CW: Racism, discrimination, death.
This evening, Oriel College will host a talk by Nathan Cofnas titled “Does DEI undermine higher education?” His presence in Oxford, following an invitation from the student-run Reform society, has been met with considerable objections from students and staff. The University must balance Freedom of Speech legislation and its commitment to protecting the welfare and rights of its students against racism and harassment.
Cofnas, a self-described “race realist”, is a postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University, but was previously dismissed by Emmanuel College, Cambridge, after writing a blog post claiming that the number of Black academics would “approach zero” under a meritocracy. Cambridge’s internal investigation later found that his comments did not constitute discrimination or harassment.
In July, Cofnas posted on Substack accusing Jason Arday, who became Cambridge’s youngest-ever Black professor in 2023, of plagiarising his doctoral thesis. Arday, who denied plagiarising, resigned from Cambridge after weeks of media scrutiny and was found dead on 14th August. Liverpool John Moores University, which awarded the doctorate, concluded Arday’s doctorate should stand.
The newly registered student society, Oxon Universities’ Reform Society (OURS), organised the event. The society bears the name “Oxon” because it has not yet been registered with the University Proctors for long enough.
The OURS are not affiliated with the national party Reform UK. In a statement to Cherwell, Jack Eccles, the president of Reform’s student branch, said he “will contact the group personally… and ensure that they do not falsely claim to speak on behalf of the party”.
Eccles’ statement comes after antisemitic writings by the OURS President, Vittorio Cuneo-Flood, were uncovered by Stand Up To Racism and subsequently in Cherwell. Cuneo-Flood had written that “Satan sow[s] confusion and spread[s] perplexity” through “the false notion of ‘Anti-Semitism’”, adding that Jewish people were “promoting Satan’s plan”. He also stated that the “denial of equal rights between Catholicism and Judaism” is “right”. These statements have been described by Stand Up To Racism as antisemitic, and fall under the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, which the University of Oxford has upheld since 2016.
After Cherwell’s report, The Times published photographs provided by the antifascist group Red Flare showing that Cuneo-Flood attended a conference held by Homeland last year. Homeland has been described as the “biggest fascist, neo-Nazi party in the UK”, but it denies these claims. Cuneo-Flood did not respond to Cherwell’s request for comment.
OURS has also not responded to Cherwell’s request for comment since its initial Instagram statement, which said it was “committed to broadening participation in University life by removing systemic barriers for marginalised voices”. The society added: “Nathan Cofnas has been repeatedly victimised with stigmatising language and structural apartheid by those with institutional power and privilege.”
Responding to initial social media backlash, the society shared a post by Cofnas saying that Stand Up To Racism’s planned protest was a “predictable response by the epistemic oppressors”. OURS have also condemned calls for violence against Cofnas circulating on social media in relation to the event.
The society added: “Constituent colleges of the University are under a legal obligation to host events like ours by virtue of the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023.”
Cuneo-Flood is a student at Oriel and is responsible for organising today’s event. In response to the event’s announcement, Oriel stated it is the College’s policy to permit events booked by students who are committee members of registered societies, but that “permission does not imply endorsement by the College”.
Oriel’s JCR, MCR, and SCR – the organisations representing Oriel undergraduates, postgraduates, and academics – have all released statements condemning Cofnas in the past week. The JCR statement, approved by 90.61% of voting students, says that “the shock and distress that this event has inspired is difficult to express” and “we consider them [Cofnas’s views] despicable”.
However, it goes on to accept that the Act means the college is legally required to allow this talk to proceed and “further recognise[s] the College’s commitment to ensuring that the University of Oxford remains a forum for free speech”, citing the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023 to say that “the College is legally required to allow this talk to proceed”.
The statement also expresses “deep anger” at Cofnas and the OURS, which it describes as “the two actors benefitting most from the controversy this event is causing”. Oriel JCR said that the OURS’ invitation and “attempt to offer legitimacy to his views deliberately creates division and is intentionally inflammatory”. “We believe that they are acutely aware of the impact that their decision has had, particularly on this community,” it adds.
“This College is our home and should not be defined by the speakers it is legally required to host. It is defined by the values and actions of its members, and we ask that we be judged on these terms.”
The JCR statement also praises the College for its communication and involvement in protecting student welfare and “accommodating the rights of students and individuals to exercise their freedom of speech in opposition to Cofnas”. It continues: “We are also disheartened by the inaccurate claims propagated online and in-person that Oriel College, and by extension its members, support the content of this talk.”
Oriel’s Governing Body and student representatives have taken measures to protect students. Due to safety concerns for students who live on the same site where the talk was planned to be held, the event has been moved from the Harris Lecture Theatre to the library building. Oriel students have also been notified of a security presence within the college from this afternoon, including limiting access to the main gate only and requiring university cards on entry.
Thames Valley Police are responsible for ensuring public safety for events happening outside University premises, such as the Oriel Square demonstration. Oriel has reassured students that it is in “regular contact” with the police about their arrangements and monitoring the situation.
In response, Oriel student representatives have worked alongside the Deans and Domestic Bursar to organise a corresponding demonstration for students to express their views within the College: an on-site demonstration area designated for students to do so safely and in line with the College’s Code of Practice on Freedom of Speech. Students will be permitted to protest within the College prior to the talk and afterwards, and once the talk has started, there will be an ‘Oriel Celebration’ in the bar, with board games, crafts, an open bar, hot drinks, pizza, sweet treats, and snacks to “celebrate the Oriel community”. Non-protesters, including staff, students, and the SCR, are welcome to attend. The JCR “recognise that many find the speaker’s views, and the subject of the talk, distressing” and have identified a room where students can take refuge if they feel overwhelmed by the events.
