Cherwell.org - Student news and reviews at Oxford University
Tuesday 9th February, 2010
Cherwell Isis
Tony Benn joins animal lab protest

by Clare Kane | 19:17 GMT, Thu 20 November 2008

Photo: VERO

Former Labour politician Tony Benn has spoken out this week against the new animal laboratory in Oxford.

Benn met with fellow Oxford alumni Sir David Madden, and the Voice for Ethical Research group in Oxford (VERO) on Monday to express his concerns about the lab.

Benn, who studied PPE at New College, told VERO, "I have always been a believer in animal rights. There is now a lot of strong evidence that animal testing is not necessary, and could be done in a different way."

Benn has spoken out against animal testing saying, "the tide is turning fast against those who still cling on to the view that experimentation and testing of drugs on animals is valid and necessary."

Animal campaigners at the event on Monday wore academic dress to highlight the existence of what they believe is a large anti-laboratory sentiment within the University itself.

The University has insisted that the new lab will improve the welfare of lab animals. The new building will rehouse animals that were previously scattered around various buildings and to "set a gold star for animal care."

John Hood said, "Where animals are needed in research, we are committed to the highest standards of care. That is why we have built this new facility.

"The fact that we have completed it in difficult circumstances reflects the depth of our commitment both to life-saving research and to animal care."

The first mice have been moved into the laboratory on South Parks Road and it will become fully operational in 2009.
Yet the university has insisted that testing will not take place.

Animals will be bred, trained to complete computer-based tasks, receive medication, undergo MRI scans and some will be operated on.

The issue divides students and staff across the University. One student, who wishes to remain anonymous said, "I'm completely against the lab and outraged that Oxford would partake in such controversial activities."

However another student admitted, "sentiment needs to be outweighed at some point, overall, finding a cure for something like HIV is too important."

Oxford claim they support peaceful protest and discussion, but find the "intimidation, threats, damage to property, and arson" the University has been subjected to "entirely unacceptable."

Some students have expressed anger at noisy and possibly dangerous protests, with one saying, "These protests are futile. Let's face it, no one wants to do it, no one says ‘Let's torture animals.' Scientists want to help us."

 

Comments and Opinions:
"Sentiment within University" by James
Posted: 15:29 GMT, Wed 3rd December 2008
It is simply not the case that there 'is a large anti-laboratory sentiment within the University' as Vero suggest. Numerous polls, including both an OUSU and Cherwell one have shown there to be overwhelming support for animal research within the university. It remains a vital method in developing lifesaving treatments and the improved conditions the new lab will provide can only be positive.
"Benn's visit, etc." by Dr David Mitchell
Posted: 15:22 GMT, Fri 21st November 2008
Of course an answer to HIV/AIDs is needed, but like all other illnesses, the solution doesn't lie in vivisection, e.g., 'A clinical trial testing the effectiveness of...a promising new HIV vaccine has ended in failure...some now doubt that tests on animals will ever produce a vaccine that will be effective in humans.' 'Clinical trial for HIV vaccine fails', The Times, 13 November 2008.
 
Your email address:
Name:
Comment subject:
Your comment: (max length: 400 chars.)

characters left
Security verification: (Enter the code in the box below)



No MinisterFor the Love of FilmMatters Scientific
MOST DISCUSSED THIS WEEK
C2 HIGHLIGHTS
COMMENT AND WORLD

Isis
© 2008 Oxford Student Publications Ltd.
Design by Henry Clarke Price, Chris Baraniuk and Adam Hadley
About Us | Get in touch | Send us news | Advertise | RSS Feeds