable, that is what you can bring to it.”

Oxailis represents the latest stage in Collins’ lifelong commitment to care: “I am the most inadvertent entrepreneur. It was no plan of mine. But we had something too precious to just let it go. And if there’s one baby in this world who is alive as a result of our screening test, that will be enough for me.”

‘The world has a lot to do with our agony’: Palestinian Ambassador Husam Zomlot

0

An unassuming building lies in the depths of a West London suburb. It is indistinguishable on a residential street, marked out only by a red, white, black, and green flag protruding from its entrance, a rectangular burst of colour against an otherwise monotone backdrop. Yet this unassuming building is historic. It houses the Embassy of the State of Palestine to the United Kingdom, officially inaugurated in January 2026 following the UK government’s formal recognition of Palestinian statehood. At its head stands Dr Husam Zomlot, Palestine’s ambassador to the UK.

As I enter his office, Zomlot offers me tea and welcomes my imperfect Arabic greetings. He suggests that we move from his desk to the more comfortable sofa and armchair for the interview, refilling his Iqos as we speak. Despite his relaxed manner, he is reluctant to make himself the subject of our conversation. He rejects the idea of a profile piece focused on him as an individual, with the weight of his responsibility as a representative of the Palestinian people evident in his insistence that there are other pressing issues to discuss. So, we do.

Zomlot’s parents were displaced from their home village of Simsim, northeast of Gaza, during the mass expulsion of Palestinians in the Nakba in 1948. Born a generation later, he spent his childhood in a refugee camp in Rafah, southern Gaza. “[It] was a happy childhood. I was a happy child. We did not have normal homes. It was makeshift homes and tents… but for a child, that’s home.”

Zomlot recalls a “very strong sense of community” in the camp, forged through the shared experience of displacement, remembering “the warmth of our parents, our families and our extended community, because all of them have gone through the experience of the Nakba. Our parents and grandparents made sure that we were, in a way, insulated from the tragedy of some years earlier”.

However, his family’s efforts to shield him from the political realities of displacement were impossible to sustain once he became exposed to life outside the refugee camp. His first experiences of travel, visiting Egypt and other Palestinian cities, exposed him to a world which stood in stark contrast to his own. “Something was not right. To see life beyond the refugee camp – definitely, something was not right.”

By his early teens, Zomlot began to understand the source of this unease. The outbreak of the First Intifada beginning in 1987, a sustained Palestinian resistance against Israel’s military occupation of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, brought the realities of occupation into sharper focus. He participated in the uprising, experiencing the imposition of curfews and witnessing the arrests of classmates. “As we grew up, we came face to face with reality… the political reality started to really hit home.”

Alongside this growing awareness of the occupation, Zomlot’s childhood was shaped by a different external presence: the international community. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA), which provided him with education and other essential services, was central to his upbringing.

“As a child I always thought that there was the bad – the bad was those with green military uniforms – and there are the goods with the blue hats and the blue flag and the 4x4s.” This distinction was, in his childhood understanding, a simple one. “The good people are the people who provided for us education, health, you know, a better future, cared for us. There was international care.”

“But there was also a bad aspect of the international community,” he adds, referring to the 1917 Balfour Declaration, in which the British government promised a “national home for the Jewish people” in Palestine. “The world has a lot to do with our agony, starting with Britain… promising our land to another people without consulting us.

“As I was growing, I also started realising with this First Intifada in the backdrop that, no matter what we do as Palestinians, without changing the international arena, and international conscience about us, and action about us, we cannot do it on our own.” This conviction in the international community’s capacity to protect Palestinian self-determination would shape Zomlot’s career, beginning with his first professional position as an economic adviser to the UN’s Middle East peace process coordinator. “My first job was with the United Nations. And that was by design. That was on purpose… thinking about the 4×4 as my army. So I wanted to join my army.”