Over the weekend, Oriel JCR hosted a placard-making session, and Oxford City Councillor Alfie Davis met with students to discuss security arrangements for this evening. Speaking to Cherwell, Davis said: “The JCR community have themselves stepped up to lead and protect each other, even though they shouldn’t have had to.”
Statements released by several colleges and societies have also objected to the event, and the SU and Common Rooms’ joint statement, decided at the Universities’ Extraordinary Conference of Common Rooms, “unequivocally” condemned the talk. This morning, the Board of the Faculty of Philosophy also released a statement via email reiterating its commitment to addressing racism and harassment and that, though it acknowledges the University’s commitment to free speech, it “does not indicate endorsement of Dr Cofnas’s views.”
Last Thursday, activist group Led By Donkeys also placed a KKK hood and a sign reading “Racists welcome here” on Oriel’s controversial statue of Cecil Rhodes. In response, the Provost of Oriel College, Lord Mendoza, told members of the college in an email: “Your college will not be intimidated. We will continue to support the work of our outstanding staff to make it clear that Oriel College is a place where all members of our community belong.”
A protest in Oriel Square is expected to begin at 5pm today, following a Stand Up To Racism petition signed by over 30,000 people. Prominent figures including Diane Abbott, Zarah Sultana, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, and Jeremy Corbyn have signed a further Stand Up To Racism statement. Cherwell understands that facial recognition cameras have been installed outside Oriel, following an announcement by Thames Valley Police last week.
Joylon Maugham of The Good Law Project, who is expected to speak for Stand Up To Racism at the protest, told Cherwell: “I could weep at the harm Bridget Philippson has done. The immense hurt this event is causing to Black students and academics; the damage to our university system; the undermining of important, recent anti-racism work done by Oriel; the centring of a far-right racist agenda in Britain’s most important seat of learning – all of these harms are attributable to her unfathomable embrace of the last Government’s attack on the dignity of minoritised groups.”
However, some have supported the Nathan Cofnas talk. An open letter signed by over 170 academics worldwide, including eight from Oxford, thanked Oriel for “standing firm in the face of calls to cancel Dr Nathan Cofnas’s talk”, citing freedom of speech and academic freedom as “fundamental to the mission of the University”. One signatory, Abhishek Saha, who is a Professor of Mathematics at Queen Mary University of London, told Cherwell: “The proper response to ideas one considers false, offensive, and in this case, many have talked about safety or dangerous ideas, is in every case to subject them to the same things: criticism, evidence, argument, counter-speech, and not to prevent them from being heard.”
Saha also praised the 2023 Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act, which Oriel has cited as informing its decision not to cancel the talk. The act strengthens universities’ and colleges’ duties to protect free speech, especially for visiting speakers. Both Oriel and Oxford’s code of practice on free speech are informed by the duties the act places on them. Saha, a longtime advocate for the act, said: “This is exactly the kind of thing the act was designed to protect… freedom of speech means very little if it only protects ideas no one finds controversial.”
Since the announcement, the University has hosted several events emphasising the role of diversity in higher education. Directly opposing the proposed content of Cofnas’ speech, Mansfield College hosted a talk titled “How diversity and pluralism enrich higher education” yesterday evening, though speakers expressed a desire to focus on the “values” of higher education rather than “one single event or individual”.
Helen Mountfield KC, Principal of Mansfield College, noted this event had not been phrased as a question. All speakers stated that diversity and inclusion are integral to the University. Lord Mendoza said Oxford is enriched by its diversity. Though all speakers agreed with this point, Baroness Amos disagreed with Mendoza’s conclusion: “If we are going to be at the top of the rankings then we need to be at the top of all kinds of things, including equality”. Regarding Oxford’s existing approach to DEI, she said: “Collectively, as Oxford, our response has been wanting.”
Baroness Amos praised the statements from Governing Bodies and student Common Rooms: “You are calling for us to be better.” She emphasised that policy changes only come under pressure and that pressure is necessary to create acceptable, fitting legislative frameworks.
Legislation protecting freedom of speech and student rights against harassment and discrimination has been at the forefront of these talks. Current free speech legislation, Amos said, was drawn up with “no consideration of human impact”, and that people are “frightened” of and “hiding behind” it. David Ruebain noted that a “false dichotomy” between free speech and inclusion has been “positioned by bad actors”, saying that the University is “having to grapple with this when people have another agenda”.
University members raised concerns about the impact of this event on Black students in Oxford. Answering the final question of the talk, Helen Mountfield said debates surrounding sensitive topics can take place “in good faith” if respect is paid to those implicated in the discussion.
Regarding this evening’s event, Amos encouraged students to attend: “If you feel strongly enough, go over and challenge. It is not easy. It is emotionally tiring. It takes away from your sense of who you are and your sense of belonging in your relationships in every possible way.”
Oxford’s termly Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion Roundtable coincided with today’s event. This morning, academics, staff, and students attended panels and discussed the theme “Progress and pushback: The contested future of equality.” Tim Soutphommasane acknowledged that though this event was scheduled as part of the programme, which has been running since 2023, the discussion was “in light of events happening today”. The Diversity Officer recalled how students have come forward to express their distress and the impact this event has had on the sense of belonging for “students and staff who have had their place in Oxford questioned”. He spoke about successes in the University’s goals towards EDI, and stated that “the University’s protection of free speech does not extend [to violations of human rights and legislation against harassment]”.

