Do the ‘good old days’ really exist?

Please mind the gap between the train and the platform. 

As I wait on the gritty station sideline, I realise there is something rather fitting about being repeatedly reminded of the existence of a gap, especially when I seem to spend so much of my life inhabiting one. Between countries, languages, expectations, and realities. Originally from Seoul, I’ve grown up across different parts of the UK and spent the past two years studying at Columbia University in New York. This October, I arrived in Oxford as a visiting student for the year, leaving behind newfound familiarity for another year of novelty, determined to make the most of my youth. Yet somewhere between the anticipation of coming here and the reality of actually being here, I began to question what ‘making the most’ of anything really means. 

We are told, restlessly, again and again that our twenties are the best years of our lives, that we must accumulate experiences like gemstones in a game, pursue opportunities, and live in such a way that we will have something extraordinary to look back on. Ah, the Good Old Days. But what constitutes an experience worth having? Why does living life to the fullest so often seem to demand constant movement and change? I’ve increasingly begun to wonder whether, in trying to make these years worth remembering, we are overlooking the quieter, gentler forms of happiness that make them worth living. Perhaps the gap we should be minding is not simply between our expectations and reality, but between the lives we think we ought to be living and the ones we actually want. 

21. New York. A balmy summer evening. 

Surrounded by friends on the rooftop of my first apartment, I blew out the candles in haste, worried that the soft but palpable breeze would beat me to it. In my long, silky dress of purply-plum – instead of a girlish, shorter one of lacy black – I felt a validity in my emerging sophistication. I imagined myself resembling a woman with a sleek name, possessing tidy drawers, ironed shirts, and a weekly routine of buying fresh flowers. Yet the frosted rainbow cake in front of me made me feel juvenile, perhaps even younger than before. My drawers were rarely tidy, my shirts seldom ironed, and my apartment probably saw more rats than flowers. Then, as I mindlessly consumed a slice of sprinkly, spongy decadence, I suddenly remembered: I hadn’t made a birthday wish. 

Ever since I developed an affection for superstition, around the age of ten or so, I have projected a long list of desires onto every eyelash, every dandelion, every full moon. So the reality of not having made a wish for my 21st birthday caught my heart by surprise. Unlike the concrete ambitions I firmly grasped at 12 or even 18, my dreams and possibilities now felt more nebulous, more sandy. My wishes, if I possessed any in particular, seemed to slip through the gaps between my fingers. Despite the cheery conversations swaying between old and new friends, their roaring laughter and rosy faces of boozy glee, the biggest thing I felt – admittedly, guiltily – was a pit in my stomach. I was meant to be happy. 

Strikingly, I felt a bit like Esther Greenwood in Sylvia Plath’s The Bell Jar. No, I’m not going to mention the famous fig tree analogy, but rather the beginning of the novel, where she explains: “I was supposed to be having the time of my life.” She, too, was experiencing a “queer, sultry summer” in New York, interning at a magazine, which was what I was coincidentally also doing. Although I didn’t quite feel the harrowing intensity of Esther’s unhappiness, I recognised the discrepancy between the life I appeared to be living and the life I felt I was experiencing. Everything was supposedly in place for happiness. So why did I feel its absence? 

With retrospective clarity, I’ve tried to deconstruct the feelings of that birthday night, the one I still hold onto during certain nights of loneliness. 

To begin with, I was moving again when I had finally created a home in New York, not only in finding a physical, liveable apartment but in carving out a space of emotional belonging. Pushing past the superficiality, bright lights, and urgency to collect social currency that I had sometimes encountered at Columbia, I had found my best friends (we call ourselves the ‘sparklemuffins’) among whom I could be sandwiched and nestled up forever, eating soup around a table, and drinking ciders on crisp evenings. 

These were the friends who came to my rescue when, on a Saturday morning, I called helplessly, unable to assemble IKEA furniture. They spent six hours building my needlessly complicated bedframe so I could sleep on a foundation of love for a year. And I was letting it go. Not forever, but for a year, which may be short in the grand scheme of things, but quite long in the context of university, because I was determined to ‘make the most of my youth’ and come to Oxford. 

For me, making the most of things has always meant being in constant movement. Between sky streams and fickle grounds, I moved and moved and moved. Shifting identities, languages, characters. Weaving in and out of myself. Korean to British. British to American. American to Korean. For a long time, I thought I was energised by this momentum, instinctively equating change with progress and stability with stagnation. If I stopped, I would not only slow down, but fall off. 

Coming to Oxford was, in part, another expression of that impulse. I wanted something different, something exciting, something that would make these years worth remembering. Yet, on leaving New York, I began to wonder why the quieter happiness I had unexpectedly found there – the soup, the cider, the six-hour bedframe – hadn’t seemed like enough of an experience in itself. 

But that isn’t to say I regret coming to Oxford. Quite the opposite. I wanted to be here, and I still do. What I’ve begun to question is not the desire to experience something new, but the obligation to make every experience extraordinary, worthy of being retold as an amazing story – whatever that means. There is also a peculiar pressure that comes with knowing I have only one year here, as though every afternoon spent doing something unremarkable is an afternoon squandered. Yet the Oxford I imagined before arriving, and the Oxford I am actually inhabiting, are inevitably different places. And perhaps that’s not necessarily a disappointment. 

Please mind the gap between the train and the platform. 

I imagine I’ll continue to hear this announcement throughout my year at Oxford, just as I’ll continue to find gaps between the lives I imagine and the ones I actually live. Perhaps the mistake is expecting those gaps to disappear, or believing that happiness must look the way we imagined it would. 

We are often chasing something shown in scenic films or in the pages of our beloved books of teenagehood, but what I’ve found I treasure most is the love that doesn’t make it into the movies. Calling a friend for an extortionate eight hours whilst cleaning my room. Studying together until mutual delirium. The joy of

discovering a shared dislike of a particular class or topic: “I’m so glad you feel that way too!” 

Perhaps the ‘good old days’ do exist, but not necessarily in the way we imagine them. We tend to recognise them retrospectively, once the uncertainties of living through them have faded and the ordinary has acquired the sentimental weight of memory. But must we wait until these days have passed to appreciate them? Perhaps making the most of our youth isn’t about accumulating thrilling experiences that lend themselves to wild anecdotes, but recognising the significance of ordinary ones while we’re still living through them.

Check out our other content

Most Popular Articles