Despite this early determination to engage with the international community, the ambassador’s path into diplomacy was far from straightforward. “Diplomacy, for me, is such an accidental evolution of who I am,” he remarks, describing a conception of diplomacy shaped more by Palestine’s struggle for self-determination than traditional statecraft.

The ambassador experienced firsthand the limitations of conventional diplomacy in the Palestinian context during President Trump’s closure of the Palestine Liberation Organisation’s delegation in Washington, which he headed at the time. As a result, his diplomatic visa was revoked, and his family were forced to leave the US. Given this experience, Zomlot explains, his responsibility extends beyond the diplomatic sphere.

“Our situation is a little bit different. We are under occupation and struggling for our freedom and our rights. So, for me, it is a combination of diplomacy… we have many diplomatic relations, diplomatic agreements, memoranda of understanding, trade, what have you – but also part of our work is advocacy. We see ourselves as the voice of our people, whatever and whenever we are posted.

“That’s what diplomacy is. Diplomacy is about really presenting the interest and the story of your people, no matter what.”

Engaging with and mobilising the public is, in Zomlot’s vision, central to achieving progress. “I, as an ambassador, who usually does not take part in demonstrations and marches and whatnot,  I was marching almost every time.

“This is unusual in diplomacy, but we live in very unusual times. If you want to ask what most of my time was spent on, it’s the bottom, bottom as in the base, particularly the young generation.”

In light of the suppression of pro-Palestine protests on UK university campuses in recent years, Zomlot is passionate about highlighting the importance of youth participation within the Palestinian movement, situating student activism within a long history of popular pressure for political change. “The youth are the moral compass in any equation. You are oriented by one thing: humanity.

“You don’t have all the calculations the older generations have. You know, you’re just about to begin your journey in life. And the younger you are, the more moral, the more principled, the more social and just in your thinking about others.”

In particular, he emphasises Oxford University’s significant global influence in protecting students’ right to protest. “It’s not a responsibility of universities. It’s an obligation. The whole idea of these institutions that were established like yours, almost a thousand years ago, is to give the young the space to breathe, and to develop, and to evolve into the leaders we want for our societies.”

But for Zomlot, the obligation incumbent upon universities extends beyond upholding the right to student protest, as he calls for divestment from “any institution that is implicated in the genocide.

“They have an obligation to make sure that they do not invest in illegalities. We’re not talking about individual settlers or individual organisations here. We’re talking about the entire ecosystem of occupation. Universities have to pay attention. Otherwise, they are no longer a place of learning, a place of good.”

The question of institutional responsibility also applies to the Western media, where the ambassador sees Palestinian representation as equally consequential. Reflecting on his first interviews as head of the Palestinian mission to the UK, he emphasises the weight of representing Palestine to an international audience. “There was that heavy responsibility of a Palestinian who’s in London, who needs to speak to the English-speaking world and to the international media. It was not easy, and I know the responsibility.”

Zomlot’s early encounters with the British mainstream media left him frustrated with what he perceives as a persistent double standard in its coverage of Palestine. He accuses the media of “disfiguring the Palestinian struggle” by “stripping the story out of context all the time” and “trying to dissolve Israel of any responsibility”.

In particular, he highlights a viral interview with Piers Morgan, in which he was repeatedly pressed to condemn Hamas. “Hamas has committed crimes during these events. Targeting civilians is unacceptable. But the mainstream media, the BBCs and the Skys and the CNNs and all those, wanted to play the game of the last 80 years… to paint a picture that the aggressors are the Palestinians, and then Israel is just in a state of constant self-defence.”

“The game is always to extract from you that admission”, he explains. “Because then, once the question is asked, it doesn’t matter. You are guilty. You see? You are guilty. So we didn’t play that game.”

But due to a shift in British public opinion, Zomlot asserts, “there has been change under the pressure and the pushback. Things have begun to change. But this change is not enough for you to make sure that the main media outlets are there to tell the truth, and nothing but the truth. They haven’t done that for a long time.”

