Oxford University’s BA Jurisprudence (Law) degree is under faculty review following concerns raised by external examiners and echoed by students, about teaching disparities between colleges.
In a 2026 report seen by Cherwell, both examiners outlined concerns about teaching disparities between Oxford colleges that could affect law students in Final Honour School (FHS) examinations. They questioned whether coordination between colleges was adequate and critiqued a “lack of process” in ensuring students are taught in a “roughly consistent way”.
“There seems to me to be a real possibility of unfairness depending on the topics chosen by the individual tutor in the College and the difficulty of individual questions on the paper,” the report said. One examiner suggested that these issues might not be resolved through simply broadening questions on the paper, while another questioned whether action was needed “to ensure a level playing field across the students in the University”.
Speaking to Cherwell, a final year law student described the situation as “problematic” for students. They said: “The faculty just don’t have enough control over what tutors put on their reading list.”
They told Cherwell that there is no set order for law tutors to teach topics. With the faculty reading list sometimes containing 10-12 weeks of content, this forces some students to teach themselves, especially if the topics not chosen by tutors are easier to score highly on in exams.
They also claimed that in rare instances, some tutors will not include mandatory cases on their reading lists. While these are available to find on the faculty reading list, “it’s on you to make sure you’ve been taught correctly”, according to the student.
Another student claimed that, in last year’s Administrative Law exam, finalists at their college were significantly disadvantaged because they were only taught the first eight weeks of content. They told Cherwell that at colleges where tutors were more versed in administrative law, students were taught more content which was less complex and more likely to come up in exams.
Another law student who graduated in 2025 told Cherwell that they found the tailoring of teaching to exams and the quality of essay feedback varied greatly between colleges.
A University spokesperson told Cherwell: “Undergraduate law teaching combines lectures and classes provided by the Faculty with tutorials arranged by individual colleges. While colleges are responsible for their own tutorial provision, we recognise the importance of ensuring that students are appropriately prepared for their examinations, regardless of their college.”
Cherwell understands that the Faculty of Law is currently reviewing the course and its teaching provision in a working group.

