Cherwell.org - Student news and reviews at Oxford University
Tuesday 9th February, 2010
Cherwell Isis
Magdalen JCR changes name to Gryffindor

by Natalya Segrove | 00:17 GMT, Mon 23 November 2009

Photo: Cherwell

Magdalen College JCR has voted to rename itself as Gryffindor in the JCR meeting on Sunday. It will be referred to as such in "all official documents".

JCR President Laurence Mills has also been mandated to contact the JCR Presidents of Christ Church, St. Hugh's and Merton informing that they should rename their common rooms Slytherin, Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw respectively.

The motion, which was passed in the JCR's General Meeting with only six votes in opposition, was proposed by third-year Zoe Tyndall. It noted that, "Magdalen College embodies the values of courage, daring, nerve and chivalry", the characteristics of the Gryffindor house in Harry Potter novels.

Tyndall said, "Magdalen college JCR embodies the exact same values as Gryffindor house at Hogwarts."

She added, "We found the resemblance between Hufflepuff and St Hugh's to be particularly strong - they are, as the motion reads, ‘particularly good finders'. The amount of ‘pure wizarding blood' at Christ Church is overwhelming, and our only conclusion was that they should be called Slytherin."

Matthew Shribman, the third year who originally raised the idea during his JCR presidential bid last week commented, "It's not a question of whether we should rename to Gryffindor, it's whether we should accept that we are Gryffindor."

During the debate on the motion, several amendments were suggested. One would have mandated the JCR President to write to the college President, Professor David Clary, asking if he would change his name to Albus Dumbledore.

Only one speech was made in opposition, and this was to suggest that the motion be changed to mandate the purchase of a sorting hat.

However, the opposition was withdrawn when a friendly amendment was added to the motion, stating that a sorting hat should be purchased. Matt Bilton, who proposed the amendment commented, "I think most of the JCR present agreed that a sorting hat was definitely necessary."

Suggestions that this could become part of the admissions process across the University of Oxford were rejected on the grounds that it could be difficult to implement.

Student reactions to the name change were very positive. First-year Suzie Harrogate commented that she was "quite ecstatic about the whole situation" as she had "always wanted to go to Hogwarts."

Tom Meakin, President-Elect of Magdalen JCR commented, "Magdalen does after all look a little bit like Hogwarts, and not to put any noses out of joint, but my Vice-President does look a little bit like Hagrid."

 