His frustration with powerful British institutions, however, does not diminish his conviction in Britain’s capacity to shape the international response to Palestine. Speaking at the UK Foreign Affairs Committee in 2024, the ambassador stated that the UK was “one of the few nations in the world in a position to step forward to fill a vacuum of global leadership”. When asked whether he maintains this position today, he responds with conviction: “One hundred per cent.”

“The UK is the penholder in international diplomacy,” he continues, highlighting its unique relations with both European countries and the US. “[It] has such a historic responsibility for the mistakes that were committed and the wrongs that were done, but also has the knowledge and the convening power.

“Washington is the head of the Western system… but London is the neck. When the neck moves, it’s moving definitely after a thorough assessment, moving in the right direction.”

The UK’s recent announcement of a proposed sanctions regime on 8th September, targeting entities involved in Israeli West Bank settlements, illegal under international law, marked an important development for the Palestinian ambassador. Having spent decades of his life campaigning for tangible measures like this, he recalls the significance of hearing the announcement. “I was there when Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband said, ‘We hear you.’ … Now, that is such a statement. Such a statement.”

At the same time as the UK’s announcement, eleven other countries announced similar measures, including France, Canada, Australia, and Spain. Zomlot sees this international mobilisation as evidence of the influential power of British diplomatic efforts. “If the UK leads, and we have a global regime of sanctions, and we have a coordinated effort to raise the cost of the illegality, then the calculus will change.”

But from the ambassador’s perspective, this hope for progress does not extend to the Trump administration, describing the US president’s political career as being characterised by “knee-jerk reactions”. Having represented Palestine in both the UK and US, he is uniquely positioned to compare the two: “The world does not consider Britain to be in that category. Britain is much more solid on the professional, legal, political assessments and the credibility of whatever decisions they make.”

Zomlot is equally reluctant to consider the announced sanctions a personal triumph. “I don’t live on expectations. I live on delivery and work. This is not the end of the road. It’s the beginning of the road. But it’s a powerful beginning, and we need to build on it. And we need to make sure that the government continues on this track.”

His insistence on delivery reflects a broader scepticism about the capacity of political change, on its own, to confront the scale of Palestinian suffering. At the time of our conversation, Israeli elections were approaching, yet the ambassador remained sceptical that a change in leadership would translate into meaningful progress. “There is almost a political consensus among the political Zionist parties in Israel not to recognise the Palestinian people and Palestinian rights, including the rights of determination.”

“Netanyahu is not the cause. Netanyahu is the product,” he adds. “The only difference would be that he would not be seen as the devil in the world. So the world might say, ‘okay, let’s give them a chance’. That’s the biggest issue.”

For Zomlot, the question of Palestine’s future cannot ultimately be answered by a change in Israeli leadership, nor solely in the conditions imposed by international actors. Rather, it rests on the Palestinian people’s own right to determine their political future. Yet the recent postponement of elections under Mahmoud Abbas, President of the State of Palestine and Palestinian National Authority, has been widely criticised, leaving Palestinians without a national election since 2006.

“Elections are a crucial thing, and the Palestinian people have the absolute sacred, inalienable right to elect their leaders. It’s long overdue, and we must do it. I was personally hoping that it would be done in November this year, as was promised and announced. But how can we do the elections under the current circumstances?” Zomlot says.

“The world needs to understand that we do not function in a normal situation. We function under the most severe segregation of apartheid system. How do you do real elections? Perfect elections, democratic elections, inclusive elections, under occupation?”

As our conversation draws to a close, Zomlot turns his attention to the generation that will inherit the consequences of today’s political decisions. He urges British students “to live up to the expectations and the reputation and the history of their parents and grandparents. The student movement of this country has always been at the forefront”.

For a man who has spent his career urging the international community to uphold its own principles, his parting words are a pointed reminder of the responsibility that falls on the next generation: “Fear nothing if what you’re doing is sticking by the values.”

