Cherwell.org - Student news and reviews at Oxford University
Friday 3rd September, 2010
Cherwell Pick up your copy of Bang! this week
A grinding form of productivity Bookmark and Share

by Joseph King | 17:31 GMT, Thu 04 February 2010

News of these new brain boosting substances first hit Oxford about a year ago, but all has remained mysteriously quiet since. However, in the aftermath of the recent Nature debate which brought to light that 16% of American college students were regularly using cognitive enhancers, universities across the UK will soon have to get serious on the smart-pills debate.

'The substances facilitate a pinched, unromantic, grindingly efficient form of productivity'

Students are turning to these substances in preference to the traditional stimulants of coffee and cigarettes to help them work harder, meet deadlines, and concentrate in exams. They don't inspire new, original ideas. Rather, they facilitate a pinched, unromantic, grindingly efficient form of productivity. But what are the offending articles?

Most notorious is Ritalin, a stimulant drug introduced in 1956 for the treatment of attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Ritalin's less infamous accomplices are Modafinil (a drug used to treat the sleep disorder narcolepsy), Donepezil (used to treat dementia) and Amphetamines. The most attractive aspect of drugs like Ritalin and Modafinil is that they seem to have no addictive potential.

'Oxford students are already devouring instant-coffee granules off tea spoons in order to bypass the time-wasting water boiling stage'

If this study aid was endorsed by universities, it would probably spread like wildfire, particularly in an environment like Oxford where students are already devouring instant-coffee granules off tea spoons in order to bypass the time-wasting water boiling stage.

So why not just stock up on these pills? Well, coercion might be one argument against; if a significant number of Oxford students start ‘using', then the rest might be simply coerced into popping pills in order to stay on top. There's also the linked question of disparity in society and the fact that only wealthy people would be able to regularly afford the drugs. Also, what's the difference between this and sport, where the use of performance enhancing drugs is considered grossly unfair in such a competitive environment? Mental activities are clearly competitive too.

Ethical considerations aside, I would prefer to wait and see how the long-term effects really pan out for the student guinea pigs. I also quite like the taste of Kenco medium roast, and feel that water certainly improves it.

Comments and Opinions:
"Concerns" by Zoe
Posted: 13:17 GMT, Fri 12th February 2010
Modafinil is often obtained over the net without proper medical guidance. Users are therefore often unaware of potential side-effects. Not that much of a problem - except that the drug decreases the effectiveness of hormonal birth control methods. I don't think that the potential distress of unwanted pregnancy or the trauma of abortion is going to help one's concentration and performance overall.
"rick the prick" by guavaya grace
Posted: 21:20 GMT, Mon 8th February 2010
wow! brilliant article Joe! xxx
"Stimulants" by Calochilus
Posted: 00:03 GMT, Sat 6th February 2010
Broadly, the level of "misuse" of stimulants approximates the estimated incidence rate of ADHD (as opposed to the diagnostic rate) You might well have asked "Is illicit stimulant usage a sign of undiagnosed or untreated ADHD" Your disparaging comments on "productivity" cannot be borne out by experience, subjective or objective. Crawl back under your rock.
"Modanifil aka "Provigil"" by Rick
Posted: 15:37 GMT, Fri 5th February 2010
The conclusion that the substances provide a "pinched, unromantic, grindingly efficient form of productivity" was obviously contrived by those who have never experienced modanafil. A heightened dimension of "creativity" is unleashed, which far exceeds mere "productivity". Howerver, both productivity and creativity are subjective terms. Is there any imperical evidence to support these claims?
 
Your email address:
Name:
Comment subject:
Your comment: (max length: 400 chars.)

characters left
Security verification: (Enter the code in the box below)



MOST DISCUSSED THIS WEEK
C2 HIGHLIGHTS
COMMENT AND WORLD

Pick up your copy of Bang! this week
© 2008 Oxford Student Publications Ltd.
Design by Henry Clarke Price, Chris Baraniuk and Adam Hadley
About Us | Get in touch | Send us news | Advertise | RSS Feeds