Page last updated: 2009-11-22 17:52:17
Comments and Opinions:
"QUICK! " by Evil Genius
Posted: 10:54 GMT, Thu 3rd December 2009
Some other JCR should change their name to "Magdalen" and then they can't change back, and the daft buggers will be stuck as Gryffindor for the foreseeable future! You can't have two with the same name, so force them to stick with it!
"The Telegraph fell for it" by Jay Schlackman
Posted: 22:12 GMT, Wed 25th November 2009
Good to see British journalism at it's finest: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/6645309/Oxford-University-changes-common-room-name-to-Harry-Potters-Gryffindor.html
"Smooce" by Dumbledore's Grundle
Posted: 07:52 GMT, Wed 25th November 2009
This reminds me of the time Eton briefly changed their name to "Camp North Star," based on the 1979 screwball comedy "Meatballs," starring Bill Murray. Don't worry, it aint gonna last...
"Ha" by Tom Riddle
Posted: 00:37 GMT, Wed 25th November 2009
You should have a look at the love Magdalen is getting on some other websites.
"???" by H
Posted: 11:10 GMT, Tue 24th November 2009
What does "particularly good finders" mean, exactly?
"Legal risk?" by Jaani
Posted: 22:47 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Considering that Ms Rowling's publisher recently threatened legal action against a mother who sought to host a Potter-themed Halloween party, this can't go unnoticed: http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/world/single-mum-who-planned-harry-potter-themed-halloween-party-threatened-with-legal-action-by-hollywood-studio/story-e6frf7lf-1225791589195. One can only hope.
"Chill out" by Tom Riddle
Posted: 21:56 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Stop being so precocious and chill out. They won't actually change the name...it was a joke motion. It took about 15 minutes or so of a General Meeting and literally no one in the room took it as seriously as you. It seem that some people have their sense of humour confiscated at Matriculation.
"Chill out" by Tom Riddle
Posted: 21:54 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
For goodness sake there will be no 'revert to Magdalen JCR' campaign because they won't actually change the name. It was a joke motion...it took up 15 minutes or so of a General Meeting and nobody in the room actually thought it was serious. Clearly some people have their sense of humour confiscated at Matriculation. Stop being so precocious and chill out.
"Chill out" by Tom Riddle
Posted: 21:44 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
For goodness sake there will be no campaign to revert back to Magd JCR because they won't actually change the name. It was a joke motion...it took 15 minutes or so of a General Meeting and it was fun. Apparently some people have their sense of humour confiscated at matriculation. Stop being so precocious and chill out.
"Constitution" by Patrick
Posted: 19:48 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
I'm fairly sure that renaming the JCR to Gryffindor in all official documentation requires constitutional amendment which, whilst it got the 2/3 vote needed in the JCR, would also require the SCR to approve the change in the constitution. So, really all the new JCR President has to do is wait for the SCR to reject the amendment and this story will soon disappear. Still, it is quite funny...
"Hmm..." by Washington Irving
Posted: 18:43 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
I'm curious as to how long they'll keep up with this bit of fun before they become bored of it, or get fed up of people trying to stifle derisive laughter in "Griffindor" meetings... I can see "change it back to Magdalen JCR" being a campaigning point in the near future...
"Durmstrang" by John from Magdalene
Posted: 18:30 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Does that mean we need to change our JCR name to Durmstrang?
"Err" by Suzanne M
Posted: 17:03 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Come on you guys....this is surely an absurd way to use your exaggerated brain cell allocation?
"No" by Tom Riddle
Posted: 16:11 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
No she won't sue because I'm pretty sure she can recognise a joke. Unlike Alex.
"It's finally time to murder the lot of them" by Fr. Robert
Posted: 16:02 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
When I were a lad, we renamed one of the JCR rooms after an 11th c. leader of the Albigenses. Admittedly, we got the name wrong, but at least we tried to be interesting, unlike the cloud of quasi-literate bottom- feeders who apparently populate the college now. St. Edmund Hall should send over a shipment of scarves, smeared with some kind of lethal contact poison, and do in the lot of them. Alas.
"lol" by Al
Posted: 15:03 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
I wonder if Rowling will sue...
"Gryffindor?" by Anyssa
Posted: 14:03 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Most definitely Slytherin! Such a misnomer would be a stain on the good name of Hogwarts - a travesty!
"A time-honoured tradition..." by Rosie
Posted: 13:52 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Even the brightest and best are allowed to have a little fun Alex! And I'd say that standards are being rigorously adhered to - I believe Oscar Wilde was chiefly noted for his sense of humour, as was Dudley Moore, another distinguished Magdalenite...
""Sense of Humour (TM)"" by Steve
Posted: 11:23 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Don't be such a "joyless stain", Alex.
"Anachronism" by Will
Posted: 09:08 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Please could the writer of this article deal with various anachronisms - references to 'Magdalen JCR' are reasonable for references before the passing of this, but sentences such as 'Tom Meakin, President-Elect of Magdalen JCR' should be edited to 'Tom Meakin, President-Elect of Gryffindor'
"Gryffindor?" by Andy
Posted: 08:53 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
I'd have put them down as Slytherin, to be honest . . .
"Country's Brightest Young Minds(TM)" by Alex
Posted: 08:08 GMT, Mon 23rd November 2009
Good to see the intellectual powerhouse that brought us Lord Denning, Baron Browne-Wilkinson, Ronald Dworkin, John Florio, and Oscar Wilde (amongst many distinguished others) is keeping up its rigorous standards.
 
Your email address:
Name:
Comment subject:
Your comment: (max length: 400 chars.)

characters left
Security verification: (Enter the code in the box below)



For the Love of FilmSaturday 12:45Matters Scientific
MOST DISCUSSED THIS WEEK
C2 HIGHLIGHTS
COMMENT AND WORLD

Isis
© 2008 Oxford Student Publications Ltd.
Design by Henry Clarke Price, Chris Baraniuk and Adam Hadley
About Us | Get in touch | Send us news | Advertise | RSS Feeds