Oxford bridges ‘town and gown’ with guide for local students

0

The University of Oxford has produced a guide to strengthen the link between the academic institution and local schools. 

This resource, Opening Oxford, focuses on what the University can give to local communities, and how the University itself can benefit from interacting with the wider region. In the foreword, Vice-Chancellor Irene Tracey described the University’s commitment to  “strengthening the University’s links with our local communities” and “ensuring young people across Oxfordshire can see opportunities in the University, whether that is study, employment, or interest in our cultural assets”. She added that universities “thrive when they are part of the life of their region”.

Within the guide, curriculum-linked workshops, enrichment opportunities, and lectures are recommended to realise the University’s vision. The activities featured are available for primary school students through to those navigating higher education and career choices.

It also emphasises helping educators through teacher development opportunities and classroom resources. Specific programmes and resources, such as a two-week research programme at Oxford University Museum of Natural History for sixth-formers and St Anne’s Super-Curricular club which offers online classes, are recommended for those considering applying to universities, including Oxford. It highlights post-school opportunities at the University, such as work experience, careers, and apprenticeships.

This guide contributes to the University’s 2025-2030 Strategic Plan, which outlines how the University will partner with the local community to “sustain excellence in education and research, extend our impact through innovation, and exercise leadership…for the benefit of society”.

The project also builds on the academic outreach that the University has previously developed. Similar to The Oxford College Twinning Project, it attempts to develop a reciprocal relationship between town and gown in the city.

Pro-Vice Chancellor for External Engagement, Sport, and Community, Professor Alex Betts, acknowledges that available initiatives and outreach are “not always visible or transparent to teachers across Oxfordshire”. In his introduction to the guide, he hopes it will help close the educational attainment gap and ensure Oxford is not viewed by young people as “distant and unrelated to their lives”.  

The programme’s aim overall is to make the University “relevant and inspiring to all”, not only to its students.

Law degree under review after report finds college teaching disparities

0

External examiners have raised concerns about teaching disparities between colleges as Oxford University’s BA Jurisprudence (Law) degree falls under faculty review.

In a 2026 report seen by Cherwell, both examiners outlined concerns about teaching disparities between Oxford colleges that could affect law students in Final Honour School (FHS) examinations. They questioned whether coordination between colleges was adequate and critiqued a “lack of process” in ensuring students are taught in a “roughly consistent way”. 

“There seems to me to be a real possibility of unfairness depending on the topics chosen by the individual tutor in the College and the difficulty of individual questions on the paper,” the report said. One examiner suggested that these issues might not be resolved through simply broadening questions on the paper, while another questioned whether action was needed “to ensure a level playing field across the students in the University”.

Speaking to Cherwell, a final year law student described the situation as “problematic” for students. They said: “The faculty just don’t have enough control over what tutors put on their reading list.”

They told Cherwell that there is no set order for law tutors to teach topics. With the faculty reading list sometimes containing 10-12 weeks of content, this forces some students to teach themselves, especially if the topics not chosen by tutors are easier to score highly on in exams. 

They also claimed that in rare instances, some tutors will not include mandatory cases on their reading lists. While these are available to find on the faculty reading list, “it’s on you to make sure you’ve been taught correctly”, according to the student.

Another student claimed that, in last year’s Administrative Law exam, finalists at their college were significantly disadvantaged because they were only taught the first eight weeks of content. They told Cherwell that at colleges where tutors were more versed in administrative law, students were taught more content which was less complex and more likely to come up in exams.

Another law student who graduated in 2025 told Cherwell that they found the tailoring of teaching to exams and the quality of essay feedback varied greatly between colleges.

A University spokesperson told Cherwell: “Undergraduate law teaching combines lectures and classes provided by the Faculty with tutorials arranged by individual colleges. While colleges are responsible for their own tutorial provision, we recognise the importance of ensuring that students are appropriately prepared for their examinations, regardless of their college.”

Cherwell understands that the Faculty of Law is has been reviewing the course and its teaching provision since 2022.